Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 9.
"Do you entertain any apprehensions for the future in respect of antisemitism?" the interviewer inquired further.
"On the contrary," replied the arch-humorist. "I am an optimist and expect from the future a revival of the former favourable conditions . . . The Fatherland cannot dispense with the Jews . . . We may be without anxiety for our future . . . Antisemitism has been placed upon the list of things dying out . . . The people is too good-natured to be able to take pleasure much longer in religious intolerance."
Dr. Güdemann summed up at last unctuously: "Mortal powers can do us no harm, neither in Austria nor elsewhere. Consider us, consider our houses, our synagogues. Look at our domestic, our commercial, our public life, our charitable institutions and our educational establishments, and tell me whether you can perceive any signs of decomposition. I cannot, thank God, I cannot."
. . . Outside, meanwhile, it was dull and foggy. Far and wide no Zola there. Merrily the germs of antisemitism ran riot. A Jewish pedlar was soundly cudgelled by a good-natured, pleasure-loving Viennese of the common people. Dr. Güdemann sank into a dreaming state. He dreamed of his decoration and of the future of the Jewish people. Suddenly the heavens brightened, and through heavy cloud there broke victoriously the golden shimmer of the sun. All the germs of antisemitism withered in a trice. And behold! Highly amused, Dr. Lueger fell upon Dr. Güdemann's neck. The two jesters had indeed been taken far too seriously . . .
M. Z.
Yet a Word upon "Jewish Realpolitik".*)
By Dr. Ph. Menczel.
A discussion in which only two pens take part has always the awkward quality that it ends by degenerating into a duel of articles. That certainly did not lie in my intention when, in No. 4 of this paper, I advanced and sought to establish the assertion that there is no Jewish national policy outside of or beside Zionism, but rather that Jewish national policy and Zionism are reciprocal conceptions. Of that variety which calls itself "Realpolitik" and likewise lays claim to the epithet "national" I made mention only in passing, and I did not expect that of all men a soi disant orthodox Zionist would step into the arena. The Zionists with whom the Jewish thought of a homeland has not yet sunk into an unsubstantial semblance have understood me. My exposition was addressed to our "Jewish-national" friends, whom I had hoped to move to join political Zionism, as that tendency which alone is wholly and fully Jewish-national. What, then, did I say? I pointed out that what calls itself Jewish real- or national policy is really only social policy — notabene something highly laudable — but that — I believed I had shown it convincingly — Jewish national policy is solely and alone Zionism. Of the assertions and arguments which I then brought into the field I withdraw to-day not a single word.
To my no small astonishment there presented himself as the first and, up to this hour, only counter-speaker a gentleman who maintains that he is a strictly believing Zionist, and who comes forward for his phantom, which he calls Realpolitik, with a passion that were worthy of a better cause. In the first article Dr. Mayer Ebner identified Realpolitik with huckstering politics, and sought to exalt these into the most effectual means for the winning of "full equality of rights and equality of worth." When I replied that this most remarkable of all political dogmas stands in crass contradiction to the clear Zionist argumentation, and that there are hindrances which do not permit even such an exploitation — one not agreeable to a finer taste — of the political rights standing at the disposal of the Jews, Dr. Mayer Ebner urges in a second article that I am afraid of the District Captains. Well, in this respect I can set the gentleman opponent at ease: I for my person do not fear the District Captain; I do not even fear those who believe that with
*) Cf. Nos. 4, 6 and 8.
huckstering politics they can wear down the Galician District Captain. I have merely described conditions as they are and as for an incalculable time they must remain. I am myself a Galician Jew and presume to possess in this field a knowledge of the matter which people who know Galicia only from hearsay must needs lack. But neither do I play a trump card, for I have replied briefly only with reluctance, and by no means in order to confute Dr. Mayer Ebner at all costs, but only in order to bring clearness into this question according to my best knowledge.
Dr. Mayer Ebner has, however, also taken the word in order to polemise against "hired scribblers" and "people of limited horizon." The matter would not further concern me, and I should have nothing to reply to this fresh effusion of so-called Jewish Realpolitik, had it not pleased Dr. Mayer Ebner repeatedly to link his outpourings with my name. But wherefore does he fling his "huckster-political" disquisitions at my head in particular? What are the Lichts, the Auspitzes, the Rosenzweigs e tutti quanti to me, and what is the meaning of all this shadow-fencing? If Dr. Mayer Ebner believes that the salvation of Austrian Jewry lies in the "Do ut des," let him set up this political "chandler's shop" at his own cost and under his own firm, in company, if need be, with the friends to whom he appeals. I merely reserve to myself the right to enter an actio publica against the misuse of the Zionist trade-mark by the new firm. That I must do as a Zionist; for once the "Do ut des" is raised to a principle, then I do not see why the Galician Jew who votes for the man that leases him a mill, a propination, a licence to keep a tavern, a toll, etc., should not be styled a "real-" or even a "national politician." He gives (his vote) in order that there may be given to him. Consistently, then, Messrs. Licht, Auspitz and Rosenzweig are Realpolitiker too. They concede the Germans some things, the Germans concede them everything. Is that not the purest crystallised product of the "Do ut des"? The Jewish manufacturers in Bohemia and Moravia also know wherefore they vote for Wolf or Brzeznovský: Do ut des.
Now I come to the punctum saliens. Doctor Mayer Ebner will assuredly answer me: "Yes, the individual Galician Jews, the Lichts and Auspitzes, as well as the Bohemian manufacturers, pursue Realpolitik for themselves; but I and my friends desire to make Realpolitik for the Jewish community at large." To this objection I will devote a few words more, premising that I hold fast to the maxim "Quisquis praesumitur bonus," and impute to no man egoism, selfish interest and the like before I have convinced myself thereof. I assume, then, that Dr. Mayer Ebner and his friends are animated by the best intentions and desire to turn the profit of their political productive association to the general good. Now I repeat the question: What are the parties with which they mean to conclude their political trade-bargains to give them? Of the "full equality of rights and equality of worth" Dr. Mayer Ebner made no further mention with a single word in his second article, and that was right. Only the opponent let it incidentally be seen that he desires to obtain as many Jewish mandates as possible in the public representative bodies, so that interpellations, etc., may be brought forward. Good; to that two things may be replied. First, in Zionist circles not much is thought of interpellations, and experience has taught that all interpellations, protests, complaints and so forth have not helped the Jews and cannot help them. But granted the case that there are still very many Jews who feel delight when an antisemite has been "well answered," granted that the interpellations are attended with success (see the Prussian House of Deputies in the matter of the appointment of Jewish notaries!!), there still remains unanswered the second question which I raised: how many mandates does Dr. Mayer Ebner believe he will obtain through the political organisation of the Jews? I will give him the answer at once: Not a single one. The ten mandates which the Jews now dispose of in Parliament they could obtain only in the manner described by me in its time. The moment they come forward as a Jewish-national political party, no Jewish deputy will enter the Austrian Parliament. I point to the Ruthenians. These have for thirty years waged an embittered struggle against the Schlachta. Streams of blood have flowed, hundreds of Ruthenian journalists languish
