No. 15. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
Not a year has yet passed since that cry rang out in the great modern Egypt, that is to say, throughout the whole world, and at once there were found people with astonished faces, and others who assured everybody, full of indignation, that no bond whatever united them with this revolting mass. The most enslaved of slaves!
One type of such timorous spirits, of souls startled out of their repose and outraged thereat, is the French Jew. He commonly takes up a position against Zionism. Two enemies he fears especially: antisemitism and Zionism. And whenever and wherever he can, he seeks to place these two movements upon the same footing, and even fancies, with childlike naivety, that he can combat them with the same weapons. Rusty already are these weapons, and notched: patriotism rich in phrases, and the invocation of the magnanimity and the tolerance of the French people, and finally undisguised apostasy. Some also believe that they have done something remarkable when they diligently bring to their fellow citizens' remembrance the merits of the Jew X. or of the Jewish family Z. And by this means they would abolish antisemitism from the world and win back for themselves the love of the non-Jewish French. The Dreyfus affair has shown them how great this love is in military circles. The comfortable bourgeoisie, the mainstay of France, has but lately told them, through the mouth of Brunetière, what they have to expect of it. The director of the "Revue des Deux Mondes" has likewise recited his little piece upon antisemitism in the number of the 15th of March. The "immortal" enemy of science charges the learned anthropologists, philologists and historians with the chief guilt for the growth of antisemitism. By their researches, he says, they have laid bare the differences of the races and so engendered race-hatred, and in it antisemitism. To be sure, M. Brunetière also mentions in passing that hatred of the Jews is besides caused by inborn prejudices, base passions and ignominious envy. "But," he adds, "formerly men had the courage to call this envy, these passions, these prejudices by their right name; to-day it is science that has put into their hands a means of appearing in a disguise." It is singular, by the way, in what manner the honourable Academician would show us on this occasion that this prejudice is wholly foreign to him. "Freemasons, Protestants and Jews, who all had the great advantage of being bound to our past by no obligation — have made themselves masters of politics, of the administration, of the school; — — 38,000,000 Frenchmen no longer perceive to-day that for a hundred years they have had to bow for ever beneath the dominion of some few hundred thousand of them, beneath the dominion of the last comers, of the youngest members of the family." The unprejudiced Brunetière! After such utterances one asks oneself which is the more disguised, Drumont or Brunetière. We hold people of the latter sort to be far more dangerous.
All this, however, does not disturb the French Jews in their convulsive efforts to maintain their false position. We truly desire to make no proselytes for Zionism among these worthy men; we claim only the right to demand of them that they abase themselves somewhat less, and that they do not fan the glow of their patriotism into a mighty conflagration upon every fitting and unfitting occasion. And their insinuations against the Zionists they might likewise forbear, for the tottering house of their illusions, whose collapse threatens hourly, will hardly be sufficiently propped up thereby. One of them lately spoke upon Zionism at Avignon. After he had brought forward all the old familiar fables against the Zionists, he closed with effusive protestations of his patriotism and of his attachment to the beloved French fatherland. In an equally tasteful manner another, in the "Univers Israelite," varied the fine theme "Cleave to the fatherland, the dear fatherland," and declared that Zionism was unacceptable for the French Jews, since it was anti-patriotic. Then he discovered that the Zionists are not even Jewish patriots, but form quite simply a "mutual insurance society for protection against persecution." The two gentlemen have of course made an end of Zionism.
