Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 5 · 3 February 1899
3printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 5. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

…officer, the professor, who has heard of Zionism — for that our enemies have not been able to prevent with all their arts — asks the Jewish millionaire with whom he associates: "What is this about Zionism?" — and receives as answer either a contemptuous shrug of the shoulders or the smiling information: "A folly of a few obscure scribblers who wish to make themselves talked of, and of a few Russian Jews who are nothing else than Nihilists in disguise." No wonder that the questioners content themselves with this enlightenment and then see us in the light in which the Jewish millionaires exhibit us to them. Opportunity is not often offered us of correcting the falsified opinion, and it is of course a great hindrance to the Zionist movement, especially in the first stages of its road, that it is not rightly appreciated by the Christian circles whose goodwill would be uncommonly important for it, and upon whose goodwill Zionism could certainly reckon if the Christian world were better informed about it.

The Jewish millionaires — that I may not have to repeat it again and again, I emphasise it once more, once for all: it is well understood that here I always speak only of their majority, of the average of the species, whereas I know very well that among them there is a minority of altogether estimable exceptions — the Jewish millionaires, I say, have no right to speak in the name of the Jewish people, for they do not know it and have no touch with it. All their utterances upon Zionism are therefore purely personal opinions, which express merely the feeling of the speakers themselves and of their narrowest social circle. But that the Jewish financial magnates are not Zionists is intelligible. Their wealth affords them all the satisfactions that money can procure — and there are nowadays very few satisfactions indeed that have not their market price. Why should they be Zionists? In order to improve their material position? That they have no need of. In order to serve a historical and moral ideal? They have no ideal, and the mere naming of the word suffices to excite their mirth or their pity. In order to escape insult and persecution? They do not suffer from these. For them, in fact, antisemitism does not exist. They belong to the privileged orders. They are distinguished by the State with orders, with patents of nobility, with appointments to the Upper House. They regard themselves as members of the aristocracy, and the aristocracy allows the claim. The Christian aristocrat sees in the Jewish millionaire an embodied fortune, a figure upon two legs, and for a figure every realist has respect. In money matters race-prejudice, like good-fellowship, comes to an end. (Lively applause.)

But more than that! The Christian aristocrat finds the Jewish millionaire with whom he consorts socially, in spite of his own antisemitism on principle, quite a nice fellow as a man too, and often lets him feel this by a markedly cordial treatment. That is easy to explain psychologically. The Christian aristocrat often sues for a place upon the board of management of his Jewish friend's bank, and for the well-filled hand of his daughter. Out of a natural need of self-respect he persuades himself that the man whose money he accepts, nay eagerly seeks, under various legal titles, is also in and for himself, apart from his fortune, a desirable acquaintance for him. For he would indeed have to be ashamed before himself if he had to confess that in the flattered chairman of the great bank, in the father of the marriageable heiress of millions, he sees nothing but the bundle-Jew in a salon edition (Lively applause), and devotes to him all the feelings with which his antisemitic heart is full. One must indeed be a Caesar to say: Non olet, "It does not smell" — for the ladies who do not yet understand Latin. (Lively merriment.) This cynicism in the grand style in the greed of money is too imperatorial for ordinary noblemen. The Christian aristocrat who strives after Jewish money holds himself bound, before the world and before himself, first to purify this money by a bath of respect for the great Jews. (Lively applause.)

I am therefore altogether inclined to believe that the Jewish millionaires are sincere when they say: "Antisemitism? What is that? Why, there is no such thing!" In most cases this is in all probability no feigned naïveté, but genuine. They feel no antisemitism! And when other Jews assure them that they do indeed feel it, they know an infallible means of escaping it: the persecuted man need only become a millionaire and a baron, and the persecution ceases at once. (Lively merriment and applause.)

That is their solution of the Jewish question. We must admit that at the first glance this solution appears more elegant, more agreeable, more desirable than the Zionist one. We shall, however, probably astonish the Jewish millionaires in question when we tell them, first, that their solution of the Jewish question is not accessible to every persecuted man, and secondly, that it is by no means so final as it seems.

Judaism in the countries of the West was in process of dying out. Baptisms, mixed marriages, free-thinking were thinning its ranks, and the moment could be approximately foretold at which it would have completely dissolved. This, it is true, would not necessarily have signified at once the death of Judaism itself, for in the East it was not dying so fast, and there was after all the danger that the process of dissolution might be arrested by the inflow of fresh Jewish blood from the East. But against this danger one could protect oneself. A nice little prohibition of the immigration of foreign Jews the Jewish millionaires could doubtless have carried through with their influence, and probably they would not have had to beg the Governments long for it. Under the protection of a strict closing of the frontier, over whose inexorable execution the great Jews would have kept sharp-eyed watch, the evil of Judaism would then gradually have been extinguished. That is the method which has proved itself against epidemics also.

The antisemitism of to-day, it is true, will hear nothing even of the slow melting away and seeping off; but the great Jews do not believe in it, or hold it for a passing phenomenon. Zionism now brings this clever plan to nothing. Living foreign Jews may be excluded from the countries of the West; thoughts may not. But once the Zionist thought penetrates a body of Jewry, it will no longer die; then it grows young again from within, even without inflow from abroad. Then there are Jews once more, they are noticed once more, in the Jewish millionaires too their quality as Jews is perceived once more, they are no longer believed when they say that they are good Aryans like all other Aryans, and that is disgusting ...

Here you have the great crime of Zionism. Certain millionaires had patiently, softly, cunningly sawn almost entirely through the cable that bound them to Judaism, and hung now only by a slender Jewish thread, which one last, trifling effort would have snapped. Then Zionism cries over all the roofs:

"There is a Judaism! We are a race! There is unhappily also a scum of Judaism, but even this scum is still Jewish. That indeed is our pain, but we cannot alter it." Without willing it, we strike barbed hooks into the flesh of the cowardly runaways and bind them again to Judaism, from which they hoped to get free in all quietness. They wish to dive under, and Zionism lays itself about their well-nourished bodies like a singular combination of swimming-belt and strait-waistcoat. (Lively applause and clapping of hands.) Zionism interrupts the prescription of the legal claims