No. 48 — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
A Rabbinical Opinion on Zionism.
I am not one of those who imagine that cultural, political or social questions can be solved by ingenious theories. That was precisely the error of the defence against antisemitism, that men gave themselves over to the naive belief that by the utterances of famous men and by ethical disquisitions a movement could be combated which is rooted deep in the emotional life of the nations. A movement such as the Zionist can be established only by demonstrating its historical and social necessity. Zionism shall attest its right to exist by its capacity to exist. It shall set the living deed in the place of the phrase. It shall do away with the humbug of the "mission" and bring into force the instinct of self-preservation, which in a people is as strong as in the single individual. The chief task of Zionism is to clear all the artificial obstacles out of the way of the natural, organic development of Jewry. Zionism will conquer, not because we are such splendid fellows, but because the laws press towards it. Circumstances, and not thinkers, create ideas.
Meanwhile we have to-day still to do for the most part with an opposition too lazy to think, to which authority is everything and logic nothing. When a troop of "Germanic" rabbis, a great part of whom are able to read Hebrew only with the help of the lexicon, soars to the assertion that Zionism stands in contradiction with the teaching of Judaism, then it is surely in place to scourge the ignorance and the hypocrisy of these "teachers in Israel". It was therefore a happy thought that the Central Committee of the Zionist Union for Germany resolved to obtain the opinions of famous rabbis upon the relation of the Jewish religion to Zionism. The first opinion has come in from His Reverence Chief Rabbi Dr. Dünner. It runs:
Esteemed Sirs!
In your valued letter of 5 July 1898 you desire to know my view upon two questions, in a negative and in a positive sense. You will pardon me if I combine the two questions into one and formulate it thus:
Is the aim of Zionism — the creation of a publicly and legally secured home in Palestine by means of the expedient promotion of the settlement of Palestine with Jewish agriculturists, artisans and tradesmen; an organisation and consolidation of the whole of Jewry by suitable local and general institutions in conformity with the laws of the land; further, the strengthening of Jewish self-respect and national consciousness; finally, preparatory steps towards obtaining the assents of governments which are necessary for the attainment of the aforesaid aim,
in contradiction with any religious law of Judaism, or is it rather to be regarded as an endeavour pleasing to God and a religious duty?
The reason for this formulation of your question will be evident to you if you consider that the expression "Basle Programme", which in your question forms the cardinal point, does not appear entirely distinct and clear to me, who am not familiar with the particulars of this programme as it was developed in detail at Basle. If, however, as regards its fundamental ideas, it contains nothing other than what is set forth upon the first page of the printed enclosure likewise sent to me, then the question as I have formulated it may well render your intention in putting it completely.
This programme of Zionism has called forth in many quarters a fairly violent opposition and has met with incomprehensible obstinate hostility. In the ranks of the opponents men see in the striving after the attainment of this aim a contradiction with the Messianic promises of Judaism. — Our forefathers, from the most recent of them back into grey antiquity, would have looked up with no small astonishment if any Jewish authority had characterised such an aim and such means, undertaken by contemporaries, as contrary to religion. What? The creation of a publicly and legally secured home in Palestine a negation of the Messianic promises? Impossible could this thought have arisen in our ancestors. — Even the founding of a Jewish State in the Holy Land they would have regarded as the highest happiness, if it came about not by revolutionary means but with the permission of the government of the land. If only for the reason that a great and most important part of our religious laws can come to execution and realisation only therein. Even that Babylonian authority of the second generation of the Amoraim, who in this respect stands quite alone and who held the immigration of Babylonian Jews into Palestine to be a religious transgression, would for the reason given have joyfully seized the pilgrim's staff if for the Jews of that day, as in the time of Cyrus, the return and the rebuilding of the Temple had been possible by legal means. Certainly, the founding of a Jewish State in Palestine in our days would signify a fulfilment of the Messianic promises as little as did the return from the Babylonian captivity under Zerubbabel. Our age is indeed still very far removed from that human perfection which is set up by the prophets as the indispensable condition of a mankind ripe for the Messiah. But do two conceptions exclude one another merely because they are different? If, then, the last prophets, the men of the "Great Assembly" and so many countless Jewish men of eminence during the Second Temple nevertheless saw in the existence of a Jewish State, without the Messianic promises having come to pass, no negation of the same, then we to-day may certainly not set the stamp of contrariety to religion upon an analogous endeavour.
But how comes it that your programme is decidedly rejected upon the pious side as well? To what circumstance is this confusion of conceptions to be ascribed? In the first place the cause of this hostility lies in the timorousness which has generally taken possession of Jewish minds through the sad experience that even the noblest deeds of our fellow-tribesmen are suspected by the inhuman tendency of the times as an outgrowth of the lack of a fatherland. Ruled by this timorousness, even the otherwise clear-sighted leaders of Jewry unconsciously see religious transgressions even there where lofty sentiments, flowing out of the religious life, express themselves vigorously. But then you also, gentlemen, have yourselves contributed not a little to this deplorable antipathy upon the side first named. Your programme lacks one condition which alone would be able to remove the scruples of our courageous but also strictly pious co-religionists. The addition that the attainment of the aim, as well as the application of the means in question, may be intended and brought to execution only in agreement with the Jewish traditional law, ought not to be lacking in your programme. — Herewith I believe I have complied with your wish, and I sign myself
Respectfully Dr. J. H. Dünner Chief Rabbi.
What will the gentlemen of the Protest Rabbis in Germany now say? We believe the gentlemen will not let their rock-firm assurance be shaken by an objective, calm consideration. At bottom they know themselves that they speak neither in the name of consistent Jewry nor in the spirit of historical Judaism. They serve merely the Jewish bourgeoisie, which for decades has swayed the sceptre in the camp of indifferentism. Probably our thorough-bred Germanic rabbis will answer that for them the opinion of a foreign rabbi is worthless. Well, we shall shortly wait upon them with opinions of German rabbis also. F. S.
Dr. Adler Again.
Vienna, 30 November.
The London rabbi Adler, whose hypocritical declamations against Zionism are already known, has once more made himself heard. For this purpose he misused the pulpit of the North London Synagogue, where he delivered a Sabbath sermon which positively teems with unworthy attacks, calumnies and insinuations. Withal this comedian rolled his eyes in the accustomed manner, protested his naturalised patriotism, expounded verses of the Bible falsely, and the whole shameful drivel was published under the title "Religious versus Political Zionism". That from the truly religious side there is not only nothing to be objected against our movement, but that it deserves full devotion, is completely established by the authoritative opinions and by the active example precisely of the most pious among the orthodox, such as our unforgettable Mohilewer was. A man of undisputed authority, the London Chief Rabbi Dr. Gaster, belongs to the leaders of our movement. It is therefore simply an impertinence when Adler comes forward as the exclusive lessee of the religious principles of Judaism. That for the rest he lets himself be employed as the hireling of a clique to which our sound, popular movement is a thorn in the eye will not further astonish us. To free Judaism from the influence of such people will surely become one of the most imperishable services of Zionism. To enter into a refutation of the individual points of Adler's unctuous twaddle we do not hold worth the trouble. In the first place he has repeated all his old fairy-tales, long since led ad absurdum. Secondly, our argumentation might make the impression as
