Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 23 · 9 June 1899
8printed page
scan 12 of 20
Facsimile · scan 12 of 20
Scan of p. 8
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 23.

(continued from page 7)

...the whole showed but one curious episode: a few window-panes were broken for Rothschild in the Rue Lafitte. This is the first time that a beginning was made among the "upper ten thousand" of the Jews, for as a rule in such excesses it is the poor, nay the poorest Jews who pay the tribute of brutality and want of culture, and not the rich.

A lady of my acquaintance told me two months ago that during the Zola tumult she had been constantly ill and had had to keep her bed. Her children did not venture into the street, because they show a pronouncedly Jewish type; her husband, who is a diamond merchant, had always come home before the fall of night. Especially ill had she fared during the Jewish holy days; then it was believed that things were now going to break loose in Paris against the Jews; she had then one attack of nerves after another. Even though the stronger sex suffered less than the poor woman, yet the Jews of France perceived that, in spite of the Revolution of '89 and in spite of the fine Rights of Man of Mirabeau, the people in general were not to be brought away from regarding the Jews as something alien in their body politic, as a thorn in their flesh, and that, as everywhere, so in civilised France also, only a certain quite small percentage of Jews is borne with. Once this is exceeded, culture and progress avail nothing at all, and unconsciously the antagonism of race makes its way, be it that a few Jews are beaten to death or only spat upon. It does not turn there upon the Jews concerned, who play a passive part, but upon the active mob, which as a Frenchman loves a comedy, as a Teuton a drama, and as a Slav a tragedy.

Greatly as France in general and Jewry in particular took harm through the Dreyfus affair, yet it had — as every thing shows light and shadow — something good also for Judaism. It brought the French Jews to the consciousness that their policy was a mistaken one, and that the Zionists with their Jewish organisation were in the right. As Jewish Frenchmen they might not even unite, for that would have withdrawn the ground from their policy of assimilation, which consists in unrecognisable absorption into the host peoples; but as French Jews they can join together and add yet a Jewish one to the many leagues of France. And this they did; they did not indeed write "Zion" upon their banner, but they were won for public Judaism and as such protested against every humiliation. And from genuine Judaism it is, as is well known, but a single step to Zionism. Only the de-Judaised Jew, who will know nothing either of religion or of nation, stands defenceless, because, torn from the Jewish soil, he finds no ground in the soil of the peoples and must hover as an abstract thing in the air, between heaven and earth. Lévy, who has dwelt in France for several centuries, perceived that he, once the mob should be in good humour, might yet be confounded with Löwy, who had come from Russia only a few years ago, and that he, the autochthon, might get the blows meant for the immigrant; what would it avail him to cry to the rabble, "I am not "Cinna the conspirator, I am Cinna the poet"; they would not believe him, or he would get cuffs for his "bad verses". Cinna the conspirator and Cinna the poet, Lévy from France and Löwy from Russia, stepped together and set up for themselves a hedge "Judaism", which will protect them from the attacks. For the present this protection still suffices, but sooner or later the hedge "Judaism" will have to be replaced by the wall "Zion".

* * * * * *

Zionism in England shows a more positive character. It finds a peculiar support in the ideas of a regeneration of Israel living in the English people itself. As early as the fifties of our century an Englishman demonstrated from passages of the Bible that the return of the Jews to Palestine must above all be brought about if Jesus Christ, as he has promised them, is to come again. Another Englishman prepared about the same time a genealogical table, according to which the English dynasty of to-day is descended from David, and a third made, with Great-British pride, the proposal to place all English ships at the disposal of the Jews who might wish to emigrate to Palestine.

Bible study in England is, further, only a very important means of furtherance for Zionism there. The pious Englishmen, who every Sunday in church, or at least in Hyde Park, hear of the wondrous deeds of the Jewish people, of its mission and of its promises, cannot refuse the tribute of respect to the "Jewish natures of strength", "which", as Laharanne sets forth, "were strong during their ancient history, strong after the destruction of Jerusalem, and strong in the Middle Ages, when there were but two powers left: the Inquisition with the Cross and Piracy with the Crescent."

Though conservative Puritanism may in a certain respect have hindered England in progress, for us it has wrought good: through Bible study it has smoothed the way for the Zionist idea. The English people honours the Jew as the descendant of King David, in whose history they are versed as is no people upon earth. For the genuine Englishman, therefore, Saturday is a half holiday, and most of the shops of London are closed on Saturday afternoons.

The zealous study of the Bible in England has worked in a good sense upon the English Jews also. They confess themselves publicly and aloud to Judaism and hold strictly to the Jewish law. Nowhere in Jewish circles is one so often asked whether one eats "kosher" as in London. In consequence of this religious Judaism they are all but a single step distant from Zionism, and by far the greatest part is Zionist. Not that in great London too there were no opponents of Zionism. It would be wholly to mistake the spirit of the Jewish people, were one to take from it its inborn spirit of contradiction. Even Moses had a Korah party against him. But all the immigrated Jews and the majority of the native-born are Zionist, and their Zionism is to be rated the higher in that it does not speak pro domo. In free England the Jews have found in London their Jerusalem. English law knows and bears no exceptional laws such as are usual in all other States.

The Jewish national character finds its counterpart in the English also. The outward brilliant being of the Frenchman with his southern liveliness may at the first moment have great resemblance to Jewish life; but more closely considered, the English, which is less socially outward and more familiarly inward, is by far the more Jewish national life. Many would indeed also see a certain kinship between the Phoenicians of antiquity, the merchants of the Middle Ages, and the Phoenicians of modern times.

There exists therefore a very sympathetic touch between the Zionists and the more advanced among the English Christians. Very often our meetings are honoured by them, and they at times take a very lively part in our debates. The Zionist Federation, at whose head stands Rabbi Dr. M. Gaster, guides the Zionist movement in England reasonably-slowly, but surely. The fluctuations of feeling upon the Continent as to the worth of Zionism make little impression here. Isolated