Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 10 · 10 March 1899
7printed page
scan 11 of 20
Facsimile · scan 11 of 20
Scan of p. 7
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 10 — "Die Welt" — Page 7

(continued from page 6)

…Pilat passes to the subject proper. The number of the Jews grew since the year 1869 from 575,433 to 770,468 souls in the year 1890, that is, from 10.56 per cent. to 11.68 per cent. of the total population. In general Pilat establishes that at present the increase is growing smaller. Whereas in the period 1869–1880 there were 111,173 added, in the decade 1880 to 1890 their number grew by only 83,972. On this occasion Prof. Pilat corrects the generally current opinion, as though the more rapid increase of the Jews in proportion to the non-Jewish population were a consequence of their greater capacity of multiplication. Proportionally, in his opinion, no more Jews are born than non-Jews; the mortality of the former, on the other hand, is smaller. But from the more favourable mortality figure the superficial conclusion is absolutely not to be drawn that the material condition of the Jews is a better one than that of the rest of the population. The real cause of the more favourable proportion is to be sought in this, that their manner of life is in general a temperate one, but especially that drunkenness is foreign to them, that they spare their health extraordinarily and always seek prompt and expert medical aid. Passing to the abode of the Jews in Galicia, Pilat establishes that they inhabit chiefly the towns and the small towns. In Lemberg and Cracow they form 28 per cent.; in 21 towns (out of 93) and in 61 small towns (out of 321) more than the half of the total population. Thinnest is the Jewish population in the west, where, as is known, the antisemitic disturbances broke out in the summer of last year. From Cracow and 19 other districts the Jews are continually emigrating. Occasion for this is given by the unfavourable conditions of existence. In the southern districts, on the other hand, their number has grown; in these, too, usury is said to flourish most. The conditions of livelihood cannot be exactly presented, since occupational statistics in Austria, and for that matter in the other states as well, are not kept according to religious confession. All conclusions in this regard can therefore be only indirect. A certain portion of the Jews give themselves to the intellectual professions. Very great is their number chiefly among the advocates and physicians. Very few serve in public offices, more in the railway and postal administration, fewer in the judicial and revenue offices. The tabular property of the Jews amounted in 1890 to 11.01 per cent. of the whole tabular ownership and 13.20 per cent. of the private holdings. In leasehold acquisition they have 48 per cent. Christians only, and these 48 in number, are for the most part wont to lease out their estates, while of the Jewish ones only 65 tabular estates were leased out. From this it is to be concluded that the Jews administer their estates independently. For the rest the Jews mostly support themselves, in the little towns as well as in the villages, by the tavern trade and their chandlers' shops, by the leasing of tolls and of cows, by brokerage in the most various businesses and services, but especially by credit transactions, which last they carry on chiefly as a subsidiary occupation. Since now in every society only a certain limited number of individuals can find their sustenance in trade, it is easily to be seen that the economic and ethical conditions of the Galician Jews exhibit no gratifying results. Numerous usurers were bound to arise. But the condition of these people too grows ever worse. Besides the usury laws, this has been brought about by the organisation of credit which is proceeding in the most recent time, so especially in the west: the loan banks, the agricultural societies (Kółka rolnicze), the Christian village stores, the peasant dairy associations and the productive co-operatives. Hence the conditions for the continued existence of the Jews grow daily more difficult. The consequence of this, he says, is that they will have to turn to other callings. The ethical principles of the Jewish masses are also becoming intolerable. Properly it would be the duty of the Jewish intelligence to remedy these evils. But this does not happen. Thus in many gymnasia the Jewish religion is not even taught, since there are no Jewish teachers of religion. The founding of a rabbinical school is therefore necessary. Evidently Prof. Pilat means a seminary for teachers of religion, since for "rabbis" there exist in Galicia no "posts" whatever, and it will hardly do that graduated rabbis should fill the posts of teachers of religion. Greatest, Prof. P. continues, is the hatred against the Jews among the broad masses of the Christian population of the country. With this one must reckon! This, as it were latent, hatred is successfully exploited by the popular parties that thirst after popularity. A striking proof, and one moreover officially established, was observed during the "disturbances." The tone here was set by Stojalowski with his associates. The clergy and the Catholic press, on the other hand, came out against the disturbances. (?) There had indeed occurred in journalism small (!) derailments, but the episcopate at once censured them in the severest manner and made it loudly known that antisemitism stands in manifest contradiction with the teaching of the Church. Antisemitism in Galicia has, moreover, no immediate connection with the analogous movement in Lower Austria; between the two there exists only an indirect reciprocal influence. In order to bring about a healing of Jewish conditions in Galicia, it is in the opinion of Prof. Pilat indispensably necessary to direct the Jews to other branches of livelihood. Difficulties there are indisputably very great ones. A plan of an internal Jewish colonisation (such as was proposed in the questionnaire of the "enquête") affords no prospect of great success. Nor is it opportune to recommend handicraft to the Jewish mass, since on the one hand they already at present carry on many kinds of it without success, and on the other it is a proven fact that great industry drives out the small trades. Mining, too, is no approved remedy. There remains, therefore, only great industry, the factory system. This is not only necessary for the Jews, but also uncommonly useful to the Christian population. Doubtless there are here too uncommonly great difficulties. These, however — such is Prof. Pilat's wish — should be overcome by the rich Jews at home and abroad. These should above all take up the matter and employ in their establishments exclusively Jewish workmen only. The relief action of the Baron Hirsch Foundation has been a minimal one, since it has assumed rather a charitable character. It is not to be denied, however, that on the other hand the Baron Hirsch schools are of very good influence and can show numerous successes; nay, they even afford the Christian population great advantage, since they call forth, as it were, a great struggle of rivalry between Jews and Christians. Lastly Prof. Pilat comes back once more to the causes of the "disturbances." They broke out chiefly also in consequence of the uncommonly bad organisation of the communes. This is an almost unheard-of one. The Zloczow commune district, for example, takes up 30, that of Dolina even 46 square miles! It is therefore impossible to require of three officials of the district captaincy that from their centre they should keep good supervision over so immense a territory. In this regard, too, an improvement must therefore come about. The question whether the Galician Jews should form a political party of their own Prof. Pilat answers to this effect, that in his opinion it might be done: such a self-organisation would have the advantage of honesty; only it would have to have its seat and its direction in the country itself, and not be influenced by elements whose political needs are often quite opposite ones.


The Jewish Proletariat in France.

In the latest number of the "Review of Reviews" Paul Pottier publishes a very interesting article under the title "Essay upon the Jewish Proletariat in France," in which he examines the condition of the Israelite workmen and sets forth the causes of their pitiable circumstances of life, which he would see chiefly in the exploitation of the poor by their fellow-believers. According to the author's calculation there are in France about 79,000 Jews, of whom 45,000 fall to Paris. In the provinces the neighbourhood of Nancy counts the most Jews, namely 4467, and that of Bayonne the fewest, namely 2000. The other Jews are distributed among the following chief centres: Bordeaux, Lyons, Marseilles, Epinal, Lille and Besançon. According to Pottier there are in Paris about 20,000 Jewish proletarians. This figure rests upon the lists of the Jewish charity bureau of the Rue Saint-Claude; but one may well assume that the Jewish proletarians are still more numerous, for there are also among them numerous ill-paid workmen who have nevertheless never begged for support. The Paris Jews are especially employed in the following handicrafts: cap-makers, tailors, shoemakers, joiners, workers in furs and in india-rubber wares. Many naturally also carry on a hawking trade in shoe-laces, play-