Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 15 · 14 April 1899
8printed page
scan 12 of 20

Page 8 — "Die Welt" — No. 15

(continued from page 7)

…district captain has at once introduced the necessary measures in order to stifle excesses in the germ.

The excesses are connected with the strike of the Nachod weavers. The labour movement in Nachod dates from the 16th of February of this year, on which day the strike of the weavers broke out, which lasted until the 22nd of March. From that time onward the workmen had already returned into all the factories; only in Jakob Pick's weaving-mill were 160 men still idle. The revolt broke out suddenly upon a formal word of command from certain instigators. House-searches are taking place not in Nachod alone, but in the neighbourhood also, and have arrests continually for their consequence.

In several factories a number of compromised workmen were arrested in the course of the day directly from the loom. The commissaries betook themselves, accompanied by military detachments of up to 20 men, into the workrooms and carried out the arrests. The comrades of those arrested let this happen without the least demur.

Upon the ground of the house-searches, which are still being continued, more than a hundred arrests have been made; most of those arrested were brought in fetters to Königgrätz.

The damage is estimated at 70,000 fl.


Dr. Alexander Marmorek in Vienna.

(Conclusion.)

After Dr. Marmorek's lecture a discussion was opened upon the motion of Dr. Herzl. The first to come forward as a speaker against was a certain Dr. Alois Pollak. He declared that Zionism contradicted the mission of Judaism and made a caricature of it, that Zionism compromised the Jews and lowered them before the world. (Lively contradiction.) The appointed representatives of Judaism were the rabbis and the presidents of the community. He could not accept Zionism, for these representatives too had declared themselves against Zionism.

Dr. Herzl (greeted with stormy applause) misses in the remarks of Dr. Pollak any grounds for his assertions, in particular for the assertion that the Zionists compromise and degrade Judaism. He points to the condition into which Judaism was brought by the so-called "appointed representatives", and in which the Zionists took it over.

"For," the speaker continues, "we have in fact taken it over, we are the representatives of Judaism, bristle against it as you will. (Lively applause.) All that in Judaism is vigorous, young and strong attaches itself to us, and only what is sluggish, incapable of attaching itself to new ideas or even of properly conserving the old, is against us. We have taken the Jews over in a condition in which the designation "Jew" passes for a term of abuse, for which one demands satisfaction. And in this condition we compromise and degrade Judaism?" The speaker then points to the revolution in the public opinion of Europe and America in the last three years with regard to Zionism, which stands today commanding respect, and likewise to the distinctions, unique in history, which have fallen to the leaders of the Zionist movement. If Doctor Pollak knows nothing of this change, then he is shut in within the same walls which the "appointed representatives" of Judaism erected about the Jews, and which have made of them a body incapable of resistance, of honour and of right. (Lively applause.) "We mean," Dr. Herzl concludes, "to beat a breach in these walls; we have already begun, we shall continue. It is simply an empty phrase that the Zionist movement does not work for humanity. If we solve various social-political problems by practical deeds, we have laboured not only for the Jews, but for the whole of humanity."

Dr. Alois Pollak seeks in a lengthier exposition to establish his assertion that Zionism is a caricature of Judaism and compromises it. He says that Judaism is international and not bound to the soil, a world-religion which is to unite mankind in the ideals of freedom and love. Through the restriction to Palestine Judaism is lowered. (Laughter.) Palestine is as little a geographical conception for the Jews as Judaism is a nationality. (Hissing and laughter.)

Dr. Herzl observes that Dr. Pollak, after his explanation of the word "compromise", does not find himself in accord with usage.

Thereupon York-Steiner spoke in excellent fashion against the opposing speaker. Dr. Allerhand associates himself with the exposition of Dr. Pollak and laid weight in particular upon this, that the Jewish people had not yet fulfilled its mission. Only for that reason did it still exist. In splendid fashion Dr. Königstein and Doctor Leopold Kahn refuted the previous speaker. Upon the motion of Dr. Herzl the following resolution is then adopted with all votes against three:

"Those here present are satisfied with the explanations which they have received from the speakers, and find that Zionism, as it has here been set forth, answers to a need of the Jewish people." (Lively applause and clapping of hands.)

After the adoption of the resolution Dr. Fuchs declared: Dr. Pollak had spoken upon "higher" command and in "higher" service. But even as Moses in the year of jubilee caused the ear of all those people who preferred the full crib to freedom to be fastened to the doorpost, so do those people also, with whom today the crib stands higher than freedom, belong to that doorpost. (Lively applause.)

In conclusion the architect Marmorek called for a lively participation in the subscription for the Jewish Colonial Bank. With great warmth he urged that all Jews, Zionists or non-Zionists, should unite in the interest of the Jewish people and contribute to the success of the bank. Not until a quarter to 12 at night could the chairman, Dr. M. T. Schnirer, close the meeting. To the organisers of it, and to Dr. Benedikt in particular, the warmest recognition is due for their exertions.


Letter from Lodz.

The best proof of the truth and historical justification of an idea is its spontaneous appearance. This mark of such an idea Zionism bears upon it. Spontaneously it arose, and spontaneously it spread among the broad strata of the people in all lands and quarters of the globe. Anti-Semitism was only its immediate occasion, but not its begetter. Similar endeavours existed in earlier times also, but the impetus of the idea came quite abruptly. Scarcely had the word Zionism been flung into the world when it shot through all Jewish hearts like a flash of lightning. Not all were convinced, but all, friends and opponents, were moved. Most conspicuous is the spontaneous character of Zionism in Russia and in Poland. There it has in a short time called forth an intellectual upswing such as the ordinary course of history could scarcely accomplish in half a century. The social life of the Jewish community was formerly wholly neglected. The Jewish people ran the danger of being not merely proletarianised, but of becoming downright a people of beggars, and no one thought of calling any institutions into life in order in some measure to mitigate the misery. The bulk of the Jewish population consists of small traders and handicraftsmen without capital. But nothing was undertaken from any side to meet the pressing need of cheap credit and of continuation schools as well. (Individual institutions