Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 4
(continued from page 5)
…Jews who are now entitled to acquire landed property?"
""No; for the Government would at once conceive suspicion and revoke the lately issued ordinance, which is due to the influence of Mr. Fernandez in Constantinople.""
"Rumours have reached us concerning certain dissensions which are said to prevail in the colonies since their transfer into new hands. Is there anything true in these rumours?"
""It cannot be denied that the colonies are passing through a serious crisis; but I hope that the difficulties will admit of a satisfactory solution. You see, the colonies have passed out of a father's into a guardian's hand. Baron Edmund v. Rothschild regarded the colonists as his children — he actually knew all their children by name — and they looked upon themselves as such. They were accustomed to receive help, and help from without works enervatingly. Could but a way be found to their heart, it must be not merely wholly possible to make the colonists independent, but also to make them ready for sacrifice. It will not be difficult to guide them, for hitherto too they have been accustomed to submit themselves to directions.""
"Is it correct that numerous colonists are emigrating in consequence of dissatisfaction with the new order of things?"
""No, the colonists are not leaving the country. But there are in all the colonies labourers who, unlike the colonists, have no land and soil of their own. Some of these labourers now wish to settle in Egypt and elsewhere, and to these the "Jewish Colonisation Association" will pay the travelling expenses. As for the present condition of the colonies, no one need ask where a Jewish colony begins. Wherever the soil is well tended and offers a fair prospect, there you may be sure that you have Jewish property before you. It is without doubt known to you that the wines and spirits of Rischon-Lezion obtained the only gold medal at the Paris Exhibition.""
"Perhaps you could inform the readers of the "Jewish Chronicle" concerning the institutions of the Alliance israélite in Palestine."
""Improvements have been carried out in the trade school at Jerusalem, and a handsome building has been erected for the elementary school. A course of instruction in various kinds of weaving has also been introduced in the trade school, and samples of the fabrics made in the school were sent to the directors of all the Alliance schools, in order that these might procure the stuffs for the clothing of their pupils from the Jerusalem school. The apprentices are thoroughly taught, and are now learning drawing, which will be of great use to them. The "Jewish Colonisation Association" has placed a considerable sum of money at disposal for the granting of loans to Jewish artisans and tradespeople in Jerusalem; and since Mr. Antébi, the present director of the school, has been the intermediary of these benefits, the relations of the artisans to the institution are shaping themselves far more friendly than heretofore. Mikweh Israel near Jaffa is resplendent "like a garden of the Lord in the land of Egypt." In the garden of Sir Moses Montefiore also good progress is being made.""
"It is generally believed that you have definite views upon Zionism."
""Indeed I have. I must confess that the movement has brought fresh life thither where before there ruled inertia. At the same time, however, I hold it to be regrettable that the Zionists put all too much trust in money — another would say: in the golden calf. The Zionists fancy that they could obtain everything for money; but everyone who is familiar with the state of affairs in Palestine knows that all the wealth of the whole of Jewry does not suffice to gain possession of the holy places. Regrettable to me, further, seems the war which they have declared upon all those who do not share their opinion. To us Jews tolerance is quite especially needful. The Zionist leaders set themselves above all religious feelings; but the Christians have not laid these feelings aside, and if it were possible to imagine that the Charter which Dr. Herzl strives after should be obtained, it might come to pass that the Russian muzhik and the ignorant Bohemian who busies himself with the "blood accusation" would undertake a new crusade against us and would wage it with far more fanaticism than the Arabs would do. Instead of entering upon adventurous plans, we must seek to improve the position of the Jews in Palestine, so that they may be able to maintain themselves and so that a feeling of dignity may be awakened in them which they cannot possess so long as they are not independent of every outside help. We must also strive to raise the intellectual and moral standing of all our brethren, so that we ourselves may be enlightened before we give light to others. We must distinguish ourselves not merely in commerce and in finance, but also in science and in the arts. We have seen that in the West and in the United States of North America even those Christians who were formerly hostile to us now stand friendly towards us. Through our self-exaltation a feeling of friendship towards us will spread abroad everywhere, and in the course of time the non-Jewish friends of Zion, who now exist only in scanty number, will develop into a world-league which will invite us once more to fulfil a mission at the holy place which was once our home and which with God's help will become so again.""
*
We had feared that Mr. Nissim Behar would cut down everything without quarter, and he, the wise and kindly man, has not killed a fly. Who will take in such a confederate? The sanctimonious, canting Anti-Zionists perhaps? But he is after all one of the foremost friends of a schooled education that trains to nourishing labour! All the anathemas that there are in Jerusalem lie heavy upon the head of this man. Or will the Assimilationists perhaps take him in, him who is a separatist national Jew? He is indeed a Zionist too — after his own fashion. He will have it at all costs that the Zionists must set their minds upon purchasing the holy places for money, that they are bent upon bringing everything into their possession for money, and that he is against it. If they do not set their minds upon it and are not bent upon it, then neither can he be against it. But since we know that it has never entered the Zionists' heads to acquire the holy places, Mr. Behar's opposition bursts like a soap-bubble. He, like many an opponent, builds up a house of cards and then knocks it over himself. He does not listen to what the Zionists say, but speaks in their stead and is then an opponent of what he himself has spoken. This "Turk" is truly not so black as the paper which is his mouthpiece has painted him.
(A second article follows.)
Open Letter to Dr. Max Nordau!
Amsterdam, 13 January 1901.
Much esteemed Herr Doctor!
The third article "The Political Equality of the Jews" in the "Welt" of the 14th of December last year has made much sensation. I had hoped that from another quarter something would be written in the "Welt" against your article, since it is not to be supposed that among the many eminent men of the Zionist movement there should not be one who does not share your opinion. To judge from a letter in the "Welt" of the 4th of January, no voice has hitherto been raised upon it among the Zionists. Only Bloch's "Wochenschrift" and t. q. have answered your article, but in a manner which admits of no further objective debate. Therefore I believe that, as a man, as a Zionist and as a Hollander, I must protest against your views. I do this the more frankly as I am convinced that you — who as the author of "Degeneration" overthrew, out of your own honest conviction, the fashionable idols of society, and thereby proved that you subordinate personal esteem to what you hold for true — that you therefore, more than any other, will respect an opposition upon the merits.
