No. 40. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.
The same conditions which in the ranks of the German and Czech Nationals have led to anti-Semitism are now given for the non-Jewish adherents of the Austrian Social Democracy as well. From the moment when one vigorously emphasises one's own nationality, one sees oneself in an antagonism to the "strangers", and this antagonism develops all too easily into enmity. To anti-Semitism door and gate are now opened into the camp of Social Democracy. The Jewish labour leaders ought to have been shrewder. The nationally feeling organised workmen will be proof against Jew-hatred? That is hard to believe. They were, after all, not proof against nationalism either. They were no longer to be tamed; they would no longer keep their national flag in their pocket, and the leaders had to give way and formulate the national confession at the party congress. They assuredly did not do it gladly.
The leaders of the Austrian Social Democracy believed, to be sure, that they could expose the workman without anxiety to the dangers of nationalism and chauvinism. For at the same time the corresponding dams were raised against the present and every future chauvinism, and a halt was called to national discord by means of the separate administrative bodies. Against the principle there is nothing to be objected. When two cannot get on together, the most sensible thing is separation. That, indeed, is what Zionism also says. The Bruenn party congress likewise took pains to provide in this sense for all oppressed national minorities — only the Jews it forgot. Can the Austrian Jews promise themselves any betterment of their position from the planned re-division of Austria? No! In consequence of their sporadic settlement they would be the only national minority without an administrative centre and without the protection proceeding from it. Every people in Austria would have its own particular home, only the Jews would not. Already now they are reproached as homeless; one might then with incomparably greater justification be permitted to call them aliens. Their national distinctiveness would be recognised in a very painful manner by the various national groups of Austria, strengthened as these would further be by the nationally feeling working class, and the rampart against this scarcely agreeable recognition, the separate administrative body, would not be there.
Fortunately there is hope that this Austrian future-state idea will not be realised to-morrow or the day after. The Jews have the hope that for a good while yet they will be standing, not under the eaves-drip, but in the rain.
The Social Spirit of Judaism and the Jewish People.
By Bernard Lazare. (Authorised translation.) III.
Likewise, when I speak of the Jews, I mean to speak of the mass of the Galician, Roumanian, Russian, and Oriental Jews, and not of the few Christianised and Hellenised Jews of the West — although the higher types among these have nevertheless retained their Jewish traits of character. In this mass a peculiar bent of mind comes to light, which has its causes in a like education and a like material, religious, and moral conduct of life. In a threefold respect, in regard to ethnology, ethics, and intellectuality, the Jews are undeniably a people, among whom, as among other peoples, there are individuals who possess the aptitude to naturalise themselves completely. If one considers the Jews in the economic respect, one sees them, like every other nation, divided into various classes; so it has always been among them. There has at all times existed among them a bourgeois haute finance — whose rôle, by the way, has been much overrated — and a middle bourgeois class of intellectuals and merchants; and it has only not been well enough observed that the economic history of the Jews is not the history of the struggles between Christian and Jewish money-men, but the history of the struggles between the Jewish and Christian small burghers who live by trade. Finally, there has always been among the Jews an uncommonly large proletariat.
That one finds no tillers of the soil among them — there are such, moreover, though but isolated ones — cannot possibly cause surprise. The Jews immigrated into the states of antiquity; now an immigrant is never a tiller of the soil, unless he brings an uninhabited land under cultivation; if he comes among peoples who hold a tract of country in occupation, he devotes himself, like the Greek or the Phœnician, to trade, or he is perhaps a handicraftsman.
So it was with the Jews also. Whether it were Alexandria or Rome, there, where they dwelt together in numbers, they had very rich merchants, speculators, and financiers in their midst, but their mass was poor folk. In Alexandria the synagogue was divided into boxes, each of which was occupied by one of the Jewish handicraft corporations. And although in Rome many among them possessed an influence which they owed to their wealth — the one thing that could be had in Rome — and although these earned the apostrophes of Cicero or the goodwill of Cæsar, the majority nevertheless was composed of little people who had their dwellings round about the Porta Capena and plied the lowest occupations.
All Jewish communities were of such a kind. A nucleus of rich people, a group of traders who occupied themselves with the retail trade, a great number of handicraftsmen, and finally a whole "tribe" of poor people who lived in the neighbourhood of the synagogue upon pious gifts and upon the dues which were levied by the administration of the community from the income of those who were able to defray the costs of worship and the maintenance of the needy.
In the documents, in the archives, these handicraftsmen and these poor did not come to light and cannot come to light; for they do not treat with the towns and the religious corporations, be it concerning the possession of lands or concerning the obtaining of trading privileges; neither do they figure on the list of taxpayers; the community had to pay for them, for its administration was responsible for them. On the other hand, a series of chroniclers and historians who report of the Jews merely in passing speak of them after the manner of the anti-Semites, and one is, in reading them, exactly as well informed as one is about the Jews of the XIXth century if one reads, say, Drumont, who writes without moving a muscle that the Jew is no workman. People like Ajobard and Rigord see in the Jew only the man who knows how to lend money at interest or to carry on banking business. One must compare the number of taxpayers with the total number of the Jewish population, so that one may not overlook the small handicraftsman and the poor man. Documents for this will be found in the writings of numerous travellers who have visited the Jewish communities. These men, like Benjamin of Tudela, Petachjah of Ratisbonne, Jean Belon, etc., found the Jewish workman everywhere. The Jewish chroniclers made sufficiently exact statements in the enumeration of the tortures customary among the peoples, or in the mention of the discussions which everywhere preceded the expulsion of the Jews. "Who has made the Turks so strong?" said Lorenzo to the Senate of Venice and to Louis Mocenigo, who wished to drive out the Jews. "Where would they have found such skilful artificers for the making of the cannon and bows, the balls and swords, the shields and targes, which enable them to measure themselves with the other peoples, if not among the Jews whom the kings of Spain had driven out!" *) Finally, the gravestones of the Jewish cemeteries and the archives of the Jewish communities, or the documents proceeding from them, will also furnish valuable facts and data. Through their
*) Emek Habbakah, p. 181. (After Sée's translation.)