Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 16 · 19 April 1901
5printed page
scan 5 of 16

No. 16. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

...knock where one will, one will find them in throngs, the representatives of Jewry who acquit themselves with credit, far beyond the percentage that would fall to them by the statistical average. And if that be so, how is the axiom of the physical inferiority of the Jews still to be maintained?!

Every effect has of course its cause, and so there is a reason too why that axiom came to be set up and accepted. I believe that the motive here has proceeded from a confusion of ideas. One sees in general more Jewish stunting and more Jewish physical misery than statistics would have any right to demand, and hence the opinion — which is not thereby made any the more correct. What we see there is not the physical inferiority of Jewry, but poverty, fear, care, under-nourishment. Go into the Erzgebirge, or into any other famine region, and you will find there just as sad a physical inferiority of Christendom. For Jewry the whole world is a famine region, and in any case an inhospitable one. Of course! I shall again have the fatted Jewish bankers and the revelling stock-jobbers held up to me. Apart from the fact that the stock-jobbers have for a considerable time past done no revelling, let it be pointed out once more, superfluous though it be, that it is an ancient injustice to judge a whole people by certain exceptional appearances which are never visible save upon the surface of metropolitan currents. It is not what thus floats upon the surface that characterises Jewry and the Jewish distress, not the upper ten thousand, but the lower millions who drag out their oppressed existence in Galicia, in Russia, in Roumania. There, among all else, much physical misery reigns also; but that, be it repeated, is not the typical misery of a people or of a race, but of pitiable poverty. Wherever in the world pauperism weighs upon the masses, precisely the same appearances of bodily degeneration make themselves felt. It cannot possibly be otherwise.

If one surveys all these conditions more closely, one will arrive at an opinion the very opposite of the current axiom of inferiority. One will be forced to find that it can be no bad race which has shown such tenacity in the endurance of hunger and want, and which after a Tschandala existence of several thousand years has not sunk lower still. There is no instance of a people that has displayed a greater power of resistance, the physical included.

The objection that physical inferiority is to be demonstrated among many well-to-do Jewish families as well is not fitted to support the crooked axiom in its generality. Here too there is nothing typically Jewish. More frequently than among other stocks it happens among the Jewish that single individuals, by natural intelligence and talent, work their way up rapidly out of the deepest poverty to considerable property. The children may then indeed inherit the property, but the curse of the bitter poverty of the earlier generations clings to them. For that the race as such is not to blame; it is so with all. Rich, to be sure, the original elements of the possessing classes of other peoples may not have been either; but a difference must after all be made between the circumstances of life of an ordinary peasant stock, poor though it be, and those of an immense proletariat hunted everywhere throughout the wide Diaspora.

And one thing more. Culture, which creates life and flowering, shatters also. It demands its price, and the price is dear; it tells upon the nerves, which it refines and thereby impairs. Culture raises peoples up and it brings them down again. It too has its ages of life, and it too is not spared senile marasmus. The better, because younger, Germanic nerves have triumphed over the Romance culture. Who knows whether the future does not belong to the Slavonic element, and whether this will not then in its turn fall a victim to a fresh invasion out of Asia? When once the gates of the Chinese walls open and the great outpouring follows — it were idle to paint that picture of the future. One is involuntarily led into such digressions when one keeps before one's eyes how the immemorial Jewish culture has, as it were, maintained itself in the interstices of all the world-historical upheavals. It has maintained itself, but it could not be that it remained without influence upon the nerves of its confessors.

The old culture and the old misery have torn at the Jewish nerve-strands, and much fault of their own has come in besides. Nowhere else is the fateful, deplorable and damnable marriage among kinsfolk so much in vogue as among the Jews. The evil may have its psychological and its material grounds; it is to be condemned nevertheless. It rages against their own flesh and blood more than all the other thousand-year distress has been able to do. And if now, in spite of all this and all that, the race still proves itself of full worth beside the others, that speaks for how well founded it was from the first.

We have seen that, judged by its highest points, the physical capacity of the Jews is a good one. It is possible that a statistical inquiry into the matter would show a bad average. No proof against the race would thereby be furnished. The immense majority of the Jews live in the bitterest poverty, and everywhere poverty is the source of physical inferiority. For that reason no particular success is to be looked for from the propaganda for the cultivation of bodily exercises. For among the well-to-do strata such a propaganda is no longer needed. Well-off Jewish circles even now do at least as much in this direction, if not more, than the others; and the immeasurable mass of the poor simply cannot. They have quite other cares than to acquire by gymnastics a healthy appetite which they cannot then satisfy. If the ideal endeavour to which these pages are devoted be fulfilled, if land, light, air, freedom, labour and livelihood one day fall to their lot, then only will it appear what was to be thought of the fable of physical inferiority.

The Questions of the Physical, Intellectual and Economic Improvement of the Jews.

Degeneration and Regeneration.

II.

The Economic Condition of the Russian Jews.

By S. Chaikis.

In my last article I treated in detail only one of the principal causes which bring about the physical, intellectual and moral degeneration of the "Ghetto Jews."

Since the abuses of the Cheder have already been discussed many times, and in the most excellent manner, in our Hebrew and Russo-Jewish publicistic writing (by P. Smolensky and L. Lewanda, for example), I believed I might content myself with unrolling before the honoured reader in broad outline a truthful picture of the Russian Cheder system, in the conviction that this brief indication would suffice to spur the friends of our people to the combating of this evil.

To-day, however, I have set myself a considerably more difficult task, in that another principal cause of the