Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 38.
(continued from page 3)
…would spread over Palestine. When Soskin, in support of this hope, appeals to the example of the German plantation companies in the colonies, this very comparison seems to me mistaken. The German plantation companies are purely capitalistic undertakings of people who live in Germany and mean to go on living there, and who have but the one aim of drawing dividends as fat as possible out of the plantations. For this purpose they have at their disposal, in the negroes, numerous forced labourers, who receive of the yield of their labour only so much, or so little, as is necessary for existence — for the existence of a negro slave. Apart from the officials and the overseers, Germans have found their bread in all the German colonies together only in a quite vanishing number.
For every new plantation company in Palestine, therefore, the whole of the requisite capital would have to be raised anew.
But should the enormous capitals really be brought together in this manner, in consequence of the proved profitableness, so as to cover the whole country with a network of plantation companies, the result would be a land full of Jewish day-labourers doing bond-service in the employ of foreign capitalists without hope of independence. A Mizrajim in Palestine!
Otherwise would the conditions shape themselves in a rural productive co-operative according to Oppenheimer's proposals.
Let us assume that a financier comes to an understanding for the lending of a million francs upon conditions to be discussed later. With this capital, which according to Soskin would be used up in settling about 70 day-labourers, the procedure would be as follows: Some 250—300 ha. (1000—1200 Morgen) of land are purchased, which is not to consist exclusively of first-class and medium-good soil. If the financier is at the same time a landed proprietor, the land furnished by him is reckoned at its full capital value. The remaining part of the capital he gives in the shape of stock, of plantings such as trees, etc., and, to a relatively small extent, in cash as working capital, chiefly for wages.
Out of the labourers to be settled — the 100 day-labourers at present without bread would come into consideration first — an association is now formed, which remains owner of the soil and works it in common. At its head is placed, as director, a first-class agricultural expert with far-reaching powers in the technical respect. This expert director, who receives, as is expedient, a relatively small fixed salary and relatively high percentages, employs the settlers like ordinary farm labourers. They stand in the pay of the co-operative formed by themselves; they have to perform the work which the director assigns to them; and the co-operative element in the matter is only this, that the yield is divided in proportion to the work performed.
For the common agricultural working, the better part of the soil is naturally reserved. What shall be planted upon it, the expert director has to determine independently, and is therein limited only by the right of co-determination which must be conceded to the financier so long as he is still financially interested in the foundation. Only, the chief articles of consumption of the colony's own territory (grain, vegetables, fodder, olives, fruit, etc.) would have to be taken into account at once from the beginning. Articles of export, such as wine, raisins, almonds, come only in the second line.
The financial direction is to be entrusted, separately from the agricultural, to a capable and expert financial man, or it may be to a board. Here the influence to be reserved to the financier may even be a preponderating one.
The least productive part of the soil is, at the very beginning of operations, surveyed with a view to the laying out of a town plan and divided into small building plots of about half a Morgen. Every settler has to erect upon such a building plot a small family house and to lay out a small garden, for which the financier advances to the first colonists the necessary building money at interest. Later a co-operative bank, still to be founded, takes his place. For the half Morgen of land a rent is to be paid to the co-operative which may not be higher than the burden of interest borne by the latter for it, and therefore, according to the land prices in Palestine, hardly more than one mark a year.
Upon the same conditions the handicraftsmen and the industrial or trade labourers receive their building plot for dwelling-house and garden, as well as for the necessary trade installations. For the handicraftsmen, etc., there is to be no compulsion to combine; Oppenheimer assumes, however, that with growing opportunity for work the logic of facts would of itself lead the trade and industrial undertakers to the formation of combinations. If, for example, a smith had work so abundant that the settling of a second appeared remunerative, both would very soon perceive that they can work more advantageously in common, because with a better utilisation of the ground and of the installations the yield of labour would be doubled, but not the burden of interest for ground, capital and working material. The new acquisition would consist, not in a second smithy, but at first only in a new anvil and a few other tools. And with the further enlargement of the colony, and therewith of the opportunity for work, the industrial combination, with its growing number of participants, would sooner than the individual be in a position, by the acquisition of more perfect machinery, the purchase of raw products on a large scale, etc., to diminish the costs of production, thereby to increase the profit, and even to conquer neighbouring markets for one or another product. At this stage it would already be out of the question that single undertakings should be able to maintain themselves beside the collective undertaking. It must, however, still be added, for the understanding of these considerations, that there are of course no assistants in a dependent position, through whose exploitation the individual master could procure for himself alone the advantages of the large undertaking; for every labourer who comes in must become an associate with an equivalent share, or it stands free to him to demand land and an advance and to set up for himself.
Let us, however, return once more to the "primary formation" of the agricultural co-operative, in order to see, at least in broad outline, what the probable course of development according to Oppenheimer would be:
Each of the 100 colonists has assigned to him by the director the work corresponding to his knowledge and capacities. For this he receives out of the working fund the daily wages usual in the place, as an advance upon his share of the profits. That he should thereby receive too much is not to be expected, for the colony works at the outset at any rate under no worse chances of profit than the neighbouring estates under capitalistic management, which are in a position to bear these wages.
But in several points the co-operative is nevertheless better placed: the special claims of a personal proprietor fall away. The colony enjoys the advantages of the intensive working of small peasant holdings and at the same time the advantages of the capitalistic large undertaking through purchase on a large scale, more perfect machinery, etc. Of especial weight, however, is the fact that the labourers know from the outset that they are working for their own advantage, that over and above their wages they receive paid out to them at the end of the financial year the entire net profit remaining after the deduction of all charges, pro rata of the hours of work performed. "From the moment in which this Ver-