Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 38 · 23 September 1898
7printed page
scan 7 of 16

No. 38. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.

(continued from page 6)

…not in all, the Jewish colonists have borne themselves even as heroes.

I must point to one of the fights in Petra, where only after collisions lasting for days did this little colony come by its right in face of superior numbers.

The stamp of the Galus is therefore, as I have said, absolutely not to be observed upon the colonists; upon the old perhaps still, upon the rising generation in no wise.

A certain narrowness of the horizon has indeed set in, thanks to the narrowing of their activity. One must put oneself into the souls of the colonists who went to Palestine years ago. What was it that drove a great part of them — let us say those who possessed the greatest influence — to Palestine? It was the thought that in Palestine a centre would grow up, that they were the pioneers, that the whole of Jewry would follow after them. And this thought was bound to be shattered upon hard reality. Little by little the hopes had to be lowered, and hence a great slackening in this regard has set in among the colonists. Only since the Congress of Basle has new life again entered into these colonies, and not from material grounds alone. I may well say, not from material grounds at all — for the colonists have hardly so very much to expect from the present Zionist activity — but rather from purely ideal ones; and I must say that they have not shrunk from confessing Zionism openly in Palestine, although they were hampered at every step in this respect.

The administration of Baron Rothschild, which since the Congress of Basle — I do not speak of the whole of it, let us say of a great part — cherishes a great dread of publicity, has sought at every step to make Zionism ridiculous among the colonists and among the Palestinian Jews generally. But I can tell you that, although I am not commissioned thereto, I was yet a dozen times directly requested by hundreds of Jewish families to bring you the greetings of almost all the colonists. For what animates them is the hope that they will not remain in so narrow a circle, that their centre will be enlarged, that out of these 5000 Jewish peasants there will in time grow 100,000, that they will then find satisfaction for themselves, and that they will not be exposed to such ideal privations as has been the case hitherto.

Before I come to the end of my report, permit me to pronounce my judgment in respect of the system of colonisation hitherto followed.

The present colonisation effects:

a) the enrichment of all the Turkish officials and Effendis, b) the enrichment of all the surrounding villages, c) contempt for the Jew on the part of the other population, by reason of the humiliations which the Jew has to endure on account of the infiltration, d) administration-management and therewith cringing, e) despondency in the ranks of the colonists, f) planlessness and chance, so that unhealthy places like Chedera also are occupied, because this whole activity was not permitted to proceed according to one uniform plan, because absolute rationality could not be brought into the business of the colonisation of Palestine. For this reason the best projects came to nothing at every step; for this reason men had to fling themselves upon sites which have called forth grave sicknesses, sites which could have been taken into consideration at all only under a colonisation planned upon a great scale, after long years of labour, g) the creation of small colonies which are for that reason exceedingly weak and for that reason occasion far greater costs, and h) in part also Arabisation, owing to the want of a large number of Jews.

What I understand by this I will tell you briefly. By Arabisation I do not understand the outward Arabisation in respect of language; the Arabic language in particular is not especially known among the colonists. Unhappily! I understand by it a certain sinking of the moral level, which in the case of a small body of Jews amid a vast Arab population is unavoidable.

Whether the small colonisation, or let us say colonisation without regulated conditions, will be able to accomplish much is hard to determine. The views of those who have hitherto colonised in Palestine tend to this, that one may indeed found one or two smaller colonies yearly after the old system, but no more; that is the opinion of — I may well say — all without exception of the persons who are active in the colonisation of Palestine and who have expressed this opinion to me. A single one only has spoken somewhat more optimistically.

It is no wonder! The entry of Jews into Palestine is forbidden, the purchase of land is prohibited, the building of houses is not permitted. How is one to colonise under such conditions? The colonisation of Palestine must be a concern of the whole people if it is to have success, and must be carried on publicly. The other, the colonisation hitherto pursued, with which we may indeed sympathise as an experiment, has nothing in common with the solution of the Jewish question.

My conclusion therefore runs:

We must strive unswervingly that the gates of Palestine be opened to the Jews, that they may acquire landed property unhindered, that we obtain guarantees in respect of dependence and privileges in respect of the tax upon produce. In the matter of culture the status quo in the colonies on the part of the Turkish Government is sufficient. Then may the work of the people begin!

Until then we condemn the infiltration, while the raising of the existing Jewish masses of the people in Palestine, which, as we have set forth above, are fitted thereto, we may strive after even now by colonisation and by industrial undertakings. To both ends our new instrument, the future Bank, shall help us.

(Stormy and long-continued applause and hand-clapping on the part of the Congress. The speaker is congratulated from all sides.)


The Week.

Vienna, 21st September 1898.

Revision. France means at last to bestow upon the waiting world the revision of the Dreyfus trial. The much-named truth, then, draws near. Yet one cannot greet it with an unclouded and entire joy. For of the revision that is here bestowed upon the world the same holds good as of every other gift. The willing, open hand was wanting. That detracts from the offering. The revision had to be begged for, nay, well-nigh extorted; the sense of justice had to be pressed upon the French. It is no voluntary gift at all. And during the procedure of the begging we have lost our faith in the nobility of a nation that men once called the great nation.

* * *