Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 41.
(continued from page 1)
…preponderance in the Transvaal, then one has approximately the right measure for the question about which the matter in truth turns.
With this measure in hand, however, one can also easily understand why the great Powers show no inclination to take the part of the Boers even platonically. Diplomatic considerations too are certainly in play here, for it leaps to the eye that no Power will for the sake of the Boers place itself in hostile opposition to England and thereby perhaps endanger the peace of the world. If France, which since the defeat of Fashoda cannot get over its rancour against England, is now again gently gnashing its teeth, and Russia does not conceal that it would heartily wish the English a reverse in South Africa, that is yet only the familiar clenching of the fist in the pocket. It is not victory that is wished for the Boers, but defeat for the English. Even in Germany, where one is much more nearly interested in the fate of the Transvaal Republic than in France and Russia, and where a popular current against England has long existed, sympathy with the Boers comes to light on the part of the State almost not at all, or only very much hedged about with reservations. Why, is easy to guess. When the Powers, pushing their spheres of interest ever further forward, gain a footing in distant quarters of the globe, they imitate the example of England, and their titles of right in Kiaochau, in Port Arthur, in Tonking and Laurenzo Marquez they base upon the compelling requirements of traffic and of civilisation. The policy of the "open door" is proclaimed; and what else than such a policy does England represent over against the Transvaal Republic in demanding the rights of citizenship for the "Uitlanders"?
One may therefore be quite easy about the extent of a war between England and the Transvaal, in so far as it still comes to one. It will remain a "localised" war. But to return to the starting point of this reflection: it will also, we believe, be a war of civilisation, however it may end. And that is the obvious association of ideas which we for our part connect with it. The Boers have shown themselves incapable of taking part in the mighty evolution which the overwhelming colonising impulse of our time has brought forth; they are no element of development. For them and their body politic, in the vital crisis in which they find themselves, human sympathies may find utterance, but these are not decisive. Conversely, for the Zionist idea, which yet coincides so wholly and so immediately with the civilising needs of expansion of the present, the human sympathies are unhappily so hard to set in motion, although the Jews are, so to speak, human beings also, like the Boers, and have no advocate to count upon such as the "Uitlanders" have. But on their side there fights the spirit of the age, which "stands under the sign of traffic." The Jews are an element of development. They have taken up into themselves fully and without remainder the ideas which fly through the world as pioneers of civilisation, and they desire for their part to work at the realisation of these ideas upon the soil which they have an indisputable historical right to regard as their heritage. What floats before us is the opposite of that whereby the Transvaal Republic has itself undermined its own existence. Freedom and self-determination we strive for, not apart from the general civilisation, but in its service — the right of unchallenged existence upon a clod of earth which we hope to make fruitful again, as our fathers once made it fruitful and raised it to a radiant source of light for all peoples — this right, which yet is legitimated so wholly otherwise than the rigid exclusiveness down yonder in the Transvaal, is the goal of our labour, of our longing, of our struggles. And in its way there stands no terrifying spectre of a small or a great war; if we attain it, then the sun of blessing-bringing peace will shine over the place where wrong shall have been made good by civilisation and desolate decay driven away by right restored. We say in the most literal sense with the poet: "What thou hast inherited from thy fathers, acquire it in order to possess it."
Oriental Autonomies.
(Samos.) By Ben-David.
New ideas require time in order to win a great multitude of adherents. The resistance of deep-rooted conceptions is broken only gradually and laboriously.
It is necessary to bring forward the same arguments again and again. Objections must be illuminated from every conceivable point of view and refuted — more than that: one must track down the unuttered doubts and disarm them.
For the unuttered doubts exist on that account none the less, and are of strong effect — I should almost like to say that the strongest doubts have the tendency not to be uttered: — they give their possessors the conviction of the impossibility of a thing, in face of which every formulation of the objection becomes purposeless.
The Zionist movement too has to contend against such doubters — they are those who call us dreamers and crazy enthusiasts — if they do not go further still.
Objective objections one cannot get to hear from these. Seldom is the existence of such even hinted at. And even then they are thrown out only so reluctantly: "How is a united procedure to be expected of a people so widely scattered!" — The events of the latest time — our Congresses, our Bank — have given an answer to that which everyone heard who was willing to hear.
"We Jews" (let the "we" be noted, which in this connection is almost always employed) — "we Jews are not capable of getting on peaceably among ourselves or of recognising an authority of our own."
I know of a colony — Pessach Tikwah — which has existed for 20 years, in which 16 different languages are spoken, and in which, in spite of the motley, jumbled population, a Turkish policeman or judge has never yet been called upon, but internal affairs, and disputes as well, are without exception settled before self-chosen tribunals.
The theme which I have set myself is a third objection, the most serious one perhaps, which for that very reason one also hears more rarely: "Is it to be assumed, or even so much as conceivable, that the Turkish Government will meet our plans halfway, that a mighty empire should renounce rights of sovereignty, whatever advantages might be offered it? Has one
