Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 29 · 21 July 1899
3printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 29. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

...to regard as just as much warranted as the national endeavours of any other portions whatsoever of the great human family; but I believe that it will have only limited practical successes and will sharpen the antagonism between Jew and non-Jew. So far as I have been able, by ocular inspection and by literature, to form for myself a picture of the conditions in Palestine, there will be no question there of a "national seat of their own", since the land is far too little productive to repay the expenditure of great means. Individual colonies may thrive well, but for the rest Jewish Palestine will probably always remain an object of European-Jewish alms. The native Jewish population has not of itself known how to acquire an economic or a political importance, and I doubt whether well-meant impulses from without can here effect any real change. It is not the opposing forces of the Mohammedans or of the Christians that have in the last resort caused the lamentable condition of the Palestinian Jews. That upon the basis of this human material, with the co-operation of European-Jewish idealists, a Jewish central body capable in itself of life can form itself, I doubt. Advances of Jewry in Palestine are not thereby denied; but by certain particular advances, such as an increase of the colonies and a better care of the poor in Jerusalem, Zionism is little served. It needs a stronger ideal than, in my opinion, is to be found in the Palestine of to-day. Whether it can bear to be consciously conducted as a "Zionism without Zion" is beyond my judgment. In the European homeland, however, Zionism does not appear to me as an alleviation of the difficulty designated by the word "Jewish question". Perhaps it does not even wish to be such an alleviation. It is true that it uncommonly facilitates the theoretical understanding between Jews and non-Jews, in that it presupposes clearly divided domains; but hand in hand with this theoretical facilitation goes the other thing, that it sets forth the partly extinguished consciousness of the ethnological antagonism as necessary, nay as desirable, and thereby influences the practical conduct of the Jews and of the "host peoples". A rising Zionism will be at once the consequence of old and the cause of new anti-Semitism. The Zionist, well-to-do Jew will employ his superfluity less "humanely" than Zionistically. The Zionist journalist and politician will be able to understand and to respect the national endeavours of the host peoples, but will place his work in the service of national Jewry. Therewith he will cease to be a fully entitled representative of a people which can never serve national-Jewish interests. The German then combats him because he makes Zionist politics or literature, and will wish to assign to the stranger, who himself asserts that he is a stranger, the rights of a stranger. At present the Jew defends himself against anti-Semitism with humane, liberal, cosmopolitan arguments. But wherewith will he defend himself when he has himself proclaimed national-Jewish principles? Upon good-will he does not choose to reckon, and for the fighting out of the question of power he lacks the strength. There is something tragic in the destiny of the Jewish race; but in the judging of so important a matter one must also not shrink from saying the tragic thing openly: Zionism is psychologically necessary, but it is no help. Upon the question of the effect of Zionism upon art I do not enter, since here the more exact knowledge of the circumstances is wanting to me.

* * *

The answer of the National-Social publicist H. v. Gerlach.

I. I hold it very easily possible that the Zionist movement will become strong enough to create a Jewish national community in Palestine which shall attain a certain State autonomy. Then it will appear whether Jewry still possesses state-forming power, which to me is very doubtful.

II a. The Zionist movement furnishes in the first instance welcome weapons to the anti-Semites, because it emphasises the difference of race which is disputed by the philo-Semites and by many Jews with a certain nervousness. It will not essentially work upon the host peoples, because the Jews who are most felt by these host peoples, in the good sense as in the bad, are hardly likely to be laid hold of by Zionism. In particular it seems to me out of the question that the educated, religiously indifferent Jews, who stand eminent in political, scientific, or artistic relations, should become accessible to Zionism. For their importance is rooted in their position among the host people. They have every interest in maintaining that place and in combating anti-Semitism, but none in fighting out for themselves a new position in a new and narrower polity.

II b. The answer lies in part already in II a. I do not believe that the development of Jewry through thousands of years can in any way be artificially directed into other channels. "Blood is thicker than mass." But thicker than blood is historical development.

III c. I lack the expert knowledge for the answering of this question.

* * *

Reply of Dr. Herzl.

To the observations of Pastor Naumann the following might perhaps be rejoined:

An antagonism between the various peoples and the Jews would hardly result from Zionism save if the Zionists should adopt wild chauvinistic habits. My friends and I have used every opportunity to warn against such an aberration. I believe, too, that nothing in our movement permits the assumption that we would foolishly exalt ourselves or sunder ourselves in hostility from the rest of civilised mankind. We have always, on the contrary, plainly emphasised that we conceive the future existence of our people as one resting upon the concord of all peoples, and that we would fain labour towards that concord. Consequently the Zionist ideal does not exclude the "humane", the generally philanthropic ideas; it includes them. Only we do not wish to be cosmopolitans without lineage, but to confess our nationality, while we cultivate the highest principles of humanity. That this love of truth should injure us with just men is hard to believe. The unjust, again, we shall never please. These have in any case accused us from of old of every misdeed. But it will in the future be one of the fair and great tasks of Zionism to prove by deed and by conduct that nothing human has become strange to us, even though we should take the liberty of not disavowing our own poor, reviled stock. We wish to be true to ourselves; men will then the more readily believe of us that we can be true to others who deserve it. That is the Zionist standpoint. When we win friends, we should not attempt to become like them, but to be true to them. This, it seems to me, is the worthier way, and upon it we shall, it is to be hoped, win more friends than Pastor Naumann to-day still supposes. Th. Herzl.