Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 19 · 13 May 1898
7printed page
scan 7 of 16

No. 19 — "Die Welt" — Page 7.


(continued from page 6)

…dispositions, not least often with a proteus-like, impalpable and wholly unreliable national individuality.

This inner division extends also to the part which we play in society. We must admit that the Jew is a being quite peculiarly endowed for social life. And nevertheless he lacks in high degree the solidarity so often insisted upon by his enemies, so greatly desired by his friends, and the purposeful spirit of organisation. As evidence for this assertion I will adduce not, say, the Oriental Jews, but the French, and among these even the Zionists.

Of Zionists there are enough in Paris. More than their hitherto achieved successes would lead one to suppose. There exist the societies "Jischub Erez Israel," "Oile Regel," "Dorsche Zion," "Pirche Zion," etc. The last-named in particular consist in their greater half of Russian and Roumanian Jews. The most French Jews are counted by the association "Jischub Erez Israel." Everywhere it is the exiles and those basely driven out of their former home who bring with them the love of Zion and the enthusiasm for the national cause. It almost seems as though they had a tragic task weighing upon their shoulders, as though they were singled out not to let their emancipated brethren, who live in greater security, forget by what fate they too might one day be threatened. When these latter drowse away in sated repose and comfort, then their laments and cries of pain must serve to give this dream-blessed condition a background from which it stands out horribly. And that plays upon the nerves of the good comfortable people, that makes them impatient, agitated, that fills them with hatred and repugnance against the typically Jewish figures which creep through the streets of Paris, bowed down by hunger and anguish of soul. Full of disgust they fling them an alms.

But it is precisely these poor who know how to prize Zionism, and even if they arrange it for themselves within the compass of their own understanding, they are none the less the foundation-stock of the Zionist societies of Paris. There are few members of the societies who pay 12 francs a year, and only few of these well-to-do people are honestly enthusiastic for our idea. Some also connect with Zionism hopes and views that are quite personal. Thus in the past year a young advocate of the court of appeal gave to his Zionism a peculiar turn. He sees in Palestine the land in which all peoples will become brothers, where they will all come together to consecrate themselves to eternal peace. The Jews would have to work more than other peoples for this future, and therefore make particular exertions to come to Palestine, for to them it is, by past and by future (as he confidently believes), a doubly holy land. Only by this roundabout way, upon which biblical recollections also, perhaps unconsciously, guided him, could this French Jew justify his love of Zion not only before others but also before himself. But, as has been said, the French Jews who occupy themselves in any way with Zionism are comparatively very few — or at least were so until the most recent time. The fault lies doubtless for the greatest part in the lukewarmness of the societies, and especially of the "Jischub Erez Israel," which after all counts a number of more influential persons among its members.

Above all, however, the tactics of the societies must be pronounced mistaken. These tactics display the furthest-going consideration for the prejudices of the French Jews. Anxiously everything is avoided that might give offence. As though a young idea, one by its whole nature utterly opposed to the old, could come to a breakthrough without struggle and contention! One example for many. When in the past year a fiery Zionist, full of energy, without mincing his words, pointed to the delusions which emancipation had brought us, and set forth that even the Revolution in France was but little favourably disposed towards the Jews, several French "Israelites" raised a vehement protest against these statements and threatened to withdraw from the society. It required the declaration of several members of the committee, that these were the personal views of the speaker, and that the members of the society likewise regarded France as "the second fatherland of all Jews," in order to settle the matter amicably.

With regard to the colonisation of Palestine and its results also, the society "Jischub Erez Israel" has done as good as nothing to instruct the French Jews concerning it. The rest of the propaganda, too, is completely unregulated and quite insufficient. And yet in France there would be so good a soil for the Zionist propaganda! When Herzl, in a fit of ill-humour, said in his "Judenstaat": "If now all or some French Jews protest against this project because they have already become 'assimilated,' then my answer is simple: the whole matter does not concern them at all. They are Israelite Frenchmen, excellent! This, however, is an internal affair of the Jews," that should in no wise serve as an excuse for making no propaganda for our idea in France. Meanwhile the French Jews have indeed learned that their house too is not so firmly built that they could look on unconcerned at the struggle of the rest of the Jews. In a twofold respect could the French Jews serve Zionism. First, they could help the Jews of the East to an existence worthy of men, which as Jews, be it only in respect of religion, they cannot refuse. So too has the Grand Rabbi Zadoc-Kahn explained the matter to an editor of the "Journal" who wished to ascertain the relations of the French Jews to Zionism. Then they could also, even from their own standpoint, support the historical-literary movement, whose continual and gratifying growth bears the best witness to the reawakening and the strengthening of the Jewish national feeling.

And the "Jewish" Frenchmen will return to Judaism. That is beyond question, even if they still resist now. They will return because circumstances will compel them to it. And because this will assuredly be the case, the propaganda should not slacken, but set in with greater vigour. It may perhaps not be able to keep to its programme of action quite as it does in other countries; that matters nothing. Simply to give up 100,000 Jews, among whom so much talent and capacity for work is to be found, would be a great awkwardness and a still greater blunder. If the French Jews will not at once acknowledge our whole programme, that should not deter the propaganda. But a beginning it must make; the rest then comes of itself. Ce n'est que le premier pas qui coûte. Argus.


Rachel's Tomb.

(To the illustration.)

A voice of lamentation is heard in Ramah, bitter weeping, Rachel weeping for her children; she refuseth to be comforted for her children, for they are gone.

Thus saith the Eternal: Hold back thy voice from weeping and thine eyes from tears; for there is a reward for thy doing, saith the Eternal, and they shall return out of the land of the enemy;

And there is hope for thy future, saith the Eternal, and the children shall return unto their own border.

Jeremiah XXXI. 14, 15, 16.