(continued from page 6)
…the leaders of the congregations, that they sit in judgment, that they expound the law. For that the rabbi is there; he can make no law, he is neither the Pope, nor a Cardinal, nor an Archbishop. We have no right to create Jewish laws; we are there only for this, to expound the law, the right, when we are asked whether something stands in accord with the letter of the law or contradicts it.
I have waited to this day for an answer that should prove to me that there is anything in Zionism against the law. No man can prove that there is to be found in the Bible or in the Talmud, in Jewish tradition or history, in the Messianic movements which have often arisen in Judaism, anything from which it could be read out — and that even in the remotest degree — that a position must be taken against Zionism. According to my most inward religious conviction, Zionism is the highest expression of the hoping and the waiting of the Jewish people, the expression of Jewish idealism. In the moment when we give up Zionism, we have shaken the foundations of Judaism. For me it is a quite definite fact that nothing will save Judaism from absolute disappearance so soon as Zionism disappears. The ceremonies in religion, the religious forms, are only the rampart that protects the fortress, but they are not the inner life. For me it is also of the highest significance that in Zionism we have at last found a point which unites the various differences that divide us, which brings together the religious and the non-religious, the orthodox and the non-orthodox, so that these differences vanish and we may reach one another our hands as brethren throughout the whole world. For me it is one of the greatest achievements that I need not ask: "Art thou a good Jew or a bad one? Dost thou keep this or that?"
This question I may not put. With the same zeal, the same enthusiasm, we all find ourselves together in Zionism. Here we can proceed in unity. That is the greatest gain of modern times. It is always being said that Jews could not proceed in unity, that they are at variance among themselves, can never work with one another.
This great, mighty movement has, however, created a centre for Jewish life; the heart in the Jewish body has been released from its numbness. That is one of the greatest achievements that Zionism has so far attained. I cannot speak here of the several phases, I cannot recount how step by step the advance is made. In England we have a comparatively harder struggle than you here. The intelligence which surrounds me here is at all events a clear guarantee for the victory of Zionism. It appears that the youth here are enthusiastic for the ideal, and that youth which is called to be the bearer of the ideal goods not merely of Judaism but also of humanity. I am glad to be able to tell you that slowly but surely we are making progress in England; gradually the intelligent youth join us, gradually we win the bourgeoisie also, and once the Englishmen have been won, they remain — conservative as they are — with us. And now I remind you of the Christian legend of the Emperor Constantine, who in the struggle with his rival saw a cross in the heavens, with the inscription: "In hoc signo vinces." We, my friends, see in the darkly clouded heavens not the shield of David but the star of David slowly rising, as a sign that we will never go under, that in this sign we will fight not a bloody but a moral battle." —
Dr. Gaster's speech was received with stormy applause. In the discussion Dr. Alois Pollak first took the word. As an adherent of spiritual (?) Zionism he must be an opponent of the political. This latter has moreover hitherto done more harm than good. Thus the prohibition of immigration into Palestine was its achievement. To win a territory for poor Jews was quite praiseworthy. Palestine, however, was not suited thereto; there was only one Zionism, the
spiritual, the mission. The speaker spoke visibly to the entertainment of the meeting. Dr. Kahn refuted all these assertions, which could not be taken seriously at all. He begged that the passages in Scripture which speak against Palestine be shown him. Dr. Schnirer corrected him, that the prohibition of immigration had existed already for 16 years. Only ignorance or ill-will could find satisfaction in the putting forth of such assertions. Dr. Weisengrün does not mistake the symptomatic significance of Zionism. It was, however, a question whether, with the divergence between Eastern and Western Jews, a new ghetto would not be created once more for the poor Jews in Palestine. Might it not then perhaps be more advisable to create a vigorous organisation in this country? Editor Schalit: Of an antagonism between Western and Eastern Jews there can be no question. One might at the most designate the Western Jews as the romanticists and the Eastern as the classicists in Zionism. Where we can live ourselves out wholly and entirely, every divergence and every ghetto falls away. Merely to create a Jewish organisation would be not only purposeless, but also impossible on account of the class antagonisms within Judaism. Dr. Werner points to the economic position of the Jews in the various countries and asks Dr. Weisengrün how he conceives, in this country, an organisation of the classes, which are fundamentally different in their claims and views. An organisation with the purpose of deliverance from economic and spiritual distress was worth striving for and attainable. This attainable and expedient organisation was precisely the Zionist one. Dr. Kofesch points out that Dr. Pollak is already bringing forward his offensive assertions for the second time in this week.
The closing word fell to Dr. Gaster. He proved himself a brilliant debater. In a perfectly finished manner he refuted the views of his opponents. And it was precisely his calm, even in the highest emotion, and the measured character of his rejoinder that overcame the opponents. "There is only one mission. Not to spread the Bible, but to keep the Bible, the word of God. Messianism, as certain gentlemen preach it, is a purely Christian product, and has nothing to do with Judaism. For us, however, the word and the tradition hold good. Therefore are we Zionists. And with the goodwill which the Turkish Government has so often shown us, we shall succeed in creating no ghetto, for the ghetto has never been created by Jews, only by Christians, but rather in winning a home for our whole people." In the name of the Zionist student body med. Munk and iur. Piekarski thanked the lecturer. With cheers for Dr. Gaster the assembled company withdrew. Sch.
The Protest Rabbis.
At the general meeting of the Federation of German Rabbis, Dr. Horowig, Frankfort-on-Main, and Dr. Vogelstein, Stettin, delivered to-day the announced report upon "Zionism."
Before entering upon the order of the day, the chairman, Dr. Maybaum, Berlin, set forth, with respect to the protest declaration issued by the Board without the previous knowledge of the Federation, that the Board had held itself bound to take this step, since modern Zionism harbours dangers for Judaism both outwardly and inwardly. In order now to prevent the endeavours of the Zionists from being laid to the charge of all Jews, the Board had been compelled to issue a declaration, and this had to be done, since the Zionist Congress stood before the door and haste was urgently required, without previously asking the meeting for its assent. That the declaration of the Board had been right and timely was proved by the utterance that the protest declaration had been recognised as a classic pronouncement of the patriotism of the Western European Jews.
Thereupon the member of the Board, Dr. Horowig, Frankfort-on-Main, received the word. The speaker declares in lengthy exposi-