Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 40.
(continued from page 3)
…study one will not only have the history of the classes among the Jews, but one will further be able to establish that in the bosom of the communities the class struggle was always alive. I cannot cite numerous facts here — the matter would be worth a special study — but if one wishes for an example precisely, then there will serve as such, at least for the Jews in the 17th century, the way in which the rich sought to abolish the progressive tax which governed the "carrière" of every man and to replace it by the personal income tax, and how at the same time they sought so to alter the system of communal representation that the small traders and handicraftsmen could no longer have been represented in the sittings of the council.*) It will also be established that no people possesses so great a number of poor as the Jewish people. In the beginning, when war was held in abhorrence in Israel, the estate to be striven for was that of a poor man and a scholar of the Law. The rich counted it an honour to have about them a numerous clientèle of needy persons and of more or less poor scholars. The history of an Abarbanel in Spain and of a Nassi in Turkey is in this respect highly characteristic. Circumstances too must have contributed much to the creation of so uncommonly large a class of persons in need of help. Tillers of the soil at home, upon their own ground and soil, traders after the dispersion, a part of the Jews became among the Christian nations middlemen between Europe and the Orient. After the great economic movement of the Crusades the Catholic bourgeoisie took protectionist measures in favour of its own trade and closed to the Jews — not without having first wrought a blood-bath among them — the trade road to the Orient, thus confining them to trading within the nation with the peasants, and thereby forced them back into the small-burgher circles. On the other hand the corporations formed themselves upon a religious-Christian basis; they drove away the Jewish handicraftsman, forced him into lower callings, obliged him to work almost exclusively for his Jewish brethren only, and in this way helped to create in every Jewish community a frightful category of the unemployed. As soon as the Jew sought to escape this situation and from time to time obtained privileges, the fellowships of the merchants and the guilds of the handicraftsmen rose against him. This may be observed particularly in the 17th century, at the time when legislation proceeded less cruelly against the Jews. One need only read the history of the Jewish merchants in Bordeaux, Angoumois, or Languedoc. At almost the same time the diamond workers in Amsterdam protested against the Jewish diamond workers. They demanded certain privileges and the prohibition for the Jewish workmen to work on Sunday.
The economic situation of the Jews has not changed in our days. As yesterday, as always, the division into classes exists among them now also; they are chiefly town-dwellers, their bourgeoisie belongs almost in its entirety to commerce and industry, with the exception of a small number consisting partly of intellectuals and partly of the bourgeois haute finance. The immense majority is still formed into a proletariat which is concentrated in Russian territory, in Galicia, Roumania, and Bulgaria, and in the vast masses of London and New York. The official inquiries into the sweating system have proved in these two centres that the Jewish small master presses his proletarians hard, though they belong to the same race. The same happens in the great industrial towns of Russia, e.g. in Lodz and Berditschew, in certain districts of Galicia, where periodical stoppages of work set Jewish employers and Jewish workmen in hostile opposition to one another. But beside this proletariat, which has known how to organise itself in Holland, England, and America, there still vegetates a whole people of unemployed, a Lumpenproletariat such as exists in no other nation, a multitude of beggars crowded together in the steppes of Russia and Poland, in Algiers and in the Orient.
But I do not wish here to furnish a study of the Jewish workmen or the Jewish poor. It is enough for me to establish their great number and the fact that they form almost the entirety of the Jewish people. They are so numerous in Russia (by the census of 1887 — 293,509 workmen and 89,844 day-labourers; not included in the census are the poor, the unemployed, and further the quite small traders, hawkers, etc., who live still more wretchedly than the workmen and are six times as numerous as they), in Roumania and Bulgaria, that the Christian workmen complain of their competition. So it is likewise in London — there are 60,000 of them in Whitechapel alone, among them 10,000 workmen — and in New York, where more than 200,000 of them are counted, and where a movement in the Trade Unions against them became perceptible, since they were accused of forcing down wages. That is true, for the Jewish proletariat is the most wretched of all, since it has against it not only its own rich, but also the rich and the poor of the peoples in whose midst it finds itself.
Thus the study of the teachings of these books — the Bible and the Talmud — has by no means let us find among the Jews a social spirit based upon huckstering; neither did the study of what Marx called the "empirical essence" of the Jew demonstrate it. To others, then, than the Jews must the development of the mercantile, industrial, or capitalist system be ascribed; and it could come about only through an insufficient study of the economic condition of the Jews in the past and the present that one could speak as Jaurès one day did after Marx, and that one could assume, with the overwhelming majority of Jewish writers, that the unhappy destiny of this people rests upon its gain in trade, that capitalism is its work, and that it gives itself over to it in a comparatively far more vehement manner and suffers more through it than any other people.
Hitherto the Jew has been studied only in his bourgeoisie; it is time to learn to know him also in his proletariat, that truly significant and characteristic main body of the nation.
S. W.
Austria's Jews.*)
By Rudolf Kohn-Schlackenwerth.
Of all the peoples that must live side by side in our wide Monarchy and must get on with one another as best they can, there is only one that is hated and despised by all alike: that is the Jews. The other peoples and peoplets have friends and foes, allies and opponents, but only against this one little nationlet does the abhorrence of all concentrate itself. Nor is that any wonder. The other peoples, whose emancipation began about the middle of this century, have their fixed abode, surrounded by firm or wavering frontiers along which national jealousy ranges itself; the Jews alone have had to raise themselves in the midst of the other peoples after a degradation of two thousand years; they have brought into the sluggish dough of a uniform racial development the leaven of an entirely different race and have called forth a stormy movement whose end is not yet to be foreseen. In setting about, with an energy suppressed for two thousand years, to conquer their little place in the sun, they have, with their explosive mobility, with their adaptability multiplied by the inheritance of bondage, in certain callings into which they were thrust by the still lurking Jew-hatred and by the illegal but still existing exclusion of Jews from many kinds of calling, outstripped all competitors and done hurt to all the other peoples. Their monstrous increase in the fields of employment still open to Jews, or, as their enemies maintain, the Jewish holding together and their worse character, have brought it about that in Austria to-day there are but few non-Jewish advocates, journalists, writers, physicians, great merchants, and so forth. As regards the holding together,
*) Bardinet: Review of Jewish Science, XXXVIII.
*) We take this article from a pamphlet published by Carl Linde (Leipzig): "Austria at the End of the Nineteenth Century", by Rudolf Kohn-Schlackenwerth.