Page 6.
(continued from page 5)
…Thopheth was in his opinion absolutely the only safe place, then there are indeed not many places at any one of which he could have hidden it. There is rather only one, and this one is Thopheth.
But if we have accordingly established that the Ark of the Covenant must have found its resting-place in Thopheth, where then lies this site prepared already from of old, this temple-grave of Israel, which place was moreover especially made ready by King Josiah, for at the same time at which the Ark of the Covenant was hidden, Josiah desecrated this spot?
I will now attempt to answer this question.
V.
Hakeldama.
Upon a spur of the traditional Valley of Hinnom to the south of Jerusalem there lies, on the southern mountain-slope, where the valley narrows into an almost desolate mountain pass that forms the approach to the traditional Valley of Jehoshaphat, a "chamber of the dead," and from there, in the direction of the last-mentioned valley, there stretches a great field of graves, consisting of burial chambers hewn out close beside one another, whose pitch-black openings draw our gaze upon them even from a great distance.
The Arabs call this place Hak ed Dumm, and among the biblical topographers the opinion prevails that this place is identical with the Hakeldama of the New Testament, or in other words with the potter's field which was purchased with Judas's blood-money, the 30 pieces of silver for which he betrayed Jesus.
In the year 1881 I visited this place and found, deep down in the chamber of the dead, which is formed by a mighty overhanging rock-grotto, a great accumulation of the bones of the dead, at the sight of which I could not but think involuntarily of that Gehenna of which I have spoken; and unconditionally this very chamber of the dead is in fact identical with the Gehenna or Thopheth where the Israelites made their children undergo the ordeal of fire, the place that was rendered unclean by Josiah.
That this opinion is the right one is confirmed, in the first place, by the accumulated bones, which, piled up to more than the height of a man, cover the whole floor of the chamber of the dead, that is to say an area of about 3,000 square feet; for in the upper part of them I found an earthen vessel which the Egyptologist Professor Flinders Petrie holds to belong in all probability to the Roman-Christian period, and if this conjecture is correct, then of course the lower strata are older still, and the lowest stratum must then reach far back into the Jewish age.
Burnt bones were also found there, and this awakened in me the thought that this store had been piled up when King Josiah profaned Thopheth; for if he proceeded in Thopheth in the same manner as upon the altar at Bethel, then he burned bones upon the altar in Thopheth and filled the space round about with bones gathered from the surrounding graves (2 Kings 23:14—16, 19—29; 2 Chron. 34:5. Cf. 3 Mos. 26:30).
That bones were accumulated in Thopheth is further confirmed in Isaiah 66, which chapter was composed not by Isaiah but long after him, for here it is said (v. 24) that in the messianic time men will make pilgrimage thither in order to see the corpses of those who had been apostate; and further by the fact that Jeremiah calls the Valley of Hinnom, in which Thopheth lay (2 Kings 23:10), the valley of corpses (Jer. 31:40); and also by the fact that he gives us to understand, as we have seen, that the bones would be cast forth out of all the surrounding graves, whilst in Thopheth they would be left in peace.
The statement of Jeremiah in question may also have moved the authorities in Jerusalem to issue a formal prohibition against the carrying away of the bones from this place, for in the year 1106 A.D. Abbot Daniel reports that nothing might be carried off from Hakeldama — "on ne permet de rien [emporter de] ce lieu saint" — and in the year 1558 Basil Posniakow mentions that it was forbidden upon pain of death to take any bones whatever out of the burial chambers there — "ordre est donné de ne rien prendre de ces chambies, car si un homme prend une partie de ces reliques et qu'il monte à bord d'un navire ce navire ne peut pas partir et les Turcs viennent fouiller les chrétiens; s'ils trouvent quelques uns de ces os, ils jettent à la mer l'homme chez lequel ils les ont trouvés".
There are also proofs extant that decaying corpses have lain upon Hakeldama, such as, according to the accounts adduced in our biblical commentary, are said to be found in Thopheth.
According to Jerome (390 A.D.), who says that Thopheth lies near Hakeldama, according to Arculfus (670) and according to the Venerable Bede (circa 720), corpses lay upon Hakeldama and mouldered. They were covered with skins or with hides, and the place has down into the last centuries been a burial-place for "meaner folk," although many pilgrims, and among them persons of consideration, have nevertheless held it an honour to be laid in the neighbouring graves.
Nor can it well be subject to any doubt that malefactors were executed upon Hakeldama, for that such found their grave there is reported to us by de Bruyn as late as the year 1681.
With the expression in Luke 12:5, "to cast into hell (Gehennah)," there might perhaps be connected a rumour which attaches to the nine openings in the roof of the chamber of the dead, namely that corpses are said to have been "cast down" through these. This rumour is very old and has been handed down from century to century in the same words.
Another oft-repeated rumour is that the corpses in the chamber of the dead decay extraordinarily fast, and this rumour has without doubt its ground in the fact that the chamber of the dead was the aforesaid place of burning in the Valley of Hinnom.
This is attested also by the outward impression of the chamber of the dead, for in the massive rock-roof of the mighty grotto there are no fewer than four great shafts or chimneys, through which the smoke may well have risen, as is reported in the Talmud: "Two palm-trees stand in the valley of Ben Hinnom, and between them smoke rises up...... that is the gate of hell."
(Conclusion follows.)
Paris Letter.
Whoever makes the Jewish people the object of his study soon accustoms himself to seeing embodied in it a whole series of contradictions which render a characterisation almost impossible. The explanation of this indubitable phenomenon must doubtless be sought in the abnormal existence which the Jewish people has led for so many centuries. But in whatever way one seeks to justify this fact is almost a matter of indifference — in truth, for most people it is not at all a question of a justification, but only of turning this fact to fruitful account in their own favour. Our disinherited form the armies of the revolted and contend in the foremost ranks in the struggle of existing society; our fellow-citizens, our richest men are the firmest props of all the institutions now existing which are supposed to serve for the protection of "order." On the one hand there are among us Jews the most rigid atheists, who with corrosive keenness dissolve faith and believing into a nothing; on the other hand there is again among us the most dogged clericalism, the most obstinate conservatism. Rationalism and mysticism go side by side with us; free and lofty thinking collides day by day with the least independent life of mind and of feeling. And so it comes about that we of the most contradictory offences un