Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 32 · 12 August 1898
2scan
of 16
Facsimile · scan 2 of 16
Scan of scan 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

“Die Welt” — No. 32

Looking more closely, in the change of methods forced upon him he wrought perhaps nothing harder and more cruel than what he did to the Jews, whom personally he by no means repulsed from him as he did the Poles; and yet it is a respectful bow before the greatness of his historical personality that one observes among the Jews in these days. He mobilised antisemitism, in the erroneous opinion that with it he could successfully combat the Social Democrats. The failure was monstrous, for in the end antisemitism turned against himself; but the antisemitism which he afterwards shook off from him was now there once for all. What a highly developed historical sense it takes that the Jews do not curse the mighty and violent dead man for it, but willingly acknowledge his greatness, although of all men they have the least reason to be grateful to him! It is only one example, but it serves excellently for illustration. Lasker's personal friends relate that he, after being treated by Bismarck in the most contemptible manner, yet never ceased to acknowledge respectfully the great adversary who had earlier used him for his works and flattered him.

We rejoice sincerely that into the mourning of the German people for Bismarck no discord has been brought from the Jewish side. Neither fear nor sentimentality determines us, but respect for the omnipotence of historical development and for the great individualities which are called to carry it forward. We Jews have some right to lay stress upon our historical existence, which has outlasted all the upheavals of the millennia, and as an individuality among the peoples we stand behind no nation. As such we mean to preserve ourselves. That the Bismarck era made harder for us, but it has also steeled us. When Bismarck retired, the beginnings of Zionism were already at hand, and to-day no one any longer denies that Zionism is a firm pillar. In Zionism Jewry has become conscious once more of its national-historical individuality. We wish every people from our heart that it may become partaker of the blessings of a prosperous national development under the leadership of powerful personalities; only we too crave these blessings. Upon Bismarck we had nothing to hope for; his pupil upon the imperial throne is free of prejudice and narrowness of heart. To him we set our hope, and we are far from embittering that hope for ourselves by gloomy recollections. As a mighty historical monument the figure of Bismarck, as we saw and lived through it, remains standing for us also; but a new, modern life floods past this monument, and it is embodied in that high-striving imperial man who, himself an individuality of sharp and powerful profile, fills the gap which has arisen through Bismarck's departure.


Our National Science.

By Dr. P. Felix.

In the strife over Jewish nationality there has hitherto, strikingly enough, never yet been brought into the field a witness that weighs heavier than all theoretical disquisitions: I mean the most eminent manifestation of the Jewish spirit in our century, the “Jewish science.”

In lay circles one commonly conceives under Jewish science a scientific grounding of Judaism, that is to say a kind of Jewish theology and apologetics; and if one considers that the nurseries of this science are designated by names such as “Jewish-Theological Seminary” or “Israelitish-Theological Institute,” one must at the least find that widespread error comprehensible. To be sure, the teachers working at these institutions have as a rule themselves enjoyed a rabbinical preparatory training, and their aim in turn is the forming of capable rabbis; but for all that they teach nothing which could in the proper sense be called theology. For a Jewish theology does not exist at all; Judaism has never developed a real dogmatics, and precisely therein consists its world-historical significance, its superiority and its indestructibility. From this is explained also the striking lack of textbooks which bring the religious-ethical content of Judaism to full and exhaustive expression. Nay, more: the history of the Jews has already been written, a history of the Jewish religion is still wanting. None of our great masters has hitherto attempted to set forth the course of development of Jewish doctrine from its beginnings down to the present; even a history of Jewish religious philosophy we do not yet possess, nor is the same likely to be written so soon.

Jewish science therefore bears by no means a one-sidedly religious character, and were this the case it would not deserve the name of a science at all. One cannot speak of it in the same sense as of a Catholic and a Protestant science; it is not “made” by Jews for Jews, but is rather an imposing exertion of strength on the part of the Jewish-national spirit which, awakened to self-consciousness, sought to hold fast for all time what the Jewish people has wrought and created, learned and suffered, thought and sung these three thousand years. In this sublime picture religion is as it were the frame which holds the whole together and at the same time sets it off; in the Jewish religion our nationality first comes to adequate expression, only in its faith could the Jewish people truly live itself out. Nationality and religion condition and complete one another in Judaism; they cannot be conceived at all the one without the other, and whoever would sunder them from one another, be he now a German-national assimilationist rabbi or a religionless national Jew, does not understand Judaism at all, or seeks to deceive himself concerning the contradiction which lies in his own view.

Jewish science may most readily be set in parallel with the classical science of antiquity, just as the Jews are altogether to be called a classical people in the eminent sense of the word, if indeed by that expression the creations of its spirit are to be designated as exemplary for all time and fundamental for the culture of all mankind. What one calls the Greek and the Roman genius is the highest and noblest form of appearance of the Greek and the Roman national spirit, and, detached from it, can by no possibility be grasped and understood. So too can the Jewish religion never be separated from the Jewish people whose genius it represents. Like those two great peoples, the Jews also had their classical language, which remained to them even after the downfall of their state as their most precious national possession, and wound a unifying bond about the scattered members of the people.

For this reason, too, Judaism can so hardly be compared with its great daughter religion. Christianity lacked every national foundation; its confessors were not held together by a common descent and language, history and literature; in the earliest period the Church hovered as it were in the air, and had therefore at an early date to seek to form a church-state and thus to rally the faithful about a firm centre; what it lacked in inward support had to be replaced by outward power. In contrast to this, Judaism in the Diaspora strove only to consolidate itself inwardly, and has thereby, to all persecutions and all the storms of the