Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 3 · 19 January 1900
5printed page
scan 5 of 16

No. 3 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5


(continued from page 4)

…placed on an equal footing with the Catholic majority; in other words, that not a State Church, but only a common citizenship should be recognised. Tolerance towards the Jews is a very elastic conception. When the power of the State accepts the presence of the Jews as a necessary evil, shuts both eyes, as it were, permits them to pursue their livelihood, perhaps concedes to them the most primitive political rights — that is called "tolerance." When the power of the State not only withdraws from the Jews all political rights, but also intrudes with hostility upon their personal rights and leaves them at most the little air and sunlight of the gloomy Ghetto, that too may still be called tolerance.

And between these extremes there lies in truth the whole scale of the sufferings we have passed through. The rulers and peoples of every age have understood, each after their own fashion, how to lead us up and down this ladder with greater or less virtuosity. Just as unsteady, and therefore just as dangerous, as the conception of "tolerance" is the explanation of the "Napoleonic tendencies" given by the "Petit Caporal." "The Jews will be regarded as citizens, but — it will not be admitted that they rule France." The cautious restriction attached to the first clause may, where the intention is evil, lead to the abolition of the rights of citizenship. How absurd it is to imagine that seventy thousand Jews could rule an empire of forty millions has been said often enough. But apart from that. The majority decides whether it is ruled by the minority, and is thus judge and accuser in one. And with that the door is thrown open to every arbitrary act.

Yet let us give the words of Count d'Ornano the most harmless sense, taking into account that the anti-Semite Lasies has after all withdrawn from the "Petit Caporal" because his anti-Jewish articles were not accepted, and that the first Napoleon assembled the Sanhedrin — even then there still remains the doubt as to the Emperor's friendly disposition towards the Jews. Let us examine the "Napoleonic tendencies" for ourselves. Heinrich Heine says that Napoleon was formed by the confluence of revolutionary and counter-revolutionary views, and acted neither wholly as a revolutionary nor wholly as a counter-revolutionary. This judgment appears to fit quite particularly the Emperor's conduct towards the Jews. In youthful enthusiasm Napoleon had admired the Jewish people. The magnificent struggles waged upon their own soil for their own land had inspired a high esteem in him, in whom the genius of the commander was stirring. His disposition changed, however, after the campaign against Austria in the year 1806. Various reasons are assigned for this. The fact stands firm that the liberties which the Jews had won in the revolutionary period were threatened by a well-organised reaction, led among others by Chateaubriand. To this anti-Jewish party Napoleon lent his ear. On the one hand he did not wish to touch the achievements of the Revolution; on the other his "counter-revolutionary views" — otherwise expressed, his monarchical sense of absolute sovereignty — asserted themselves. In short, the Jewish question was set down for discussion, laid before the Council of State, and Napoleon was inclined to give way to the clerical influences. At the last hour he allowed himself to be more favourably disposed. An assembly of Jewish notables, and later the Sanhedrin, was convoked. Yet this was done, not in order to set up ancient Jewish institutions, but in order to lay downright humiliating questions before the Jewish representatives and, after they had answered them, to dismiss them again without any friendly assurances. Through the wars the Jews were carried out of Napoleon's field of vision, and the historian relates that the Emperor's unfriendly disposition lasted until his fall. *)

We observe that the Emperor was by no means friendly in his disposition towards the Jews; that he followed not his own view, but yielded to alien influences; that he wavered between sentiments of humanity and ridiculous prejudices, and in the end listened to the voice of vanity. Whoever, then, should wish to appeal to the conduct of the first Bonaparte towards the Jews might find proofs both of cruelty and of clemency. The phrase of the "Napoleonic tendencies" is nothing but a fine catchword, behind which the most suspicious facts lie hidden. It is a bait, to draw the Jews away from the Republicans or the Orleanists and to win them for the Bonapartists; or else — though this, to be sure, is hard to assume — it sprang from ignorance of the events.

One more word in Count d'Ornano's commentary challenges a brief consideration. He says: "We persecute no race or religion à la mode revolutionaire." The incorrectness of the assertion that the Revolution persecuted races or religions is evident if one briefly weighs the causes and the course of the Revolution. If the Bonapartists object that the Reign of Terror struck the Jews as well, that corresponds only to the half of the truth. There were rich Jews in France and in Alsace who excited the envy of the covetous terrorists and were plundered, nay, put to death. But their number is vanishingly small, and does not come into account against the great liberties that were won. They fell simply as a necessary tribute in a time of ferment. We are accustomed to nothing else.

And now the warning for the future. Count d'Ornano has made the matter fairly easy for us, in that he himself, by his explanation of the "Napoleonic tendencies," aroused attention. But should a shrewder man come one day and content himself with simply throwing out a similar catchword without expounding it, then too one must carefully examine what lies concealed beneath the glittering word. Nor let us forget that in the Dreyfus agitation the nobility created by Napoleon — although much Jewish blood flows in its veins — has the same share as the Orleanist; and we shall find the right standard for the judgment of fine phrases.


The Week.

Vienna, 17th January 1900.

The eighth sitting of the Austrian Delegation was seasoned with a little Jew-debate. It was of course to be foreseen that the Delegations would not pass off without a Jew-baiting; one may at most wonder that the inevitable occurred only at the eighth sitting. The tone of the baiting speech was somewhat more genteel and more dignified; it was distinguished to some advantage from the anti-Jewish clamour that is wont to resound from the other representative bodies. The anti-Semitic delegates have, in fact, a certain delicacy of feeling. The "higher" the parliament, the more chivalrous the abuse. A distinct gradation is to be observed from the Vienna Municipal Council upward to the Delegations. At its most savage and most blackguardly is the Jew-debate in the Municipal Council; upon its way through the Diet chamber, the


*) See Graetz, Geschichte der Juden, last volume, chap. 6 and note 6.