Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 15 · 15 April 1898
3printed page
scan 3 of 16
Facsimile · scan 3 of 16
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 15. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

And as a Zionist too I have no need whatever to wish that anti-Semitism should cross the Alpine frontier. As the glorious example of England proves, our idea is strong and great enough to conquer ever new ground without the beadle's aid of anti-Semitism and without a propaganda of terror, and to storm stronghold upon stronghold victoriously. In the long run Italy also would not remain untouched by this movement, and among that enthusiastic nation Zionism might well find an ardent echo for more than one reason. Even without anti-Semitic ulterior motives, a people's longing for political and national rebirth can scarcely count upon so much understanding in any other land of Europe as precisely in Italy.

But nevertheless I must trouble the waters, and, in accordance with my modest observations, set up a quite different prognostic for anti-Semitism in Italy. The opposition of my views to those of Herr Kauffmann springs perhaps only from a difference of temperaments. Yet perhaps also from this, that I have comprehended the thorny complexity of the Jewish question and of Jewish distress far too well to treat this partial, Italian problem with the truly alarming optimism of Herr Kauffmann. I repeat, it is no propaganda of terror that is intended, but — a signal of warning.

Soon after that essay something very remarkable happened in Rome. For the first time since 1870 there rang out from Italian student throats the loud cry: Evviva il Papa-Re. To the Pope-King, the sovereign possessor of the States of the Church, or at the least of the Eternal City, was addressed this loud homage of young academicians, who thereby set themselves in the harshest contradiction to the official political dogma that Rome is the inviolable capital of united Italy — Roma intangibile! The young people carried their audacity and their appetite for opposition so far as to have placards in this sense distributed and posted up in the city itself. This, to be sure, turned out ill enough for them. The crowd tore these placards down and thrashed the criers and distributors — as is usual when new, or even newly old, ideas which had long seemed buried venture once more into the light of day. Naturally such a "defence" has never yet had success, as the liberal press of Italy may dimly have felt when it took cognisance, with grave concern, of the fact that clericalism and the idea of the States of the Church had now penetrated the circles of the academic youth as well. Comical was the horror of these people, who evidently had not yet heard the least thing of the "social Christianity" so widely spread in Central Europe. And yet in Italy too there has existed for nearly ten years a very firmly consolidated Catholic Socialism, which makes its conquests especially in the countryside. The clergyman and the parish priest are in earnest about the social betterment of the peasant class and have already unfolded a very meritorious activity through the organisation of credit and loan banks of every kind. But in the towns as well the clerical influence is visibly growing, and it is characteristic of Italian conditions that a great part of the lending institutions, the so-called monti di pietà, is in clerical hands. And the churchly politicians would have to be other than the shrewd men that they are, not to exploit this instrument of power thoroughly. It is above all the growth of the social, even of the social-democratic movement which is for ever driving fresh water to the mill of clericalism. For however hostile Social Democracy may in general set itself towards positive religion, it nevertheless indirectly strengthens, and even overheats, the religious sentiment. In the first place Socialism brings to purely formal, diplomatic politics an enormous content, and thereby paralyses to a certain degree the confidence in self-acting human intelligence. To wage wars, to contrive alliances or to overthrow ministers — all that does indeed demand a great expenditure of human acumen and human will-power, but in no way exceeds the limits of human capacity. A politician who sets himself only such aims may reckon upon successes even in his own present and immediate future, and has no need to rack his brains on account of his great-grandchildren. The politics of substance pursued by Socialism, on the other hand, put an uncanny quantity of problems up for debate which cannot be solved so soon, even though one discuss them a whole night through. There one must simply believe, believe, believe — in the future, in evolution, in the logic of facts, or else in God. The form in which this faith is framed will commonly be conditioned and limited by the degree of education of the individual, or of the masses as well. But one can understand that in a socially agitated age the Church too, beside the state of the future, gains ever more ground, and I believe that this development is far from being at an end. In Italy the Pope need only permit the Clericals to take part in the parliamentary elections, and a numerous, black, hideously social guard makes its entry into Monte Citorio. And then the Jewish debates in the Italian parliament would not be likely to keep us waiting long.

The Social Democracy of the peninsula is hardly likely to offer the victorious Clericals any serious competition either. Apart from the north, Italy possesses as yet no really considerable industry, no purposeful, thoroughly trained proletariat. Last year's "revolution" in Sicily was a revolution of the peasants, who followed the Socialists to the field only because the clergy there did not wish to fall out with the great landed barons and therefore turned the peasants away. But so soon as the clergy will, it will always have the peasant. Experience in other countries teaches this abundantly, and the Italian peasant, although an old, aesthetic culture lies deep in his bones, stands far behind the countryman of Central and Western Europe in logical intelligence. Far less, therefore, than in Austria, say, will Social Democracy in Italy be in a position to prevent the rise of anti-Semitism.

Furthermore, the feudal lords from above, who extend their well-tended, comital hand to the anti-Semitic small burgher, will be as little wanting in Rome as in Vienna. The high nobility of the papal era has for the present withdrawn entirely from great politics. At most it attempts to occupy the municipal administration, often with decided success. For the rest it sulks in its palaces, cultivates belles-lettres, or saves itself from financial ruin by the sale of costly picture galleries and rare libraries. How powerful this nobility still is, the world will learn to its astonishment when, at a sign from the Holy Father, this papal band of picked men once more enters the field of battle. It would be revealed that an Italian Centre would have a quite different weight to throw into the scale than even the guard of Windhorst and Lieber in the German Reichstag. It will then become decisive for the Jews how the Italian government and bourgeoisie bear themselves towards this new enemy.

Were the Pope to remain irreconcilable and were he to insist upon his semblance, upon his States of the Church, then indeed the Jews would have not the least thing to fear. Even sincerely pious Catholics will not for all that put up with a dismemberment of their fatherland. About the government which defends Roma intaugibile the whole nation would rally as one man, and there would remain no time and no humour for anti-Semitic jests. But the Curia will, against such a clumsy policy,