No. 52 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…question interesting the whole world could for so long not find the very simplest and most reasonable solution.
In every act of knowledge there lies an element of joy, and out of that is then to be explained the enthusiasm with which new movements fill their adherents. I hold that every man, in whatever camp he may stand, once he has recognised Zionism, must needs become a Zionist too. The only misgiving in the matter is, as has been mentioned, merely that the thing is too reasonable, too self-evident. That is always dangerous and always assures a widespread hostility. I began to read the "Welt", I may say to study it, and to follow its twofold agitation, the one directed towards the practical side and the other towards the moral. As an incorrigible Utopian I was able to find absolutely nothing Utopian in the idea of the taking of the land; but doubts did indeed rise in me with regard to the ideal endeavours to raise the national self-esteem of Jewry. There are certain indestructible legends: thus that of the wealth of the Jews — for one rich man there are thousands upon thousands who starve in the deepest misery — and that of their arrogance and overweening obtrusiveness — here the same proportion. For one case of hybris, ten thousand cases of dejection, of despondency, of humility. Poverty makes humble. The world sees only the few, and lets the many do penance for them. It is true that a moral raising-up would do good to those who creep depressed through life, but by exhortation they will scarcely be helped. For that dejection springs not from an opinion that might be set right, not from a mood which could be displaced by another, but is a state of suffering; and one might just as well exhort a disease or an inflammation to be so good as to disappear.
There exists also the legend that the Jews are cowardly. And this legend is, by way of exception, correct: the Jews are cowardly. I hold it an unfruitful undertaking to delay oneself with wishing to refute this opinion also, where there are so many of the false legends that must be confuted. The familiar objections have from of old made little impression upon me. That numerous Jewish soldiers in numerous wars have done their duty and more than that, that many Jewish men and young men about town have stood up to the duel and have left their lives in it, that too is known to me; but it nevertheless seems to me of little probative force. The Jewish stock has hitherto shown no less sense of duty than any other; and when a Jewish soldier honestly plays his part in the field and even distinguishes himself, or when earnest Jewish men or foolish young men about town give way to a mightily welling indignation or to the phantom of social prejudice and join in the silliness of the duel, they do only what the others do also. One has no right to presuppose in them less sense of duty, or, in certain circumstances, a smaller measure of folly. But if they do the same thing, and there is a merit in it, then this merit is an incomparably higher one. For to the same achievement there was needed in them an incomparably more heroic gathering-together of all their forces than in the others, since it went against their nature. Here too the phenomenon so often observed: the Jew must accomplish twice as much in order to attain to the same estimation as another.
"Die Welt" has, as I have been able to observe, roused up the Jewish national consciousness in many circles where formerly not even an inkling of it dawned. The Jewish-national students, in heightened pugnacity, fight as well or as ill, and no less often, than the Aryan student corps; but that does not for me overthrow the axiom that the Jews are cowardly, and I beg to be first heard before the opinion is condemned. It is after all better to confess a fact honestly than to seek to maintain in useless strife a position which, regarded without prepossession, is untenable; and above all things it can be no evil to clear up men's opinions.
To begin with, I am not of the opinion that the reproach of cowardice is so very terrible a one, or that one must therefore straightway fly out of all bounds. The gentleman who so frequently recurs in the comic papers, and who gives to an academic rowdy that jostles him the answer: "Give yourself no trouble, I am a coward", has even always appeared to me very serious and very reasonable. Our society, which plumes itself so greatly upon the spirit of the new age, is nevertheless in many points still quite backward, and it will, willing or unwilling, have to resolve upon many a transvaluation of moral values. Still it proscribes cowardice, which is nothing else than a lack of pugnacity; and withal its whole system of education is reasonably arranged to damp down such pugnacity as may be present, by no means to heighten it. But if this be lacking occasionally in a given case, then society is at once at hand with the great ban.
Very well: cowardice is an unvirtue, a vice, a disgrace. Let us look somewhat more closely at the justice of the social conceptions. A man of society may make a poor girl unhappy and drive her into death; he may make debts at his pleasure and ruin craftsmen and small tradesmen by troops; he may as a spendthrift squander his fortune or be a miser; he may be a drinker, a gambler, a finished idler, without society's disqualifying him. On the other hand, the proscription follows immediately if a man is unable to wring from his nerves the contempt of death which society under certain circumstances demands of him. And commonly it is not even death that terrifies the coward, but the nerve-racking stage of preparation, which after all still permits a favourable issue to be expected. Not death is the terrible thing, but the fear of death that falls upon a man. The examples are not rare in which nervous — let us say, for all that, cowardly — natures have proceeded with full decision of will to suicide, in order to have to bear no longer the torment of awaiting a duel or a battle. That would be a preposterous undertaking, and psychologically quite inexplicable, if one would assume the fear of death alone as the motive. The truth is that, as has already been remarked, the psychical phenomenon of fear prepares far more frightful torments than any real catastrophe whatsoever, whose final occurrence may even be greeted as a deliverance. That is so always and everywhere. Not real misfortune constitutes the actual suffering of mankind, but the tormenting anxiety, the fear of misfortune. The overwhelming majority of men go through life burdened with care and oppressed, and withal it is not the real misfortune that oppresses them, but the care for what is coming, for the future, for the "to-morrow and the day after to-morrow". One
