Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 8
(continued from page 3)
…in Europe nothing Jewish withdraws itself to-day. For in the course of the ages we have become frightfully interesting.
In the national enquiry which is sitting in council upon the improvement of the economic condition of the Ruthenian people of Hungary, the Government Commissioner Eduard v. Egan, entrusted by the Hungarian Ministry of Agriculture with the direction of this work of amelioration, reported on the 12th of this month upon the projected welfare measures of the Government. In connection therewith he discussed the Jewish question with frankness and at circumstantial length. He has thereby called forth some amazement in the country, even among the antisemites. For although antisemitism in Hungary has from of old been cultivated within the bounds of prosperity or outside them, it had yet essentially a social, private character. Into a "Jewish question" endowed, so to speak, with a public standing, into a seriously discussable political and economic problem, it has never really been able to grow.
The Magyars have learned from Ludwig Kossuth that politics is "the science of the exigencies," and they have found that the raising of the Jewish question is unnecessary, and therefore unpolitic. Hungary has more than enough in its old questions of nationality; it was therefore prudently upon its guard against breeding a new one in addition.
Now Herr v. Egan has set the stone rolling. He has sharply criticised the economic activity of the Jews in Hungary and represented it as in manifold respects injurious to the common weal. That both the feebly developed commerce and the industry of the country, still lying in its swaddling-clothes, are dependent upon the fostering care of the Jews, and already at this hour owe a very great deal to that care, the envoy of the Government was obliged to admit. Yet that did not hinder him from designating precisely the trading and industrious Jews as the cancer of the nation, which infects the whole economic life and disintegrates all legislation, all justice.
For all that, to Herr v. Egan the rich Jew is the better Jew, nay, the only true Jew. It is true that, as the Government Commissioner said, one cannot take three steps in the country without having to call in the aid of the Jewish money-man; on the other hand, however, he has also his good qualities: he is pliant, submissive, adaptable, and serviceable for many a purpose. He is the type of the "genuine Jew out of Judaea," and if he will but condescend to "strip off the special confessional zone" and to melt entirely into one with the Magyar, he will no longer stand in anybody's way.
The Jewish proletarians of the eastern frontier comitats, on the other hand, would have to be "thoroughly sifted"; for these are really no Jews at all. Herr v. Egan, be it known, occupies himself, in the time which his patriotic solicitude for the fate of the Ruthenians leaves him over, with anthropological studies. He has discovered that the masses of proletarians immigrated from Galicia are dolichocephalic, straight-haired, fair, of vigorous build of limb, courageous, nay foolhardy, almost violent — thus not at all such as one commonly pictures the Jews to oneself.
A mortal less schooled in anthropology would, to be sure, have interpreted otherwise the outward aspect — so widely differing from the exterior of the Budapest boulevard merchant-princes — of a Munkács Jewish coachman or porter, or let us say of a former Galician miner or wood-cutter. And the bearing of the eastern proletarians, downright foolhardy and desperately resolute in comparison with the comfortable ease and the sedate, modest demeanour of the well-fed, small and rotund "Jews out of Judaea," might likewise be found somehow explicable even without better anthropological knowledge.
But Herr v. Egan is well acquainted with the latest achievements of anthropology and is not content with layman-like, primitive attempts at explanation. He knows very exactly that only the rich, useful, pliant, submissive — in a word, the brachycephalic — Jews are to be regarded as the true Israelites, whom the Hungarian national organism can take up into itself, once they have "stripped off the special confessional zone."
The have-nothings and "Luftmenschen" come over from Galicia, on the other hand — the proletarians who with every resource of audacity, nay almost violently, snatch after the hardest labour and the most wretched earnings, in short the dolichocephalics — are no real Jews at all, but inferior "descendants of Chazar renegades," artificial Jews as it were, for the sound Magyar national stomach just as indigestible and injurious as, say, margarine or artificial wine.
And the Hungarian Government Commissioner by no means stands alone with his view of the inferiority of the Jewish proletarians of eastern Hungary. In this year's Year-Book of the "Hungarian-Israelite Literary Society" (Izraelita Magyar Irodalmi Társulat), which appeared some weeks ago, there are to be found, in a "study" upon these unfortunates by the secretary of the Pesth "Chewra Kadischa," Dr. Franz Mezei, among others the following remarkable sentences:
"This people has learned nothing; to useful labour it was not to be moved. The wonder-rabbis have laid snares for the calling of the peasant, in that they taught that the husbandman could not be pious and well-pleasing to God. They preach contempt also towards the artisan. To this day they believe it to be a vote of no confidence in God if anybody follows after work." — In this style it goes on through several columns.
Sketched by an antisemite, so malicious a caricature of the actual conditions could draw from us, who have long been accustomed to accept such things with quiet resignation, at most a rueful smile. Flowing from the pen of a Jew, this obsequious indictment — nay, self-indictment — drives the blush of shame into our faces.
Utterly contrite with shame we stand in the face of the Hungarian press that is served by Jews. The Jewish editor-in-chief of a Budapest Magyar daily, immediately upon the Egan speech becoming known, triumphantly brought forth out of its obscurity the aforesaid "study" of the Chewrah Kadischa secretary and worked it up into a sensational leading article.
In the leading article in question it is said: "Yes indeed, this hapless multitude is work-shy and therefore in an economic respect harmful, but morally corrupt. It sticks up to the neck in crass superstition and in bodily filth, hence it is incapable of culture and abominable. It clings convulsively to its dreadful foreign Jargon, and is thus from the national point of view also a matter for anxiety. In accordance with all this, one must fight against its moral and intellectual depravity. This the one (Egan) proclaims filled with hatred, the other (Mezei) with regret, but both with equal decision."
Further the Jewish article-writer says: "Let the immigration be regulated by way of legislation. If this could come to pass in the home of free thought, in America, if even England at the time of the expulsion of the Russian Jews went about with such a plan, why should Hungary of all countries not
