Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 1 · 4 January 1901
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 1

(continued from page 3)

...Middle Ages shame attached itself to the name of the Jews, as of the murderers of the Saviour and the accursed of God. In the age that followed, the Jews were the universal object of attack, because they were held to be enemies and blasphemers of the ruling religion, and were reproached with poisoning the wells. It was said, too, that they slaughter Christian children in order to use the blood for ritual purposes, that they steal hosts out of the churches in order to desecrate them and to make their mock with them. And not merely the faith of the Jews, but their nationality also was the target of all malignity and vindictiveness. It was said that an evil odour (foetor judaicus) streams from their bodies, and more of the like. Nowadays they are reproached with practising usury, with sucking the people dry, with drawing to themselves all the goods of the land, with leading a parasite's existence, and with robbing the peoples that have hospitably opened to them the gates of their country.

Since, then, the grounds of the hatred are various, they cancel one another. The pretexts change, and the hatred remains.

It is remarkable that all the accusations which are raised against the Jews are raised against every minority that is hated by a majority. The murder of children for ritual purposes is known as an old accusation, which the ancient Romans already raised against the first Christians; and to-day the missionaries and Europeans in China meet with the same reproach. All the reproaches that are made against the Jews are raised in other countries against the German workmen as well, and generally against all immigrants, from wheresoever they may have come. That is the key to the solution of this difficult question and to the discovery of the truth.

It is the way of man from of old to hate deeply everyone who differs from us in his peculiarity and in his bearing. We cannot endure that there should be a man of another nature than we are; quickly have we found out that he stands in our way, that he disturbs our quiet, that he overturns the order to which we are accustomed and compels us to accommodate ourselves to new habits of life which come hard to us. Now if these differently constituted persons are a minority, we shall find no ground for suppressing our evil impulses and for concealing our feeling of hatred; but when no occasion is present for letting the good impulse prevail, the evil one gains the upper hand of itself. That explains the hatred, everywhere existing, of the many against the few who dwell among them — quite especially when the hatred against the few rests upon a tradition, and above all when the few distinguish themselves in any point. As regards the Jews, there exists a religious hatred nourished from of old, and the influence of the gruesome fables of the murder of boys, etc., which come down from the Middle Ages.

The minority can never do right in the eyes of the majority. Hence it comes that the majority always makes the minority its scapegoat when it commits faults or is visited by adversity. For it is also a psychological law that children and savages, as well as peoples whose critical sense is little developed, make responsible for all the suffering that befalls them that one of their surroundings who is hateful to them. Therefore in the time of the "black plague" the Jews were accused of poisoning the wells. In our time the agrarians reproach the Jews with forcing down the prices of grain. The Aryan workmen, on their side, accuse the Jewish workmen of underbidding them. The reactionaries in all countries complain that the Jews join themselves to the Radicals, further the endeavours after subversion and prepare hindrances for the Government. In the countries where there are no Jews at all, all these evils and plagues are found in a far higher degree, and there the guilt is rolled over upon other hated minorities, mostly upon the foreigners, to hate whom passes for meritorious, or else upon native minorities — in France, for example, upon the Protestants and the Freemasons, elsewhere upon the Jesuits, etc. That is simply a shifting of the responsibility. It witnesses in no way against him who is accused; it witnesses only to this, that those who accuse him harbour hatred against him; and because they are incensed and malignant towards him, they impute to him everything evil. The primal ground is the hatred; its consequences only are the various and ever-changing accusations.

Anti-Semitism does not comprise the whole Jewish question, but only a fraction of it. The other part is what the Jews themselves think of their situation in the midst of the nations and of their future destiny.

It is no wonder that all Jews who get to feel anti-Semitism wish to escape from it. The few rich Jews, whom anti-Semitism can touch not at all — for, as is well known, anti-Semitism halts before the palaces of the rich Jews, even in Roumania — distinguish themselves by their optimism, by their manner of speaking of this matter lightly and with an untroubled smile. These people always say: "Anti-Semitism is a passing malady; yet a little while, and it vanishes." The mass of the Jews, however, feels that this is untrue. It has not, indeed, the clear knowledge of all the circumstances which we have here enumerated, but instinctively it says to itself that anti-Semitism is a violent aversion, such as every man — and every animal too — feels towards those who are otherwise constituted than himself; and therefore anti-Semitism will not cease so long as the Jews remain a recognisable, characteristic minority among the nations.

In order to be no longer hated and persecuted, in order to be able to lead a sufficiently secured and normal existence like all peoples, the Jews would have either to cease to be a minority or to cease to be recognisable. These are the two solutions of the Jewish question which are striven after.

Upon the one side it is counselled to unite the Jews in some one place into an imposing majority. From historical and religious grounds the people who counsel such a thing have fixed their eyes upon Palestine, the land of the fathers, as the fitting place. These are the Zionists. Were Palestine again a land inhabited by Jews, and could the Jews establish themselves therein by their own strength and labour (at present the number of the inhabitants of Palestine amounts to 600,000 souls, among them 60,000 Jews, while there are about 6,000,000 Jews who cherish the wish to return to this land), then anti-Semitism would visit them no more, for there they could find rest and work, and pursue their calling undisturbed, like every people that lives in security upon its own soil. But the Jews who will not return to Palestine may just stay prettily where they are; and if anti-Semitism shall further oppress them, we must resign ourselves to it. They could have fled and have not done so; therefore either they are very well off and bear their suffering with equanimity, or they are not affected at all, or they possibly have another remedy. Be that as it may: about these people one may be unconcerned.

Other Jews strive after another solution of their question. They will not become again a separate people in a separate land. They prefer a