No. 34. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.
Lewin (Ekaterinoslaw) holds that the Zionist movement in Russia must not be measured by the number of shekel payments or by the quantity of shares subscribed. Zionism has of itself called forth there a mighty ferment, of which hitherto not a trace was to be found. The communities are to be won not by force, but by moral influence, and this aim Zionism has completely attained. Literature is in the midst of an undreamt-of upward flight. The new schools have indeed not been founded exclusively by the Zionists, but they have for the most part been prompted by the Zionists. The Zionist movement in Russia increases from day to day very greatly. (Tempestuous applause.)
Dr. J. L. Landau (Vienna) takes the A.-C. under his protection against the reproaches raised against it, One must not demand of it something that it cannot do. The chief task of the A.-C. is to gather the scattered forces, in order then with united forces to strive towards the goal. (Tempestuous applause and clapping of hands.)
The sitting is thereupon adjourned to 4 o'clock in the afternoon. (The report upon the further sittings we shall give in the next number.)
Impressions of the Congress.
By Dr. Ph. Menczel (Czernowitz).
The Debate.
A Jewish parliament in London! The history of the world has strange whims. Precisely there, where the parliamentary forms display the greatest rigidity, where a superfluous movement of the hand is held for shocking and gesticulation is regarded as an offence against good manners, the men of storm and stress came together with their excess of temperament, with their overflowing feelings and their flaming enthusiasm. Many an Englishman who was present at the proceedings may well have shaken his head in displeasure. In the plenum itself voices of censure were heard: "That these people cannot restrain themselves! That they debate so wildly!" By no means. To me the picture was pleasing. Who knows how it may have looked in English assemblies before the Magna charta libertatum emancipated the British people? Assuredly things did not go there so solemnly and so measuredly as now in the House of commons. Into the Jewish people there has come a ferment which stirs up the masses. The Congress is a picture of the people in miniature, but sharply drawn. Everyone who takes the word in the assembly of the deputies of the Jewish people feels that he must cry out into the world concerning the great Jewish distress. And so I saw old men, who assuredly were speaking for the first time before so great an assembly, wrestling after words; their heart felt more than their mouth could say, and therefore, after some unsuccessful attempts to bring their thoughts into ordered speech, their closing words died away in a solemn oath neither to rest nor to stay until the great work of redemption is accomplished... Beside these, however, there were also men who observed and handled the rules of parliamentarism as though they had belonged for decades to parliamentary representative bodies. As often as mighty waves of feeling broke one over another and threatened to make the debate shoreless, the "parliamentarians" intervened and led the discussion to a profitable end.
The Rabbis.
They were the first whom I encountered. On Sunday forenoon I saw them sitting round a long table in a corner of the great Congress hall. They debated eagerly. Their discussion held me fast. They were disputing about Zionism, from the religious standpoint, as a matter of course. Quotations from the Talmud whirred through the air. The Tanaim and Soferim, named with reverence, celebrated their resurrection. The Russian rabbis are strong dialecticians. From Jewish religious philosophy, whose representatives handle the Aristotelian method with skill, the rabbis fetched their logical armoury. I heard them carry through in the discussion regular chains of inference, with major and minor premisses, with principal and subsidiary syllogisms ... They made preparations for the Congress proceedings, came to an agreement upon points of principle, discussed the culture question of the Jewish people, and sought to bring past and present into harmonious accord ... They succeeded ...
Interesting figures! Here a man, pious and plain to his very finger-tips; a pointed little cap covers the grey locks, an ascetic line marks the narrow lips. There a vigorous, full-blooded man; a long reddish-fair beard harmonises with the fresh colour of his face. Strength and energy speak out of these features. I heard him speak later in the plenum. With self-conscious pathos, with a full-sounding, sonorous voice, he spoke of the rabbis as the teachers of the Jewish people, of the knowledge and the capacity of these teachers, who devote their whole life to the study of the Jewish doctrine of God, of Jewish literature and history. "A Jew," said he, "who does not know the history of his people, the holy tongue of the fathers, is no educated man .."
The old man ascended the tribune. His words sounded like a prayer that rings through the sultry spaces of a thronged synagogue, fervent and solemn, jubilant and lamenting ... To bring past and present into accord: that is what Zionism desires. Had but the modern "preachers" — for so the protesting gentlemen "shepherds of souls" are now called — heard the words of the Russian rabbis! ...
The Ladies.
The Jewish women had this year sent a stately contingent of Congress members. They were the most attentive among the listeners and the most indefatigable among the bestowers of applause. Women in general are reputed to talk much, and what comic paper has not made merry over the coffee-party and over the meetings of the "champions of women's rights"? I therefore observed with great interest the women's bench in the Congress house. All honour to them! With the greatest earnestness they followed the proceedings, and repeatedly I saw individual ladies draw forth their note-books and write down what they had just heard. Of the tears which they shed when Nordau depicted the great misery of our brethren in Roumania they need truly not be ashamed. I saw strong men weep too, and — why should we deny it? — the Jewish heart is soft. The tears which flowed for the poor homeless ones were, after a long time, the first genuine tears that Jewish misery had wrung forth. I mention them here expressly, because I hope that these lines will furnish a historical document. The Jewish woman who with her tears wrings forth not journeys to the baths or toilettes, but compassion for the Jewish people — that is what Zionism has brought about.
The Close of the Congress.
Thursday was come. The commissions and committees had worked feverishly; the night's rest had been sacrificed, that report might be made to the plenum. In spite of the heat and the unremitting labour, weariness had nowhere gained ground. I heard many say that the Congress must be prolonged. It could not be. The hall had to be given up. And so it was the very last day that brought us a fruitful, matter-of-fact debate. Without a midday pause the proceedings were carried on from early morning until the falling of the evening. One report after another was disposed of. The elections began. A solemn mood took possession of the house — and when Dr. Herzl took the closing word, it was as though the Shofar were sounding through the house, the Shofar that is to gather the scattered Jewish people from all "four ends of the world" — to the homecoming. A solemn stillness lay over the assembly. No noisy demonstration disturbed the consecrated mood...
The Complicity of Europe.
By D. Salo.
It is not with our enemies, but with our friends, that we have at the present moment to settle accounts. In these latest days several governmental declarations have been made in the Roumanian affair which may indicate a turning-point in the hitherto sad course of events. A turning-point for the worse, of course. What the new action of the Roumanian Government — which, according to the officious reports, opposes no hindrance to the repatriation of the emigrants — is in truth intended to signify, no man will as yet be able to establish with certainty, in view of the obscure sources from which these tidings flow. If, however, one considers that this resolution of the Roumanian Ministry followed only after the Hungarian Minister-
