Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 35 · 31 August 1900
7printed page
scan 7 of 16

No. 35 — "Die Welt" — Page 7

(continued from page 6)

…whole human race we may least of all count upon within any time that can be foreseen — that is not to be had! For the present, "let each see what he is about, let each see where he abides, and let him who stands take heed that he fall not." — On the day whereon I should behold the dawn of a bodily and spiritual recovery of my people, I would cry out exulting:

"I have lived enough!"


Second Day.

Afternoon Sitting.

In the afternoon sitting, which was opened by the President, Dr. Mandelstamm, the debate upon the report of the Actions Committee is continued.

Dr. Rosenheck declares, in the name of the Galician-Bukovinian delegation, which represents about 10% of the whole of Jewry, that he receives the present report of the Vienna Actions Committee with quite especial satisfaction. In the strengthening of the organisations lies the only success that can at this time be attained. He expresses to the Inner Actions Committee his unconditional and firm confidence. As a member of the Galician Provincial Committee he can only establish that the Actions Committee has fully fulfilled its obligations towards it, inasmuch as it has always stood in contact with Galicia. He desires only closer explanations concerning the general political situation, a furtherance of the agitation and organisation by the sending out of numerous speakers to Galicia; finally he emphasises the necessity of an economic strengthening of the Galician Jews. (Lively applause.)

Frau Dr. Steinberg has gained from the sittings of the Russian delegates the impression that the principles of Zionism are not quite exactly known. She therefore desires from the Actions Committee an explanation whether the same, if it were in possession of large sums of money, would be entitled to intervene with help in a catastrophe such as, for example, the Roumanian. She also puts the question whether the Congress has the right to meddle in the business of the Bank, since the solution of such tasks as the one mentioned above will probably be left to the Bank. (Lively applause and clapping of hands.)

Rabbi Rabbinowitz (Sopotzkin) reports upon his activity in his district in Russia. One sees that at every Congress ever more representatives of Zionism appear, from which it follows that Zionism spreads ever more widely. He discusses the attitude of the Protest Rabbis towards Zionism and explains their attitude of refusal by their fear that a cultural movement might call forth antagonisms to orthodox Judaism. Here, however, the pious should be wiser and the wise more pious. (Lively applause.)

These orthodox opponents of Zionism will be won over by bringing them to the conviction that Zionism is not directed against religion. When one has won the Rabbis, then one has won the whole of Jewry, which indeed, especially in Russia and Galicia, belongs 9/10 to the orthodox tendency. (Stormy applause.)

Pineles (Galatz) remarks that the sad position of the Jews in Roumania has not held them back from doing their best for Zionism. For the rest, it does not quite correspond with the facts if everything is painted so black. In the district of Galatz, for example, the treatment of the Jews on the part of the authorities is praiseworthy. There the Jews have emigrated only because for a year past they had found no employment. (Lively contradiction.) The speaker opposes the erroneous view that Zionism had encouraged the mass emigrations from Roumania. (The speaker is here called upon by the chairman to speak to the question.) In conclusion Herr Pineles addresses an appeal to the Jews of Western Europe and North America to help their suffering brethren in Roumania. In England the means for this could be found, if only the good will were present. (Applause.)

Rabbi Landau (Bottuschani) is of opinion that the Actions Committee has not yet found the right way to carry Zionism into the broad strata of the people. In the Actions Committee no sufficiently clear standpoint was taken up in this respect. The broad masses of the Jewish people are devoted to Zionism, but an injury to their religious feelings might nevertheless bring it about, not indeed that they should cease to be Zionists, but that they should detach themselves from a particular Zionist association. The culture question in its present form has, for example, a deterrent effect upon the broad strata of the Jewish people. The Actions Committee ought altogether to have refrained from raising such questions. Nevertheless more weight might have been laid upon the spread of the Hebrew language and of the history and science of the Jews. That language courses were established in Russia is not to be set to the credit of the Actions Committee; it sprang rather from an inner impulse of the Russian Zionists. He appeals to the Congress that it may give the future Actions Committee the commission to turn more attention to the questions raised. (Lively applause and clapping of hands.)

Ellmann (Braila) opposes the view that there is in Roumania even a single place where the Jew is treated as a man and as a citizen with equal rights. Here swift help is necessary, otherwise the Jewish question will very soon be solved for Roumania, and in a quite peculiar manner. (Lively assent.)

Dr. Weitzmann is of opinion that one must look to the inner activity of the societies if one would form a picture of the extension of Zionism. It is in no case correct that the injury of religious feelings by Zionism is the cause why not all Jews further the Zionist endeavours. The question of religion must here be regarded as a private question. The broad masses will bear themselves indifferently towards Zionism so long as nothing positive is accomplished. (Lively assent.)

Dr. Awinowitzki (Odessa) finds the chief task of the Actions Committee to lie in centralisation. The bringing together of the Congress alone is already a gigantic labour. (Lively assent.) The Actions Committee can do nothing other than the individual societies, for it is nothing other than a member of the Zionist body. (Lively applause.)

Dr. Bernh. Goitein (London) gives a suggestion for the spread of Zionism in Hungary, where this movement has hitherto taken but little root.

Tolkowski (Belgium) defends the Actions Committee against the reproaches raised and expresses to it his confidence.

Loewy (Blackburne) declares in the name of the English Zionists that these have absolute confidence in the leaders and in the Actions Committee. The Actions Committee has done enough if it has but organised this Congress. The speaker welcomes it that the Congress sits this year in London and calls to it a hearty welcome. (Stormy applause.) In conclusion he puts the question what attitude the Actions Committee takes towards the colonisation societies, since the "Chowewe Zion" in particular are very widely spread in England. (Contradiction.) He personally is of the opinion that one may unite with none of these societies if it does not recognise the Zionist principles.

Leo Mozkin is likewise of the opinion that the Actions Committee is merely an executive organ, to which one must nevertheless bring confidence for its labours. He too would have Zionism kept apart from the religious questions. The broad masses know notwithstanding very well what Zionism wants. Moreover, the influence of the Rabbis in Russia is overrated; they were never in a position to call forth such a movement as Herzl's "Judenstaat" has done. Zionism must not be doubted in its honest intentions. (Lively applause.) Wherefore did the Rabbis not come to the first Congress? And now they would here point out to us the way?! (Lively applause.) The agitation must be carried on as hitherto if one would attain the goal. (Stormy assent.)

The debate is thereupon closed, and as general speakers there are chosen: pro — Dr. Menczel (Bukovina), contra — Dr. Bragin (Russia).

Dr. Bragin is of opinion that the Actions Committee has accomplished nothing in the past year; at least from the report rendered nothing of accomplishments is to be perceived. If political considerations forbid the communication of more, this at least might be said. And if the Actions Committee could do nothing in consequence of the circumstances, wherefore does it not quietly admit it? (Cries for the close and contradiction.)

Dr. Menczel does not hold the manner in which criticism is here exercised to be the right one, even though indeed there is something to be found fault with. It would have been far more in place had the Actions Committee exercised a criticism upon the activity of the individual Zionist societies. So long as no