No. 25 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…is making great progress everywhere. Subscriptions and inquiries are of late coming in great numbers from South Africa, Canada, North America, etc. In view of the great distances of these countries, an extension of the term for subscription is desired. We shall meet this wish. We further note that from now on, besides the A. Schaaffhausen'sche Bankverein, our central depository, the Norddeutsche Creditanstalt in Koenigsberg i. Pr. and the banking house Gebrüder Arons in Berlin, Mauerstraße 34, will also receive deposits for the purposes of founding the Jewish Colonial Bank. The two latter banks already accept deposits of one hundred marks and upwards, which are deposited in the name of the payer.
The Aliens and the Lords.
Esteemed Editors!
May I ask leave to offer a few remarks upon the article "The Aliens and the Lords," which appeared in the "Welt" of the 10th inst. It deals with the Bill for the admission of destitute aliens (aliens bill) introduced in the English Upper House on the 23rd of May. I read this article with astonishment and great regret. That countries like England and the United States, which otherwise open their gates hospitably to the poorer class of immigrants, might come to close those gates one day for fear of too strong an influx — this anxiety has assuredly long hovered before every thinking Jew. It has occupied the Committee here, which attended to the forwarding of the emigrants during the last great Russian emigration, in the most serious manner; a restrictive American law, though mildly administered, would likewise not be long in coming. It is indeed precisely this anxiety, the difficulty of settling masses of poorer Jews upon foreign soil, which with many has given the chief impulse to Zionism — signs that in England too the growth of this population in the East of London was not gladly seen have not been wanting. It was known that their competition pressed hard upon the native workman and provoked his resentment And can we, if we would be just, censure this ill-feeling? In oversea countries it turns against Chinese and Indians as well. The English Government long closed its ear to the complaints brought forward; Gladstone as well as Lord Salisbury have — I remember it precisely, opposed the motions in question. And if the latter now, letting fall his earlier objections to restriction, assents to the Bill, he must have good grounds for it. — Anti-Semitism is not in play with the English ministers. From Mr. Leo Raphael's descriptions, one less familiar with English conditions and the English character may easily come to wholly erroneous conclusions, I have to-day read over the report of the debate (Times of the 24th of May) and can find nothing in it which warrants the vehement utterances of the article referred to. Everything entirely matter-of-fact, calm, nothing offensive to Jews. The mover (Earl of Hardwicke) laid stress upon it that the resentment of the English population in the East of London has nothing to do with race hatred or with any form of anti-Semitism. It is the pecuniary loss of the English workman that produces it. Increased rents, diminished gains, since the new arrival, having small wants, is content with lower wages as well. Lord Salisbury too has set forth the grounds of his assent in clear fashion, and I believe that many a good Jew will find his reasons convincing, however much the matter itself may pain him. We must be just, and must impute no base motives to others who act in self-defence, or believe that they must so act.
Doubtless much may be urged against the views of the champions of the Bill, from the economic standpoint as well. That was done in that sitting also. Who is in the right I cannot presume to judge; I wished here only to censure the one-sidedness and the vehemence of the said article.
What the writer says of the laughter during the debate is likewise calculated to mislead. I noted the three passages in question at which there was laughter; they contained nothing about the immigrants, but referred to incidental matters, such as the barrenness of an inquiry, etc.
But what, in my opinion, must give offence in the article, apart from all else, is the malignity of its tone. To what purpose, for example, such passages as: "England, dripping with the fear of God and the love of man"; to what purpose the enumeration of Lord Salisbury's (alleged) failures in the political field, all over the world? Matters upon which we are far from being clear, and which in any case have nothing to do with this discussion. I confess I had not expected to hear the echo of such well-known utterances, current in the anglophobe daily press, in the columns of the "Welt."
Hamburg, 14th June 1898.
X.
Worthy Editors!
Do Mr. X.'s objections to the article "The Aliens and the Lords" embarrass me? Not in the least: on the contrary. I have not a word to reply to his reproach, for he is perfectly right. I was vehement, in measureless wrath against the authors of the Bill. Certainly I am so still, I am so in a higher degree, and feel myself much tempted to let my wrath — only too well-founded, as I shall show — be felt also by that fellow-tribesman who knows how to defend the aliens bill in such eloquent words. So the English population in the East of London has for some considerable time been out of humour over the increase of Jewish immigration? "And can we" — asks the correspondent — "if we would be just, censure this ill-feeling?" Truly, a great word calmly spoken! If the correspondent's "justice" were to be brought to bear not upon England alone, but upon all countries, then the Jews would have to rid the world of the Jewish question by a mass suicide; for where have we not provoked ill-feeling by our appearance? Wherever we have wished for a share in God's light and air, there we have provoked ill-feeling "and if we would be just, can we censure this ill-feeling?"
The correspondent finds my tone towards the Lords incomprehensible; he has read over the debate in the "Times" and finds "everything decent, matter-of-fact, calm. Nothing offensive to Jews"; the mover had even expressly laid stress upon it that the English workman's complaint of his Jewish competitor "has nothing of race hatred or of any form of anti-Semitism about it," that it was a question merely of "self-defence." If the correspondent only knew how naïve this objectivity is! There are various ways of making an end of a man: the peasant slays with a club or an axe, the nobleman with a rapier, a lord with a Bill. (When one speaks of English conditions, a pun comes involuntarily to one's pen.) The same economic motive, only in somewhat other words, has been urged by Wagner and Stöcker in Germany, Schönerer and Lueger with us in Vienna, P. Stojalowski and his people in Galicia.
The correspondent feels himself offended by my malignant tone towards England, for which he seems to have a particular respect. England, with its strength and its weakness, is not wholly unknown to me; but precisely thence comes the wrath against "England, dripping with the fear of God and the love of man." If any land on the wide earth is bound out of self-respect, out of shame before the world, to open its gates to the poor, persecuted Jew who seeks work, that land is England. One may forgive all nations their Jewish policy, if one be as objective as the correspondent — only not the English. When an agricultural land closed in upon itself, such as Russia, declares that it forbids foreign Jews to enter, one will recognise in these prohibitions the expression of a low state of culture, but one will not be able to reproach the representatives of this elementary policy with inconsistency. But England! Is there a spot of earth where the English have not, in the name of culture, forced their intelligence and their labour upon an unwilling population? The very part which the English, so warmly defended by the correspondent, now play was played fifty years ago by the Chinese — and against whom? Against the English! England compelled China, in the name of culture, to open door and gate to European enterprise and European labour, compelled it by a bloody war; and that same England refuses to let a handful of human beings earn a dry crust of bread by hard toil!
The correspondent is — I repeat it — right; I am very vehement in the matter and in the tone. But the same reproach was once made to me also by an anti-Semitic colleague, who proved to me by a thousand grounds, in the most distinguished calm, the justification of anti-Semitism. My answer ran: When the wolf holds the lamb by the throat and declares to it that he has a thousand reasons for devouring it, the lamb will indeed defend itself in vain, but it will be permitted to call the wolf a wolf.
Prof. Dr. Leon Kellner.
The Jews in Moravia.
By Berthold Feiwel. (Conclusion.)
Two groups have detached themselves from the great mass of the more or less assimilation-friendly Jewish population of Moravia: the Social Democrats and the Zionists.