Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 35 · 30 August 1901
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 35.

(continued from page 3)

. . . cealed it, that even the antisemites cannot sniff it out upon us."

"Zionism gives to the Jewish proletariat, the most wretched and most unhappy of all proletariats, the sound foundation upon which it can successfully exert its power of labour."

"What sort of gibberish is that? With us there is no Jewish proletariat. We are doing quite well, and whoever will work will in any case spin silk far more easily in Germany, France and so forth than in the wildernesses of Palestine or in other fine regions back yonder, far away, in Turkey, where the peoples come to blows with one another."

It is unnecessary to continue this dialogue. It turns in a circle and gets no further, cannot get further. Zionism is a matter of reason in the measure in which, say, the three-dimensional geometry of Euclid is. That too has postulates which cannot be proved. Zionism likewise has a postulate that is unattainable to rational proof, because it holds sway in the sphere of feeling. The presupposition of Zionism is Jewish feeling, pride in the history of the Jewish people, the wish for a further historical development of the venerable ancient stock. Where this presupposition is wanting, there Zionism is neither to be defended nor to be comprehended. It must appear senseless and unacceptable.

From this results the method according to which alone the Zionist idea can be advocated among assimilated Jews. It is of no use to argue with the mature Jews who have completely unlearnt how to feel as Jews, and who live in a settled asemitic or even antisemitic view of the world. It is a squandering of time and of strength if we would convince and convert these elements with rational proofs. What matters is to create Jewish feeling. For feelings too are created. They are an effect of education, of early influences upon the mind, but quite especially of example. By these forces one makes out of the Jewish child Mortara a deeply believing Catholic priest, feeling as a Christian with Jewish sentimentality, and out of the sons of immigrant Polish ghetto Jews crisp-haired Teutons who find that "a certain kernel of truth cannot be denied to antisemitism." With these forces one can make good Jews once more out of the descendants of assimilated deserters from the stock, wholly estranged from Jewry, and that the more easily, for even in the most rotted and most undermined Jewish soul there are always still a few square centimetres of firm ground where one can build, in order to raise, with the overgrown, half-weathered rubble of old memories that lies scattered about, a new edifice of Jewish thinking and feeling.

The thing, then, is to work upon the youth, if possible upon childhood already. That this is easy I do not maintain. We have against us the resistance of the parents, the influences of the family and of the school. In Germany the forming of societies is not permitted in the gymnasia, and at the university the influence of the Jewish students' associations frequently comes too late already. Nevertheless zeal and enthusiasm for the great cause, tough perseverance and a certain resourcefulness always find means and ways of penetrating in good time into the Jewish family citadel, upon whose ring-wall a sharp lookout is kept against us. Here Jewish art and belles-lettres have a great part to play. Jewish novels, dramas and poems, paintings and sculptures of a high order do more for the kindling of Jewish feeling in young souls than any systematic instruction of the understanding, however convincing it may seem to us. The latter only comes into its right when Jewish strivings and longings already pre-exist in the feeling. Unhappily we are still very deficient in these means of educating Jewish souls. For what was created many generations of men ago has no living value for the most modern of recipients, and in the last two or three generations all our talents have forsaken Jewry and have laboured with all their might at the de-Judaising of their fellow-tribesmen. A Lilien and a Nossig in art, a Grünau and a Zlocisti in lyric poetry, a Viola, a Rosa Pomeranz, a Robert Jaffé in the novel, signify excellent and promising beginnings, upon whose development under the influence of the new Zionist life we may set our hopes.

The most important thing, however, remains the example. We work educatively by the mere fact that we are. Nothing surpasses the propagandist force of the spectacle of earnest, irreproachable, cultivated men, whose conduct of life defies every slander and puts every mockery to shame, living and working for the Zionist ideal without letting themselves be discouraged by indifference, disconcerted by scorn, or agitated by the fury of enemies. A group of men that fulfils these requirements makes its way, be it never so small at the beginning. It need only endure; the first successes may perhaps be long in coming. But once they do appear, then they grow after the formula of the snowball undertakings.

Zionism cannot renounce the West, although its Jews seem wholly lost to Jewry. The army of the Zionists recruits itself naturally in the East. But a great part of its corps of officers must come to it out of the West. For officers can grow up for it only out of such Jewish popular elements as have developed in freedom, have raised themselves to prosperity, and have drunk from all the springs of modern culture. Such elements, however, are to be found in any frequency only in the lands of equal rights.

I will not be deprived of seeing even an advantage for our movement, at least in its beginnings, in the fact that Western Jewry on the whole bears itself toward us with the extremest coldness and in part with abrupt hostility. In this way we are certain that the few Zionists who come over to us out of these circles are the result of a severe selection. The Zionists of the West are neither ghetto place-hunters nor réclame-tigers, neither petty profit-makers nor speculators, neither vain camp-followers nor parrots, such as they may be there where Zionism has already become a matter of the people and of the majority; they are pure idealists, undaunted men of the minority, and natures of strength of the hardest national grain. They are survivors in a sharp moral struggle for existence, in which the weaker have gone under nationally. They are individualities whose hidden, inherited racial and national substructure is exceptionally firmly knit. But of such a make must the men be who are to lead the Zionist multitude of the East upon its ways and in its struggles.

Whoever should have read out of these expositions that I already regard Western Jewry as fallen away would not have understood me rightly. Certainly it is upon the road to apostasy, and this will become final if no national renewal leads those who have strayed back to their stock. But the Vita nuova of Zionism can save them for Jewry. It will assuredly save them for Jewry, once it comes to realisation.

For let us be just: we may demand of the average man, and therefore of the average Jew also, neither heroism nor a rich visionary imagination. Both are exceptional gifts. The ordinary Jew today, in the lands where he has at least a tolerable security of person and of property, can picture to himself nothing whatever other than his present circumstances. The law defines him as a German citizen of the state. He has a