Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 6
(continued from page 1)
…first appearance of the union onward an able leader and a faithful counsellor. To the Protest Rabbis he was a dreaded opponent, against whose awe-inspiring personality and scientific authority men ventured to come forward as little as against his publicistic utterances, borne as they were by a truly Jewish spirit.
The readers and the editors of "Die Welt" value in Dr. Rülf a contributor as excellent as he is at all times welcome.
It is no exaggeration when we say that uncounted thousands will keep Dr. Rülf's seventieth birthday with him in their hearts. May it be permitted to us also to offer the venerable scholar our most heartfelt good wishes.
Are We Still Jews?
By Dr. J. Rülf (Bonn).
The analogous question was, as is well known, answered in the most decided negative by David Friedrich Strauss, and after him by Ed. v. Hartmann, with regard to their ancestral faith. If we now put to ourselves the question: Are we still Jews? then we shall have to answer with the same decision: Yes, we are still Jews! And so we shall have to answer even then, should we share the scientific standpoint of the one or the other of the two men named and profess ourselves their faithful adherents and comrades in conviction. But how are we to explain this to ourselves?
The explanation does not lie in the opposition between Judaism and Christianity. Judaism is the religion of the Law. Its legalism knows no bounds. The Mosaic Law with its 613 commandments and prohibitions has been extended and multiplied beyond all measure by the Talmud and its decisors, the "Earlier," the "Later" and the "More Recent," in such wise that no man is any longer able to compass with his knowledge the enormous wealth of law of Judaism. — Christianity is the religion of dogma, of the article of belief; and Christian dogmatics too the Church has at all times sought to develop and to build out in quite the same manner, to a compass scarcely to be mastered.
Now science, however, the exact as well as the speculative, has gnawed and tugged at the Christian dogma and worked upon it so dissolvingly that little has remained of its original shape, and above all the believing mind has with time dwindled away. It was pre-eminently this circumstance which made the two men named grow doubtful in their traditional faith and seek a thorough regeneration or some other substitute.
But with legal Judaism it has fared far worse. Not only science, but life also, social and economic life, have worked dissolvingly and destructively upon fidelity to the Law. Ease, love of enjoyment and religious indifference have likewise done their part, so that of Jewish legalism scarcely a feeble remnant is left; apart from the fact that through the necessity of vis major, through the dissolution of the Jewish State, the destruction of the Temple, the expulsion from their land, two-thirds of the religious legalism of the Jews have become inapplicable and incapable of fulfilment. In face of these facts, should we not feel constrained to answer, as our final result too: We are Jews no longer?
The refutation may easily be made, by pointing to the great mass of Jews in all quarters of the world, who one and all still seek, as Jews of the strictest observance, to fulfil the Law and to order their whole life accordingly. Such a refutation Hartmann has already rejected with the words: "as though that which in an ideal sense has been laid by history among the dead could not nevertheless, as a real existence, go on vegetating for thousands of years, as the plain evidence of so many forms of religion teaches us." "As though everyone did not know that the mass of the people always remains thousands of years behind the properly civilised peoples, that the greatness of this backwardness grows with the progress of culture…"
Now these remarks of Hartmann's are indeed not altogether to be brought into agreement with the situation of our fellows in people and in faith; yet they contain the right indication towards a diagnosis of our own infirmities and ailments as well, such as these come to light so very manifestly in the struggle against Zionism. When, a few years ago, Zionism raised its head in a new form and shape and set out upon its triumphal progress through all the lands where Jews dwell, it was not only the Assimilants, wholly estranged from Judaism, who fought Zionism with all their might; the Orthodoxy which gives itself out as strictly faithful to the Law joined vigorously in the chorus of opponents also, although this very Zionism appeared to meet all their religious views, prayers and hopes. Wherefore? One of the greatest Jewish money-princes, faithfully attached to the rigid Orthodoxy, has betrayed the reason.
Being applied to for his support of the good cause of Zionism, he is said to have answered: "Whether the cause be good or bad is all one to me; enough, I will have nothing to do with the 'Poschim.'"
Orthodoxy sees at the head of the movement men who know nothing of Jewish legalism, and in part will know nothing of it; and therefore, quite especially therefore, must Zionism be fought; and they thereby place themselves at the side of their own opponents, although these, by their own conceptions, are the greatest "Poschim," that is, transgressors of the Law. Yet this contradiction is not even the worst reproach that can be made against Orthodoxy; a far worse one is its want of insight.
They are still faithful to the Law, or at least believe themselves to be so; but have they also the assurance that their children — if they have any — their grandchildren or great-grandchildren will still be such "good Jews"? All reason and experience speak against it. So soon as the Jew — and this is precisely a remarkable phenomenon — turns to modern culture, or attains to fortune and standing, he begins to grow indifferent towards the legalism of the faith and at last to strip it off altogether. Yet towards modern culture they all press with irresistible force, and just as much towards social intercourse and the enjoyment of life.
In the same measure and degree in which these elements of culture are on the increase among the Jews, fidelity to the Law shows a declining tendency; in such wise that the psychologist of to-day, who in his psychological laboratory believes himself able to determine states of the soul by measurement and calculation with mathematical certainty, would also be able to give in figures the point of time which might be regarded as the end of all Jewish life and being, indeed as the end of Judaism altogether.
Are we still Jews? If we Jews possessed nothing further than our legalism of faith, and were nothing further than a religious community resting upon this legalism, then, yes then must we honestly and