Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 20 · 20 May 1898
3printed page
scan 3 of 16

No. 20. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.


(continued from page 2)

…lings or grow up into rachitic dwarfs; the whole race is condemned to disease, ignorance, vice and madness, and its complete destruction is only a question of a few generations. How will you help these unfortunates? Do you perhaps hope for the abolition of the laws or the customs under which the Jews are going to ruin in the Eastern lands? Such a hope has not the least reasonable justification. It may indeed be very difficult to settle six millions of Jews in Palestine, the Hauran and Syria with self-government and rights of statehood; but it would be a thousand times more difficult to obtain from the Russian and Roumanian Governments the repeal of their Jew-laws.

I will not for a moment believe in the possibility that a non-Zionist Jew should hold out against me something like this: "the Russian and Roumanian Jews are not our concern. We have nothing in common with them." That would be not only a crying inhumanity and a wicked betrayal of all natural and historical duties, it would be above all things a pitiable folly; for do what we will, in the eyes of our enemies the Jewry of the whole world is one. We may tear the last remnant of the Jewish feeling of solidarity from our hearts never so grimly. Our enemies forge about us all an iron clamp of solidarity which we cannot break. The whole of Jewry will always be only as strong as its weakest point, and the standard by which it is measured will always be furnished by the Jew of low estate. You cannot shake the caftan-Jew from the skirts of your fine dress-coat! Your exertions to this end only make you ridiculous and contemptible in the eyes of non-Jews. The contempt which the doglike cringing beggar in his greasy caftan and with his greasy ringlets at the temples inspires falls back upon us all. The travelling anti-Semite who may spit, without danger and without penalty, upon the rags of our outlawed and unhappy brother in the East thinks, in that insult, of the Jewish baron, privy councillor and professor of his own country, to whom, on account of his official title and rank, he must show outward respect; and every kick that leaves its dirty trace upon the caftan carries within it an intention which morally strikes also the official robe of the Jewish judge and university teacher and the silk gown of the Jewish bank-baroness. If then not out of brotherliness, out of humanity, we must in our own well-understood interest do what is possible to raise the degenerating or already degenerate Jews of the East to a higher economic, moral and intellectual level.

That is my answer to the objection that Judaism does not require Zionism for its continued existence. The more highly educated Jews of the West no longer wish to be despised, and will fall away; those who are insensible to contempt will sink into a repellent materialism and will really deserve contempt; but the Jews of the East will perish body and soul. In a mistily distant future anti-Semitism will indeed cease as well. But if until then Jewry is to remain delivered over to hatred and contempt, the golden age of pure humanity and of universal brotherhood will find no Jews left who might rejoice in its sunshine.

Now, to the second objection against Zionism. It might do harm to the non-Zionist Jews. This objection springs from a selfishness so naively shameless that one has difficulty in discussing it with composure. It amounts to this, that a one-fifth minority, say, of comfortable and well-fed Jews says to the four-fifths majority of Jews who are desperate and resolved upon the utmost deeds of self-help: "How dare you disturb our digestion by your wild invocation of Zion? Why do you not choke your sufferings down? Why do you not starve in silence? Do you not see that you furnish the wicked anti-Semites. who alone still cloud our comfort a little, with an argument against us, who yet will know nothing of Zion?". A minority which speaks so to an immense majority has really forfeited every claim to consideration and would deserve to be answered: "You sacrifice us with a light heart, and yet hope that we shall show consideration for you? If Zionism did nothing else than kindle a little fire under your well-padded arm-chairs, that alone would be a sufficient justification for it."

This answer would be deserved, but we do not give it. For, unlike the non-Zionist Jews, we are no anti-Semites, and we do not rejoice when some evil befalls any Jew, be he ever so bad a one. I uttered a moment ago the word "naive." Indeed, I believe that those who raise the objection of danger are not at all conscious of the meaning of their standpoint, and have hit upon their argument not out of ice-cold ruthlessness towards the others, but out of pure thoughtlessness. That permits us to speak our mind to them upon this point also, calmly and in a friendly way.

The dangerousness of Zionism is said to consist in this, that it appears to justify the reproach that the Jews have no love of country. Who is to raise this reproach? The anti-Semites? They have not waited for Zionism in order to declare us in every land to be countryless aliens, and they will always abide by their assertion, even though you repudiate Zionism with never so noble an indignation. There is no more hopeless policy than to wish to act so as to please the enemy. This unworthily timorous policy is not ours. We say: Do right and fear no man. We have not the ambition to disarm the anti-Semites by humility and submissiveness. Let them go on railing. That may not and never will hinder us from doing all that seems to us conducive to the welfare of the Jews. What the anti-Semites say to it, whether they take it as a pretext for new insults and calumnies, is perfectly indifferent to us. There remain the Christian fellow-countrymen who are not our irreconcilable enemies and who are of good faith. That these will deny us love of country on account of Zionism is not to be expected. To whom, then, are they to make this reproach? To the Jews who go to Zion? These Jews do not assert that they have found a fatherland in the land of their birth. They practise no hypocrisy, they confess their feelings openly, they wish to be citizens of Palestine, and their genuine, glowing love of country has for its object the holy land of their forefathers. Or will the reproach be made to the Jews who remain in the land of their birth? These surely prove their attachment to the land of their birth by the very fact that they remain. They have to choose between Zion and their homeland, and they decide for their homeland. Is that not enough to secure them against spiteful misconstructions, if they, to those