(continued from page 6)
…effective spirit, which will pour itself forth from the centre over the whole earth, wherever Jews are. Then will the Jews in Palestine and the Jews in the remaining lands and quarters of the globe be able to fulfil their mission. It lies, therefore, precisely in the interest of the Mission-Rabbis that Zionism should unite, organise or centralise the scattered mass of the Jews physically and morally, culturally and intellectually, for without that their mission-idea will never be realised.
III.
If, however, we will be quite candid, we must here uncover the other chief motive — not merely of the Mission-Rabbis, but of the German Jews in general — which drives them to opposition against Zionism. It is the fear that the Jews might through Zionism lose their position in the West European countries, materially, and for the present politically also, still so favourable. The English Jews do not share this fear; hence a quite considerable part of English Jewry, and not the worst part, has already joined the Zionist movement, for the English Jews know their English people, its respect for right and law, its wide outlook and its high-mindedness, its sympathy for freedom and independence, and therefore also its sympathy for all freedom-movements of oppressed peoples. The English Jews have the firm confidence that the English people sees in Zionism absolutely no ground for undoing the Jewish emancipation, and that if all the Jews of England were to become Zionists, this would not offer the slightest occasion for withdrawing from them even one of the rights which now belong to them by law and by right.
The German Jews have not the same good and firm confidence in the high-mindedness of the German people. Nor is this to be taken ill of them. German anti-Semitism ever reminds them how precarious their position in Germany is. They know too well how little beloved they are among the Germans in spite of their so fervent endeavours after assimilation, or precisely because of them; they know that although they be Commercial and Judicial Councillors, Sanitary and Town Councillors, advocates and men of letters, yet a deep social chasm everywhere divides them from the German people, and that the majority of people accord them just barely the most indispensable measure of respect and confidence. There it is natural and well comprehensible that they do not wish to make their position still worse, but rather avoid everything that could even remotely offer occasion for pressing them altogether to the wall. They fear, then, that the nationality-endeavours of the Zionists might call forth repressive measures on the part of the anti-Semites, that anti-Semitism might upon the ground of Zionism make the attempt to move the Government and the Parliaments to undo the emancipation. There are indeed people enough in Germany who regard the Jewish emancipation as the cause of all evil and would therefore like to have it abolished again the sooner the better. The fear of the German Jews is therefore not so much wretched cowardice as rather cautious prudence. They know the German Michel and know their insecure position over against him. We understand very well, then, why the German Jews in their overwhelming majority have hitherto placed themselves in the following of their Rabbis, and why it is welcome to them that these should employ the so beautiful and lofty mission-idea as a battering-ram for the attack upon the Zionists and as a shield for defence against them. If the alliance between Rabbis and bankers were not in itself already a natural one, and one mostly founded in family relations, they would nevertheless be obliged now to ally themselves against the Zionists, for both have the same interests. But because nobody will name aloud the true ground of the opposition against Zionism, the others are glad that the Rabbis push so eminently religious a ground into the foreground, behind which they all believe they can entrench themselves. Let us then seek first to remove and to enfeeble the secret but true ground of opposition; then the officially and loudly proclaimed ground will lose much of its force and of its prestige; men will easily come to an understanding about it and be able to arrive at a common way of thinking about it. If this is then attained, an agreement upon a common way of action will also be possible.
Can Zionism really injure the German Jews politically and materially? We do not believe it; we are rather convinced of the contrary.
The German Jews now belong, in political respects, mostly to the Liberal and Progressive parties; indeed a part of them reckon themselves to that party of the Social Democrats which has long been designated from above as hostile to the State. About this there has already been much complaint and outcry from the remaining, the so-called State-preserving parties; but have special measures on that account been set on foot against the Jews as such? Would anyone have dared, because the leader of the Berlin Social Democrats is a Jew, to make the proposal to withdraw the franchise from the Berlin Jews? It would lie so near to apply the lever against emancipation precisely from that point — that the Jews press into the political parties of the Germans or even attach themselves to the State-hostile and religion-hostile Social Democracy. Therewith one might long ago have made feeling against the Jews in wide circles of the German people; but every agitation of the kind has miscarried and has come to grief upon the sound instincts of the people. No man in all Germany, not even the most narrow-minded anti-Semite, will hold Zionism to be dangerous to the State, or could come upon the thought that thereby the German nation or any political party among the Germans could be injured, wherefore one would have to proceed against the Zionists or against the Jews in general. Everyone sees at the first glance that Zionism has not the least thing to do either with the internal politics of a country or with its political parties. On the contrary, all the political parties of Germany, perhaps with the exception of the Social Democratic, will greet it with joy and satisfaction if the Jews occupy themselves with their own, national affairs and keep away from theirs; but on that account it will occur to nobody to dismiss the Jews from the other parties or to forbid them admission. To wish to arraign them on that account before right and law — to that no Government and no parliamentary majority will lend a hand.
In general the emancipation stands unshakably firm; no ruler and no Parliament can be induced to stain itself with the everlasting shame, in the annals of the world's history, of having robbed a whole people, or a part of its subjects or fellow-citizens, of their sole rights and delivered them over to the caprice of their enemies. Even the greatest enemies of the Jews know quite precisely that it is wholly impossible to undo the Jewish emancipation or to restrict it in its extent and its significance. One would at the same time have to overthrow and alter the whole imperial constitution and those of the individual States; indeed the entire public law would be set tottering if recognised imperial and State citizens were simply robbed of their political and civil rights or arbitrarily restricted therein. Such a thing one might venture only against a directly State-hostile party. But not even the greatest pettifogger in the world will succeed in representing the Zionists as a State-hostile party which had in view the destruction or the injuring of the German Empire or of any German State, or the diminution of their power and their prestige. In the political and legal position of the German Jews, then, nothing at all will be altered, even if they all become Zionists. And again, Zionism will in no way hinder them, so long as they are and wish to remain German citizens of the State, from making use of all the rights of such and from availing themselves of all the advantages of this position.