By way of counterpart we would cite the observations of a French writer, Paul Adams, in the March number of the "Revue blanche," in which he gives expression to his sympathies for Zionism. He there says, among other things: "What would you (Rothschild) do if one day in the month of May you found yourself confronted with a Chamber whose majority was manifestly reactionary, antisemitic and friendly to the military? If antisemitism should triumph in Paris as it has in Vienna and in Russia, and the Government should favour the rising against Jewish capital, then nothing would remain for you but to throw yourself into the arms of the Zionists and to seek out an exile... M. de Rothschild, of this one must think, and one must learn to understand the near necessity of founding a Jewish republic. It would then be your care to bring into the land of your choice a multitude of industrial producers, by establishing there laws that are filled with the theories of common property, and by preparing there for the workers the best lot that is anywhere to be found in the world. Money would permit the rapid realisation of a considerable State, which would be in a position to take into its possession the whole of the implements of labour and then to leave them to those men who should desire to defend, even with their lives, the fatherland which alone favours social freedom. Capital, labour and science, united to a purpose of brotherly harmony, would enchant the barbarous spirit of the old world, which would itself have to withdraw in shame in the face of such an example."
One sees that there are among the intelligence of France people who understand us. We may therefore hope that they will favour the blossoming of Zionism in France. If only a few French Jews shall first have been found who are devoted friends of the redemption of the Jews, they will surely draw the others after them. These, to be sure, will have to be men free of philistine prejudices, with a soul that thirsts after freedom. Only such men will help Zionism to victory in France also. Only he who is free in the highest sense of the word can grasp Zionism in its whole greatness.
Argus.
The Dreyfus-Esterhazy Affair.
Men's minds have not yet recovered from the sensation of the quashing of Zola's conviction, and already there come from Paris fresh disclosures concerning Esterhazy, whom a serious Paris journal, upon the strength of documents, decidedly designates as the traitor and spy, and Dreyfus as innocent, and seeks to prove this by detailed particulars.
Under the title: "The Truth about the Esterhazy Affair," the "Siècle" publishes a long letter dated from Berne, signed "A Diplomatist," which contains disclosures respecting Esterhazy's relations with the former German military attaché Schwarzkoppen.
Count Casella publishes in the "XIX. Siècle" an account which confirms and supplements the disclosures of that journal.
Casella questioned the Italian military attaché Panizzardi respecting the much-discussed card which contained the words: "That canaille T ..." — Panizzardi declared: I give you my word of honour that this card neither proceeded from me nor ever reached me. Casella observed: But you must be very much au courant, if you were willing to speak. — Panizzardi answered: That is easily said. Nobody wishes to hear anything. The German embassy declared categorically that it had never had anything to do with Dreyfus. It was labour in vain. One cannot, after all, demand that the German Government should itself denounce the man really guilty, and I may say nothing; I cannot injure a friend such as Schwarzkoppen. — Casella remarked that a single man knew the whole truth, namely Schwarzkoppen; they ought to have applied to him at once. — Panizzardi rejoined: You speak like my friend Schwarzkoppen, who has often declared to me that he was astonished that the Dreyfus family never took a step with him. He has a good heart, and I believe that it would have been very hard and painful for him to withdraw himself from the request of the unhappy relatives. Perhaps things would have shaped themselves otherwise.
Casella thereupon made known his intention of interviewing Schwarzkoppen in Berlin. Panizzardi replied: I believe that now it is already too late. My friend can do nothing more. The German Government, like every Government for that matter, will never denounce the man really guilty, else there would be no intelligence service any longer.
Casella nevertheless went to Berlin and had repeated meetings there with Schwarzkoppen, who said to him: I can only appeal to the plain declaration of the German embassy, that we have had nothing to do with Dreyfus...
I think I understand, remarked Casella, that you are convinced Dreyfus is not the author of the bordereau. —
No, answered Schwarzkoppen, the bordereau is not his.
Casella: You are then personally convinced that Dreyfus is innocent? —
Schwarzkoppen: Yes, I know that Dreyfus is innocent.
Casella: And what do you think of the documents which were laid before the court-martial and moved it to condemn Dreyfus?
Schwarzkoppen: I do not doubt that the judges were of good faith; but if those documents were meant to set forth the relations between Dreyfus and the German Government, well, then they can be nothing but forgeries.
Casella: Who then is the man really guilty? Did you know Esterhazy? He himself conceded the relations with you
