No. 31 — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…in earlier days come to know many young Jews who dreamed with joyous ardour of the lofty ideals of their people, and who suffered bitterly the while under the Mammonism and materialism of their surroundings; I welcome it with glad sympathy if in the new movement a way is given to these to overcome materialistic Jewry, and I wish their endeavours good fortune from my heart . . .
Zionism — Egoism. By H. York-Steiner.
One should never quarrel with an assimilationist. It is so merciless to shatter a man's ideals.
Who among us has not played the redeemer with the conviction of the redeemed, and preached the doctrine of the brotherhood of all mankind? We know what happiness the thought of the final victory of humanity brought us, and we know the sorrow that arose in us when we came to the conviction that we Jews must reckon not only with too many inhuman opponents to be able to look for that victory, but also with racial antipathies which makes even humane men unjust towards us.
We did not become Zionists in order to let a coloured rag flutter from our cloak; no, we have fastened the yellow patch upon the outside because our non-Jewish friends always fancied it hidden beneath our clothing.
The much-reviled yellow, degraded into the symbol of envy — it was gladly seen when fashion, some time ago, chose it for its favourite colour.
What many wear is no longer singular.
We Zionists must therefore seek out comrades; the duty of self-preservation compels us to it.
And yet one should never quarrel with assimilationists. Let one only lay a single question before those Jews who resist Zionism.
Do you wish your children to go over to Christianity?
Many of our western Jews will admit that they have nothing whatever to urge against it. These people, who are content to be manure for a generation of men that will cast stones at their own cousins; to whom it is a matter of indifference if their grandchildren defile their grandfather's grave with filth; who permit a man to swear to a dogma without inner conviction — these people are hard to instruct.
The request that they should no longer disparage Jewry by their existence I would not address to them either, for their children may after all become quite respectable people — and remain Jews.
Let no one be counselled or urged to baptism.
The majority of Jews will truly have nothing to do with this way of escape, and many a vehement Anti-Zionist will start when we put this question to him; and he, the seemingly indifferent one, the cool and superior one, then becomes eager, warm, cordial, and declares himself a faithful son of his parents who means to bring up faithful children.
In whoever answers thus, the strength of our idea lies latent. One should then expound it to him with mildness and dignity.
After a while, when we have spoken out upon all the questions that find their answer in Zionism, our counterpart will propose an armistice upon the following terms:
"I am quite agreed that Palestine should be colonised; that the Jews from Poland, from Russia and Roumania should go thither seems to me right also." Let us beware of this Truce of God, for it holds a great danger for us and for our movement.
This concession — it means no more than the green covering of the moor, beneath which the thick swamp lurks.
However sweetly the thought allures that we western Jews flung ourselves into the Zionist movement in order to redeem our oppressed brethren in the East, we must energetically ward it off; nor may we for a single moment believe, or let it be believed, that we feel as Zionists only for the sake of others.
True, it is they, those great, dull masses whom we do not know but only divine through the cries of woe that sometimes penetrate to us — it is they who are first to draw profit from our movement. But it is not because they suffer that we mean to fight at their side and for them, for other hecatombs of men suffer too — we take their part because they are our nearest brethren, because we suffer with them, because every insult that threatens them wounds us; because every blow that falls upon them makes us wince.
We suffer through them, their woe torments our heart; that brotherly fellow-feeling has come over us which drives a Tolstoi out of the comfort of his countship to his nearest brethren, the moujiks.
Through this deep torment we see confirmed within ourselves the indissoluble solidarity of the whole suffering Jewry. Out of the burning flame that licks about us all in common there rises a pure feeling which men call Zionism.
But this feeling might also live itself out in the colonisation idea alone, which does not suffice us. Why does it not suffice us? Because we need Zionism for ourselves as well; because we are by no means Zionists out of mere altruism, like so many rich and yet noble Jews. No we are egoists, I will betray it, and we think always of ourselves amid all these appeals, at these meetings, collections, journeys and speeches. We are selfish; we recruit playfellows and playmates for our children; yes, we even think of it that our girls shall one day find a husband and our boys take wives.
And these playfellows and playmates shall neither hear, at every slight quarrel, a term of abuse that ends in "Jew," nor shall they look on while their young friends dishonour their forefathers in the grave. The future husbands of our daughters shall respect and esteem us — without reservation; and our daughters-in-law shall not take fright when they discover our features in the faces of their children.
In short, we fight for the preservation of our kind. We do not wish to grow solitary; we work for our future, that it may not be said with justice that our life has been a purposeless one.
That fact, to be foreseen with absolute certainty, that the modern western Jews are dissolving and evaporating — it terrifies us, and we save ourselves in Zionism for our own sakes. We do not wish to wander about as lonely fools with a yellow patch upon our cloak; we wish to procure general respect for the colour yellow.
We do not wish that Christendom should with rotten, uprooted elements out of Jewry
