Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 15
(continued from page 5)
…about their loins leave the house, so that every Bokharan, Sart and Uzbek might know that it was a Jew, and that every affront put upon a Jew is of no consequence ... Such was Jehovah's will . . . The sins of the fathers He punished in the sons . . . Yet Jehovah heard the prayers and the tears of His unhappy people . . .
The old man rose and stretched out his arms towards us. We stepped up to him . . . He whispered a few words . . .
— The grandfather has implored down God's blessing upon you and upon your children, said Jasuf softly.
The aged man smiled gently upon us, stroked his beard once more in token of greeting, and, supported upon the arms of his son and his grandson, went out of the room . . .
Soon we too left the hospitable house . . .
— A rich man is Mosche Boruchow — said I to one of the Djigits, who, standing by the horse, awaited my orders. —
— The richest in all Samarkand — answered the Djigit, an elderly, experienced Sart who spoke tolerable Russian.
— A good man too? — I remarked questioningly.
The Sart was silent.
— Dschugut! — he forced at last through his teeth, and in his voice there lay an unspeakable contempt.
A. B.
The Necessity of a Translation of the Talmud.
Little known, but much reviled, is the Talmud. Such has been its lot from of old. Yet in earlier times there stirred at least now and again the wish to learn, after the event, that which had been proscribed. Out of this somewhat belated thirst for knowledge the first translation of the Talmud arose. The Emperor Maximilian had in the year 1509 commanded that all Hebrew books be burnt, and had thereby kindled the quarrel between Reuchlin and the Dominicans of Cologne. As he thus became the indirect author of the famous Letters of Obscure Men, so he gave immediate occasion to the first translation of the Talmud, in that, after Reuchlin's victory, he charged the professor of philosophy Paul Ricius, a baptised Jew who had meanwhile been appointed his body-physician, about the year 1519, to translate for him the "whole Talmud". Thus arose the "Talmudica novissime in Latinum conversa, perjucunda comm." (Augsburg 1519).
More than ever is the translation of the Talmud to-day an urgent necessity, since the study of the Talmud is in decided decline and the apprehension is not to be put aside that no renaissance will bloom for it again. Truly, alas only too truly, says Erich Bischoff in his "Critical History of the Translation of the Talmud in All Ages and Tongues" (Frankfort-on-Main, J. Kaufmann, 1899): "With the flattening of theology the study of the Talmud likewise fell away; the shallow enlightenment (among Christians, be it observed, and Jews alike) could not abide the 'sea of the Talmud'. Where to-day are the special professors of Litteratura Talmudica? All of three German university professors still lecture now and again upon this or that tractate of the Mishnah, yet only, so to speak, in a subsidiary office. How few students of theology know anything of the Talmud, how few Christian scholars have worked through an entire tractate! How few Jews too, born and bred in Germany, still possess profound knowledge of the Talmud! Russia, Galicia, Hungary, Bohemia are for the most part the native lands of such real Jewish Talmudists as still remain, and if one looks at the labours of the younger generation, these for the most part already present a picture of decline." It is therefore high time to think of salvaging the treasures laid down in the Talmud. It might fare with us in regard to them as with the hoard of the Nibelungs. With justice the poet admonishes: "What one has let slip of the minute, no eternity gives back."
A conditio sine qua non of a good translation of the Talmud is the exact knowledge of the achievements in translation hitherto. We have therefore every reason to be grateful to the scholar mentioned above for his careful and circumspect work. He himself characterises it as follows: "My work too has probably its defects; more free from error and more complete than those of my predecessors it is at all events. Of these, Strack is perhaps the only one who has really had in his hands all the writings he discusses. With my far larger material this was not possible; nevertheless I know more translations by actual inspection than another might boast of knowing — for of his industry, according to Lessing, every man may indeed boast."
It is noteworthy that it is precisely the age of Lutheran orthodoxy which exhibits the most intensive study of the Talmud. Shortly before the middle of the seventeenth century begins the flowering time of the older scientific translations of the Talmud, which finds its zenith in the last decades of that century and reaches into the thirties of the eighteenth century. Despite the odium which then attached to intercourse with Jews, we see the students seeking out Jewish teachers; they also listen devoutly to the discourses, to the "Schiur" of eminent rabbis, and keep at times one or more house-Jews who lend them a hand in their Talmudic studies. To be sure, the study of the Talmud is for them no end in itself, but an auxiliary science of theology, and therein is rooted the strength and at the same time the weakness of their translations of the Talmud.
Upon the aurea aetas of Christian Talmudic scholarship there follow more than seven quite unfruitful decades, in whose wilderness the labours of Ugolino and of Rabe form the only larger oases. Rabe by his modesty casts all vain authors into the shade. The prefaces to the second and fourth volumes of his German translation of the Mishnah contain critical corrections drawn from the reviews of Moses Mendelssohn in the "Letters concerning Literature". Mendelssohn says in the 186th Letter: "Herr Rabe has accepted the criticism . . . with a kind of self-abnegation which perhaps does him more honour than if he had translated the whole Mishnah without the slightest inaccuracy. He has had our 122nd Letter . . . inserted in the preface to the second part, and . . . . without cavilling at his critic, without making evasions, with the renunciation of all authorial vanity, has shown how the censured passages are to be amended."
A characteristic difference between the modern business of translation and that of the preceding period consists in the strong preponderance of the Jewish translators of the Talmud over the Christian. It is significant, too, that the German language has the largest share in the modern work of translation. Ephraim Moses Pinner purposed to bring out a German translation of the whole Talmud in 28 volumes. It is highly interesting that the first volume is dedicated to the Czar Nicholas I., who subsidised the work. It never got beyond this first volume, however. — The most recent translation, by Lazarus Goldschmidt, born in 1871 at Plungiany near Vilna, which is reckoned at 80 parts, has been appearing since 1896. With a unanimity that seldom occurs, scientific criticism has passed condemnation alike upon the untrustworthy rendering of the text and upon the far too numerous errors and the obscure and faulty German of the translation.