No. 51. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 11.
(continued from page 10)
...ficed, but through a miracle the oil was sufficient for eight days. We do not celebrate the victories of the Hasmonaeans, said he, for these victories brought about the downfall of the Jewish State, since the Hasmonaean princes were vicious and ambitious persons. — Whence, I asked myself, can it come that the Rabbi thus strikes history in the face, that he has the boldness to describe the heroic struggles of the Maccabees, which excited the admiration of the world and form the pride of Jewry, as a national misfortune? Well, this comes of his fanatical hatred against the Zionists and the National Jews, who are themselves the Maccabees of our time and who use the feast of Chanuka in order to revive and to awaken anew the national feeling of the Jews. For this reason he is a second Herostratus. He bespatters the victorious struggles of the ancient Maccabees and prefers to let an old legend pass as the sole ground of the Chanuka celebration. The authors of our prayers were surely genuine, pious Jews, with whom the pleasure-loving Rabbi cannot indeed compare himself, and these in the Chanuka prayer על הנסים brought into prominence the victorious struggles of the Hasmonaeans and made no mention whatever of the legendary little cruse of oil. With this species of Jewish priestcraft ...*) the proverb proves itself true: "Blind zeal does but harm." But if the Rabbi will have the fight at any price, we Zionists will take it up; on our side stand truth and justice, on the side of this ...*) wrong and untruth, and we must do everything possible to put a stop to the trade of this ...*)
With high esteem E. Binder, VIII., Florianigasse 5.
Correspondence.
Vienna. We receive the following communication: In the "Jüdisches Volksblatt" of the 7th December a meeting-reporter attempts, after the dear old custom, to jostle certain persons in an impudent manner — though, as a matter of course, without the mention of names. Since these personal attacks are beyond all doubt aimed only at me and at my colleague Mr. Nathan Gross — the Zionist speakers at the meeting discussed — I see myself moved to set the state of the case, distorted as it is by party journalism, a little in the clear. After the paper of Dr. Sofer, which was for the greatest part of a polemical and critical nature, several Zionists took the word in order, in the most objective manner, to combat the paper, or rather the principles of the "Jewish People's Society" which coincide with it, and to defend the political Zionism that had been attacked. Upon their expositions, in which every personal argument was avoided, there followed only an ironical — and therefore wounding — reply from the presidential table, and an unheard-of personal attack on the part of the reader of the paper, who could not be brought, even by interruptions, to an objective treatment of the opposing view. If now the reporter of the "Jüdisches Volksblatt" speaks of "youthful brawlers" whom, in the interest of Jewish-national concord, one "should let speak only under supervision", then this presumptuous, provoking tone is to be excused only by the great want of understanding and the lack of tact which speak out of every line of the short report.
But if the "Jüdisches Volksblatt" is really in earnest about Jewish-national concord, then let it in future allow certain reporters to write only "under supervision".
Thanking you most heartily for the publication of this short reply to a brutal — anonymous — attack, I sign with excellent esteem and Zion's greeting
Egon Lederer. Member of the Zionist District Committee for Lower Austria.
* Trieste. Last week our distinguished fellow-partisan Rabbi Dante A. Lattes delivered, in the great council chamber of the community, a lecture upon Nordau's drama "Dr. Kohn". The speaker demonstrated the social and national significance of the piece for the Jewish question. The lecture, elaborated in brilliant fashion, was rewarded with lively applause.
Sefrou (Morocco). The Jews are here in great danger. Discontented tribes in the north are rebelling against the Government, and the first blows fall upon the Jews. The shops are at present closed for fear of the revolting tribes, and it is feared that the insurgent hordes will succeed in penetrating into the Jewish quarters. The struggle against the rebels is carried on from the Jewish side with desperation. Sefrou is about 4 1/2 hours distant from Fez.
Nadworna. (Personal notice.) Our fellow-partisan Mr. M. Hübner, honorary member of the society "Zion" in Nadworna, celebrates on the 25th inst. at Pasieczna his marriage with Miss Pepi Wundermann.
The "Zion" Federation and the Austrian Jewish Students.
For Sunday the 23rd December all those Zionist societies which have hitherto not attached themselves to the "Zion" Federation are invited to a conference at Vienna. This invitation is — so I believe — addressed also to the Jewish students' societies, of which hitherto not one has joined the Federation, although it is precisely the Jewish student body that would have very great need of a union.
The "Zion" Federation would now seem fitted to bring about a union of all the Jewish students' societies of Austria. Certainly, however, there are weighty reasons which withhold the students' societies from declaring themselves branch societies of the "Zion". These reasons, however, lie by no means in the Federation, but in the several academic corporations themselves.
We students fit less easily, with our theory and our practice, into the counsel of old men. We champion our sacred idea otherwise than the Federation does; we university students, we, the youth, can support Zionism not materially, but only morally; and finally: whoever would unite himself with others must first be at one with himself. Not as though I would assert that the students' societies of Austria are at variance; but with the exception of the deputations at larger functions, and of the one occasion in the semester when they notify one another of the result of their elections, they stand in almost no connection at all.
Here the lever must be applied. To my knowledge the attempt to attain a union of the students has been made three times of late (Hessiana at Zurich 1897, Academic Zionist Society Berne 1899, and Society of Jewish University Students Prague 1899); but it always remained at the attempt. The "Society of Jewish University Students Bar Kochba in Prague" has called upon its representative at the conference of the "Zion" Federation mentioned at the outset to propose the foundation of a federation of the Austrian Jewish students, and has herewith for the second time taken the initiative in this matter.
Such a league could propagate Zionism and the Jewish national idea in an undreamt-of measure. Upon what basis such a federation might be erected, in what direction, in what manner and fashion, and finally with what means this league might work — that I would set forth only when it appears that the decisive factors, that is to say the Jewish students' societies of Austria, desire the foundation of a federation and are also willing energetically to further it.
Prague. E. Gütig.
*) Here follows a characterisation of the Chief Rabbi which, notwithstanding the personal responsibility of the sender, we do not wish to reproduce, out of regard for the office of Dr. Güdemann. Note of the Editors.