Page 8 — "Die Welt" — No. 23
(continued from page 7)
…tions, that he has not the capacity to be as coarse as the rejoinders to the declaration of the Board, from the Zionist side. He declares it to be incorrect that all Russian rabbis are adherents of Zionism. For example, the Chief Rabbi of Lodz, one of the largest Russian congregations, had told him that he could well understand that a rabbi of the extremest Reform might be a Zionist, but that an orthodox rabbi could never do homage to Zionism. The same rabbi had begged him, the speaker, to translate the protest declaration into Hebrew, in order to let it reach all the Russian rabbis, but the speaker had declined it, since he did not know whether the same would also suit the Russian conditions. It was psychically explicable that among the sorely afflicted Russian Jews Zionism, as a rescue out of the utmost distress, has found so passionate, so glowing a following, and also that the German youth, who have so much to suffer under antisemitism, joyfully seize the opportunity. Yet the diagnosis was not yet the cure; even if Zionism be strong under criticism and withstand attacks, it is not thereby yet proved that its aims would be of advantage as a remedy for the whole of Jewry. The speaker turns to the Basle programme and declares the same to be unclear. He cannot comprehend how the colonisation is to serve as a means for the establishment of a publicly, legally secured homestead, and just as little that the raising of Jewish self-consciousness could serve thereto; on the contrary, it must surely be the reverse! The aim must be the colonisation, and the means thereto the public legal guarantees. The speaker asserts that the departed Prof. Schapira, whom he highly reveres, had said to him after a conversation, "we do not differ at all; I too care only for the raising of Jewish self-consciousness, but we cannot say that, or else we lose too many adherents." In a certain sense Zionism had a justification, and the effect was moreover not at all bad; for when a Max Nordau, the author of the Conventional Lies, is to-day enthusiastic for Judaism and for Zionism, then he, the speaker, thanks God for Zionism; yet Zionism was, like so many poisons, only a curative for the disease, and when Judaism should be healed, Zionism too would be a matter disposed of. Point 2 of the protest declaration had in many quarters been taken as an imputation, yet it had been far from the mind of the Board to cast suspicion upon any person whatsoever; rather had it been done in order to remove the erroneous view that all Jews were Zionists. The speaker closes his exposition with the exhortation to further the colonising endeavours in every way.
The second reporter, Dr. Vogelstein, Stettin, who among us is still held in good remembrance from his lecture in the Liberal Society, declares, although he is not a member of the Board and therefore not responsible for the declaration, his agreement with the Board. Zionism was dangerous in a high degree, and it had been high time that the rabbis made front against the further "beguiling" of Jews. The declaration contained nothing offensive to anyone. — Now the speaker delivers a part of his speech from the Liberal Society in a still further deteriorated form! — The aim of Zionism was not worth striving for, because the truly ideal endeavours in Judaism are thereby thrust back. In the further course of his speech the lecturer disavows the previous speaker, with whom he had claimed to agree completely in the judgment of this question, in the following manner: "It is an error that it is a merit of the Zionists when people who had turned wholly away from Judaism are again enthusiastic for it. Zionism will in the end make its adherents entirely estranged from Judaism! That a Jewish distress exists the speaker admits, yet not in the sense of the Zionists. (Here follows again a part of the Liberal speech in a second and still further deteriorated infusion.) To Zionism there belong people who have absolutely no belief in God, and therefore a religious element will never be allowed to have a voice in it.
Zionism had greatly injured the colonisation, and it was urgently necessary to say to the Jews who take an interest in the colonisation: You are working against Zionism if you support the colonisation. After the speaker had declared the Basle programme to be unclear, he closes with the request that the Board's declaration be approved, since a not unanimous assent would make a bad impression. After Dr. David, Düsseldorf, had briefly stated his agreement, he closed in the hope that the meeting would unanimously approve the proceeding of the Board. Now Dr. Maybaum permitted himself a parliamentary salto mortale which was in nothing inferior to those of Herr Abrahamowicz. He extracted, namely, from Dr. David's utterance, which hoped for the approval of the Board's proceeding by the meeting, a motion — though, as he himself said, not parliamentarily correct — to close the discussion and to vote upon the proceeding of the Board. The protest of Dr. Gronemann, Hanover, who had already before announced himself for the word, Dr. Maybaum met by not even allowing him the word upon the order of procedure, but letting the "motion" be voted upon amid great tumult, whereupon it was carried against Dr. Gronemann's vote. Thereupon Dr. Gronemann received the word, and protested energetically against such an overriding by the majority. He declared that he had intended to move the appointment of a special commission, which was to have the task of altering the declaration to suit the times; for even though he was not a Zionist, he must nevertheless recognise that Zionism had now assumed milder forms, and that the protest declaration no longer suited the present form of Zionism. To issue this protest declaration against Zionism in its present form would never find his assent, for it no longer fitted it.
Herewith the point of the order of the day was disposed of.
J.
Zionism and the Orthodox Rabbis.
In the "Krakauer Jüd. Ztg." Ahron Marcus communicates the following:
The really orthodox rabbis, who were united under the chairmanship of Herr Dr. Breuer at the Rabbinical Conference in Frankfort shortly after the Basle Congress, have resolved, towards this new current, whose power they first came to know through the Basle Congress — to take up a position.
We believe we serve the good cause if we publish the resolution here without special authorisation.
-
The declaration of the protest rabbis rests upon error. The openly published theories of Zionism in no way collide with the religious dogmas; on the other hand, it cannot accord with the principles of the German orthodox to render obedience to a leadership which does homage to other principles.
-
It is the duty of orthodoxy to take up an energetic position towards the religious concern of the first rank, the colonisation of Palestine, and in this respect to proceed independently by a parallel action, and to give effect to the same by the support of the native population in the founding of colonies.
-
This question has nothing whatever to do with the religious hopes of the Messianic redemption of the nation. In this we adhere, without any innovation, to our old tradition.
-
The project of State-formation remains, like every political institution in this connexion, entirely outside the programme.