Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 44 · 2 November 1900
11printed page
scan 11 of 16

No. 44. — "Die Welt" — Page 11.

(continued from page 10)

…and their bearing they are anything but social democrats. Meanwhile, the time is no longer distant when their "modesty" will there too be requited with the well-deserved throwing-out. N. Gr.

Vienna. (The weekly report) of the registry office of the Vienna Israelite Community for the period from the 14th to the 20th October shows 34 births and 31 deaths.

Review of Periodicals and Books.

Received.

Stenographic Protocol of the proceedings of the Fourth Zionist Congress. London, 13th, 14th, 15th and 16th August 1900. Vienna, 1900. Published by the society "Erez Israel".

Zionists and Christians. By Emil Kronberger. Leipzig, M. W. Kaufmann 1900.

Report upon the Questions of the Intellectual Elevation of the Jews in the East of Europe. By N. Sokolow (Warsaw). Editor of the "Hazefirah".

The Stepchild of Humanity. By Dr. M. Tschernichoff. Leipzig, M. W. Kaufmann 1900.

Famous Israelite Men and Women in the Cultural History of Humanity. By Dr. Adolf Kohut, parts 1, 2, 3, 4. — 1900. A. H. Payne in Leipzig-Reudnitz.

האוצר ("The Thesaurus"). A thesaurus of the language of Scripture and of the Mishnah, composed by R. S. J. Fin, of blessed memory. Published by the "Achiasaf" Company. Parts 1—4.

מעמק עכור ("Out of the Valley of Achor"). Sketches and jottings. By J. H. Brenner. "Bibliotheka Ivrith" 108, Warsaw 5660, "Tushiyah".

In the "Hazefirah" N. Sokolow, in an essay equally excellent in form and in content, appraises the symptomatic significance of the suggestion proceeding from Professor Philippsohn for the holding of a German Jewish Diet. "After we had become Zionists," so Sokolow begins, "they became 'Friends of Zion', and after we have summoned the Jews of the most various lands to Congresses, they begin to convoke a Congress out of the Jews of one land. Among the German Jews the proposal of a 'Jewish Diet' at present stands under discussion. Look, look! The Jews are to assemble, the Jews are to sit in council over their affairs, the Jews are themselves to give themselves the testimonial that they have 'special endeavours' and 'special interests'! Where has the like ever been heard of? How did it run of old? 'The Jews have indeed the right to come together in the "Temple" for common divine service, but outside the synagogue they must feel themselves a "member of the nation", must strip off their peculiarity, must take part in all the affairs of the fatherland.' Can it now be permitted them to have internal affairs, to hold separate conventicles? Would it not be said that they form a 'State within the State'? — *) So then the convokers of the German Jewish Diet are fanatics, obscurantists, reactionaries, disturbers of the peace, dangerous fellows? So then they drive water upon the mill of the anti-Semites, who have indeed long since reproached the Jews with being 'separatists', with being no patriots?! To be sure, the authors of the Jewish Diet wish to call together merely the Jews of the fatherland; but from that to a Congress of the Jews out of all lands is but a single step! All special endeavours are indeed reared up in this manner: to-day the Jews of one land join together, to-morrow the Jews of two, of three and of more lands will do so. This road leads straight to Zionism incarnate! A liberal-minded, progressive man, a friend of the fatherland, a good citizen cannot devise so dangerous a thought. By chance the author of the proposal is called, in Christian name and surname, Martin Philippsohn, and is by calling a university professor. He is the dangerous separatist, the sectionalist, who would call Germany's Jews together to a Congress. Three years after Max Nordau hurled his bomb-shell, the "Western Jewish distress", into the world, there rises up in Germany a man like Professor Martin Philippsohn and proclaims aloud that German Jewry is threatened in its existence, that it must strain all its forces in order not to be annihilated, in order to save itself from complete ruin. And Professor Philippsohn is by no means a Zionist!

With satisfaction we can record it: certain people are drawing near to us in striking fashion — unconsciously, involuntarily. Not the rich, the great owners of banking houses, the candidates for patents of nobility and the suitors for aristocratic sons-in-law. These will doubtless keep us waiting yet a while. But the intellectuals, the knights of the spirit, they are coming nearer to us, step by step, yet perceptibly. The Philippsohns, the Landaus and Baginskys in Berlin speak a language which distinguishes itself clearly from that of the men of attachment of the generation just past. The intellectuals cannot repeat the old, threadbare hurdy-gurdy tunes; it is indeed precisely this that stamps them as intellectuals.

From the Zionist point of view we rejoice at every sign of the impulse to live and of the urge to activity, such as is the suggestion of the Jewish Diet. Whether that calls itself Zionism or not is all one to us. The name is nothing to us, the essence everything. We do not know how far the German Jews can help themselves when they shall have assembled. Even if they should have no success, we shall not mete out to them with the same measure. They ask us: You have assembled, have taken counsel, have travelled far, have wearied yourselves — what have you attained? What is the practical use? Where is the great settlement that you would create? — Who knows whether we shall not be able to hold up the same objections and reproaches to the men of the "German Jewish Diet". We do not doubt at all that in the eyes of the impatient, of the snatchers after momentary successes, the German Jewish Diet also will present itself as something extremely "unpractical". But those people have no notion of the essence of a national activity.

The Congress of the German Jews may well become an institution of the highest importance, even if it shall not at once accomplish anything "practical". The enemies of the Jews will cry murder: the Jews are joining together into a fatherlandless organisation. But they cry too: the Jews multiply, the Jews live, the Jews do this, the Jews do that. They who would please the anti-Semites, these are the true Utopians and enthusiasts. We must fulfil our duty without other considerations than those which the laws of the land and our own interest impose upon us."

In the "Ungarische Wochenschrift" of the 26th inst. there has appeared, under the title "What Hopes does Zionism Awaken?", an interesting article by Mr. Sam. Partos, rabbi in Duna-Földvar, in which he polemises in very tactful, yet energetic fashion against the opponents of Zionism. We shall best characterise the train of thought of the article if we give the following sentences in extract. "Their (the Zionists') sincere striving none can mistake; their love for Judaism none may doubt. If hitherto they have achieved nothing else than that the anti-Semites already feel the wedge which checks their senseless doings, if brotherly love, the union of the members of the race, embraces broader strata in our midst, because the source of Zionism lets abundant nourishment flow to them thereto — before these successes alone must the opponents strike sail." "The day will and must dawn when the insight gains in breadth in Israel that Zionism aims at our best: to win for persecuted Jewry the longed-for peace."

By S. Gordon, the author of the tale "The Sisters", there has just appeared a novel, "The Sons of the Covenant" (Sons of Covenant). It brings pictures from the life of the Russian Jews who have settled in London.

Upon the true situation of the Jews in Hungary we find instructive disclosures in an article of the anti-Zionist "Egyenlőség". It runs there, among other things: "Under the Bánffy régime … the Wallachians and Panslavs clenched their fists with curses, but it did not occur to the Jews to lament or to be anxious. To-day the heaven


*) How apt these satirical allusions of Sokolow's to the "German citizens of the Mosaic confession" are is proved by the fact that the Mainz "Israelit", in its number of this week, really makes use of these assimilatory phrases, tormented almost to death, in order to protest against the German Jewish Diet.