Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 37
"French Orient."
On the Palestine Journey of Wilhelm II.
By O. Erter.
Is there a French Orient?
Fifty years ago E. Charrière published in Paris a very comprehensive collection of all the diplomatic documents bearing upon the history of Franco-Ottoman relations, and in the preface he made the remark that through this collection a "French Orient was being brought to light." Charrière's remark was, up to a certain degree, correct. Ever since Franz I. of France, in a letter conveyed by Johann Frangipani in the year 1525, had summoned the Sultan Soliman the Great to an alliance with France, there was established between Paris and Constantinople a relation by means of which France obtained a kind of right of protection over the Christians in the Orient, a right which through three centuries found its expression in the so-called Capitulations. A kind of right of protection, not a protectorate! In the Levant especially France sought to keep this customary exercise of its solicitude for the Oriental Christians in force, and in the end it was on that account that it fell into the war with Russia, occasioned, as is well known, by the dispute over the Holy Places.
Far earlier, towards the end of the tenth century, it had been the first Frenchman upon the papal chair, Sylvester II., who had issued to the whole of Christendom the first call for help on behalf of the Christian sanctuaries in Palestine. When thereupon the French knighthood took the most prominent part in the Crusades, set up French thrones in Jerusalem and Constantinople, and Guy de Lusignan, after his fall from the throne of Jerusalem, obtained from the Sultan Saladin the preservation of the sanctuaries, there formed itself, before ever any grounds in international law existed, something in the nature of a legend of France's privileged share in the destiny of the Oriental Christians.
Thus the papacy and the crusaders did the preliminary work upon which the diplomatic claim of France to the protection of the Oriental Christians was afterwards founded — a claim, to be sure, for which Franz I. laid the foundation by the most Christian of all means, the summons to Soliman for an alliance against Karl V.
It is enough to recall this course of events in its broad outlines in order to understand why France is so deeply disquieted by the approaching Palestine journey of Wilhelm II. that the French Cardinal Langénieux has called upon the Pope as witness for the French guardianship over the Oriental Christians. Leo XIII. has complied with this call and declared that France possesses in the Orient a protectorate entrusted to her by Providence and confirmed by national treaties, which must under all circumstances be maintained.
But is this protectorate so well founded in law and in history that all the world, the non-Catholic world included, would be simply bound to respect it? The appeal to Pope Sylvester II. and to the French crusaders is manifestly quite without binding force; romantic reminiscences establish no right. And the alleged "treaties" — are they in fact so incontestable that one need merely cite them in order to furnish proof in international law? They are, as has already been said above, the so-called Capitulations, which, however, are of an altogether one-sided character. In them the Sultans grant, thanks to the mediation of France, alleviations for the Christians, but they bind themselves to nothing: neither to refrain from revoking those alleviations, nor to recognise France's office of mediator as a perpetual one. Very characteristic in this direction is the memorandum which in the year 1672 the ambassador extraordinary d'Arvieux, sent to Constantinople, addressed to Ludwig XIV. "The Sultan," it runs in this memorandum, "tolerates indeed that the King of the French should protect the Latin Christians, but not that he should meddle in the affairs of those Christians who are his subjects." Treaties, then, the Capitulations can hardly be called, and Abdul Hamid, the present Sultan, strives after nothing with greater zeal, as is known to all the European chancelleries, than their abolition. Still less, however, do they establish a protectorate of France which, according to the French conception, is to extend not merely to the French Christians but to all Christians in the Orient.
If France now trembles lest the Palestine journey of Wilhelm II. should raise the prestige of Germany in the Orient and shake that of France, it may well have its good reasons for it. But no one will be able to see in the journey of Wilhelm II. an unjust irruption into her Oriental sphere of influence, not even because the Pope confirms the French claim. In the first place, it is for the present merely French spectre-seeing that Wilhelm II. is coming to the Levant in order to claim a protectorate for himself and his empire; in the second place, there is nothing more self-evident than that the great Powers should themselves attend to the protection of their Christian nationals in the Orient instead of leaving it to others. When France was still the world-commanding European power, it followed of itself that the right of protection over the Oriental Christians fell to her; but now there exists a great German Empire with a powerful Oriental policy, and it is surely too much to demand of it that it should concede to the French the protection of the Catholic Germans in the Orient. The legal title claimed by France, which was from the outset very doubtful, has simply been rendered void by the historical facts, and it contradicts these facts also that the Pope should now afresh recognise it.
In his gifted personality Wilhelm II. represents the modern reality; guided by all the good spirits of our age, he comes to Jerusalem as the friend of the Sultan, and without needing to stir a finger he raises the German prestige in the Orient. France and the Pope, on the other hand, stand upon the unsteady ground of a faded romanticism which braces itself impotently against that which history has brought to pass. A French Orient! In that memorandum of the envoy d'Arvieux to Ludwig XIV. there occurs the sentence: "the Turks are friends only of those who ill-treat them." The Palestine journey of Wilhelm II. is surely a shining proof that d'Arvieux did not understand the Turks. For centuries the European Powers, together with d'Arvieux, likewise failed to understand Turkey. Wilhelm II. comes to Jerusalem without prejudice and without yellowed legal titles, as a prince of civilisation and of peace; he has no need to have himself legitimated by the Pope as the arm of the Church; he is the immense moral force which works through itself alone, and for the further destinies of Palestine, for the appreciation of the value which it may have in the development of the Orient, for the renewal of its prosperity buried through two millennia, the visit of the German Emperor will in any case be of greater significance than the obsolete French claim to a protectorate. Here there are imponder-
