Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 20.
(continued from page 1)
… anti-Semitism did in fact diminish very rapidly. A well-known verse in Corneille's "Cid" says: "Et le combat cessait faute de combattants," "The combat ceased, since there were no combatants left." Since the Jews docilely returned into their Ghetto, the Christian community had no need to excite itself about them any longer. If the Jews will be content to be citizens of the second class — no, that is a little too much! — of the third or fourth class, then anti-Semitism disappears, because it becomes objectless. Then they may count upon a benevolence on every hand, which is admittedly mingled with a little contempt — but, good heavens! This earth is, after all, a vale of tears, and the man of understanding knows how to reconcile himself to it.
Yet I will not mock, for at bottom my heart is not in such a mood at all. I am grieved at the blindness of those Jews who console themselves over the evils of the present with the thought that anti-Semitism is a fashion of the day and will soon be over. Give up that hope! Anti-Semitism will not disappear within any foreseeable time. It is founded too deep in the human soul. It is bound up too intimately with some of the most primordial peculiarities of human thinking and feeling. All of us, Jews as well as Christians, savages as well as civilised men, feel hostility towards whatever differs from us in nature and in habits. It is enough that someone be other than we are for him to be disagreeable to us. If those who differ from us are a vanishingly small and feeble minority, we do not feel compelled to suppress our aversion, or even so much as to veil it, and its unrestraint favours its growth. To this general human ground of the hostility of every majority against every minority living in its midst and recognisable by particular traits, there is added in our case a survival of the old religious hatred against the murderers of God, and an echo of the superstitious fables of the Middle Ages concerning all manner of Jewish misdeeds. The aversion towards the divergent minority marks it out, with psychological regularity, as the whipping-boys and scapegoats for all the faults or misfortunes of the majority. When the peoples of antiquity, uniform in tribe and in creed, were visited by some calamity for which they found, or wished to find, no sufficient explanation in their own guilt, they supposed that the tribal gods were wroth with them, and sought to appease them. In all cases where those peoples ascribed the blame for their sufferings to the gods, modern enlightened peoples hold the Jews dwelling among them responsible for them. It is the same superstition, only recast to suit the times. And this will not become otherwise so long as human nature shall not have changed. How long that will last I cannot say; in any case far too long for Judaism to be able to await it.
For that is the essential thing at which I wished to arrive. Judaism cannot wait until anti-Semitism runs dry and a luxuriant crop of charity and justice springs up in its parched bed. Set up no rule-of-three calculation in which, out of the two thousand years of the Jewish past of suffering, you would obtain a figure for the X of the Jewish future of suffering. Conditions are no longer the same as they were in the past; the reckoning would therefore not come out right. The educated and self-respecting Jew of the West feels himself a whole man and wishes to be acknowledged as such by all the world. He no longer has the impenetrable armour of faith which formerly protected, if not his body, at least his soul against malice and disparagement. To his heightened sensibility, persecution and insult have become insufferable. Do but look about you! How can you mistake the signs of the times, unless you are smitten with blindness? In the autumn of 1896 I was invited by the "Berliner Allgemeine Israelitische Wochenschrift" to give my opinion upon the future of Judaism. I wrote to the paper: "Judaism is at present undergoing a process which amounts to a dulling of the mind and a thickening of the character. The clever, the witty, the gifted among the Jews — those, however, who possess only these gifts of intellect and not corresponding qualities of character as well — turn their backs upon their race; there remain behind only those who are either too dull to feel persecution and insult painfully, or who are firm in character to the point of stubbornness and set a stronger defiance against the fiercer enmity. If this twofold selection lasts another one or two generations, the Judaism remaining from it will presumably be a collection of men of little intellectual consequence, perhaps positively narrow, but unbendingly obstinate and inaccessible to every outward influence; and whether such beings also possess that measure of adaptability which is indispensable to self-preservation in the midst of more numerous and stronger adversaries seems to me questionable." In October 1896, when I wrote this, I was not yet a Zionist; I knew nothing of the matter and was not even acquainted with the word. I was very positive in my prognosis, but very uncertain in the therapy. To-day I am in no doubt about the treatment either. The defection of educated Western Jewry is not to be prevented if it remains further exposed to the assaults of anti-Semitism, which, I repeat it, is no transient phenomenon. Whoever would preserve the educated Jews to Judaism must open to them the possibility of developing freely as Jews, of living themselves out to the full, of feeling themselves surrounded and upborne by general esteem and love, of satisfying every legitimate ambition; and these conditions a Jewish commonwealth of their own, and that alone, can grant them.
Thus far I have had in view merely the case of the educated Jews of the West, your case. I say it calmly to your face: your old Jewish defiance is rotted through and will not much longer hold out against an anti-Semitism that never disarms. And yet you have only a discomfort of the soul to suffer, which coarser natures do not feel at all. German anti-Semitism undertakes nothing against men's bodies. For all it cares, the Jew may quietly stuff his belly with Schalet and even with truffles, and he who is kneaded of the stuff for which choice meals are a sufficient purpose in life may find himself quite comfortable under this form of anti-Semitism. But in the European East it is the bodily existence of the Jews that is at stake. There the Jews demand no rights of honour, but at the least one meal of dry bread a day. There anti-Semitism is no pseudo-scientific theory seeking to prove the intellectual and moral inferiority of one race to the greater glory of another race, but a hard weapon in the hand of the power of the State, wherewith that power labours pitilessly at the extirpation of the Jews. So long as the peoples of the East were a feebly organised, loose heap of men, Jewry could hold its ground among them in spite of their hostility. In the measure in which these peoples are educated to a higher civilisation, their hostility becomes more effective. Their consolidating structure crushes and casts out whatever it endures in its midst only unwillingly. The Jews of the East are literally perishing in the chains of the laws that bind them fast, unless they are helped with all speed. They suffer hunger and cold, they are made brutish by homelessness, nakedness and want of food, their children die as suck-