Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 19 · 10 May 1901
6printed page
scan 6 of 16

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 19.

(continued from page 5)

…awakened in me memories of the many-thousand-year-old sufferings of your race. I must herewith confess, to my deepest shame, that my fellow-Christians have through centuries disregarded the teachings of Christ, in that they persecuted the ancient people of God in the most barbarous fashion." Passing on to the accusations which at the most various times have been raised against the Jews, he cited the word of a famous bishop who called out to the enemies of the Jews: "Whatever the Jews may be, it is you who have made them so! You despise the Jews because they are usurers and dealers in old clothes: that they are such lies upon your conscience!" Bishop Potter then related to the assembly an occurrence which had befallen him upon his latest journey through Europe. While he was travelling through Holland he became absorbed in Heine's "Buch der Lieder." After a considerable while a lady who shared his compartment said to him, in the course of conversation, that he might well be proud to belong to the race of that great prince of poets. He answered that, so far as he knew, Heinrich Heine had been no American. Thereupon an astonished shaking of the head on the part of his fellow-traveller, whom he could convince only with hard labour that he was no Jew… Upon Zionism Bishop Potter expressed himself as follows: "I heard your speaker tell of two parties in Jewry: the national Zionists, and those Jews who regard themselves as belonging to the lands wherein they dwell, and whose ideal is love of the fatherland. Even at the risk of wounding the feelings of many of you, I tell it you straight out: I am no Zionist! If I understand the matter rightly, the Zionists desire that Jewish men and Jewish women should pack their knapsacks and, forsaking the peoples in whose midst they have hitherto lived, should found a home of their own. I cry out to you: Do not that! You form a very valuable constituent of our body of people, and one hard to be spared, even though you have your own, perhaps not always agreeable, racial peculiarities. Strive rather with all your might to make America your Zion, the land of promise and of the Jewish ideals!"

Of the remaining speakers of the evening there are to be singled out: the Rev. Dr. Samuel Schulmann, who called for the support of the "Alliance," and Mr. Nissim Behar, the emissary of the "Alliance," who spoke upon the Palestinian work of the "All. Isr. Univ." and illustrated his lecture with stereopticon views from the Jewish colonies of Palestine, every single one of which was stormily acclaimed.

In conclusion our valiant comrade in sentiment the Rev. Masliansky rose and defended the Zionist standpoint in an excellent Jargon speech. As against Bishop Potter he pointed out that, if the patriotism of the German-Americans may not be called in question notwithstanding the existence of a great and mighty Germany, neither may the American Jews be accused of a want of love for the fatherland merely because they labour for their Zionist ideal.

Jul. Z.

The Questions of the Physical, Intellectual and Economic Raising of the Jews.

On the Question of Raising the Economic Condition of the Jews in Galicia.

Concerning the relief action to be undertaken by the "Bnei Brith" in favour of the Jews of Galicia the following is reported: It is above all to be ascertained by statistics how many persons in need of help are present in each several community. Then a definite sum of money will be fixed for each community, which shall be devoted once for all to this purpose. And now the distribution is to proceed in such wise that the families to be assisted shall be divided into two categories: into such as are suited to a domestic industry, and such as must be helped in some other manner. To the latter loans free of interest would be granted, which they would have to repay in small instalments. Therewith the poorest could undertake something, so as to be able in this way to gain their livelihood. The repaid loans shall be granted out again periodically; dilatory debtors, on the other hand, shall be proceeded against at law, and the insolvent spared.

As regards, now, the families with grown-up children of both sexes, these shall be drawn into the domestic industry. In every Jewish community the requisite working machines are to be provided, in every community a teacher is to be engaged who shall duly teach the people the handling of the machine, and then — then let opportunity of work be procured for them, and they would be helped.

One might almost be inclined to the view that this relief action, of however problematical a nature it may otherwise be, has a claim to success. Yet already upon closer consideration the untenableness of such a plan is manifest. One may cherish no illusion upon that point. The misery of the Jews in Galicia is so great, the distress has already assumed such dimensions, that the material means of the "Bnei Brith" would hardly suffice to bring about a temporary alleviation, let alone a lasting remedy. We do not believe we go too far in assuming that more than the half of all the Galician Jews — to make use of an expression of Birnbaum's — belong to the beggar and prayer proletariate and languish in misery and want. If we now set the strength of a family at five persons, the number of families which would have a claim upon the support of the "Bnei Brith" would be 80,000. At a minimum of existence of 400 Kr. yearly, the capital to be invested would have to yield a yearly return of 32 million Kronen. What a prodigious sum — and withal how low the number of those to be supported has been reckoned, and how low the minimum of existence!

For this reason alone there can be no talk of an action embracing the whole body of the Jewish proletarians in Galicia. An action would therefore have to confine itself to a definite number of families. And what would this signify, having regard to the giant misery of the Galician Jews? A drop in an ocean! Nevertheless the range of such an action is not to be underrated. It would still not have to be left undone merely because the help could not be brought to all at once. In general, indeed, such a task as the combating of the Jewish distress in Galicia cannot be solved in the turning of a hand. Thereto belong much time, much toil and above all much money. And thus at least a beginning would have been made. But apart from this circumstance, yet other misgivings arise against a relief action in the above sense.

A lasting remedy, the raising of the economic level and of the material condition, cannot in our opinion be effected in Galicia by the introduction of the domestic industry and by the raising of handicraft and the drawing of men into it. Even in general the domestic industry, at the present state of industrial technique and with the perfection and the diffusion of the machine, has no possibility of existence at all, or at most one limited to a short time. What misery does not already prevail in most of the regions in which the domestic industry is a long-established branch of livelihood? And surely now no man will wish to undertake, with so doubtful a means, an experiment which is only in the future to bear fruit. Even though it be indisputable that certain conditions for it are given in Galicia, such as superfluous labouring hands, which are to be had cheaply, still these are not all, or at least not the most important, of the presuppositions of a domestic industry. It is precisely this surplus of unemployed labour power that harbours within itself the greatest danger for the domestic industry in the future.

Cheap labour power forms an attraction for the great industry, and if this sooner or later makes its entry into Galicia, that cheapness will stand it in very good stead. Such phenomena show themselves oftentimes in Russia. If a domestic industry is to be of lasting duration, then the presuppositions for an industry must be wanting. Otherwise there would simply be no necessity present