Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 11 · 18 March 1898
6printed page
scan 6 of 16
Facsimile · scan 6 of 16
Scan of p. 6
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 11.

(continued from page 5)

…with reverence. Across whole ages we reach out our hands to one another; one brother recognises the other.

And yet another thought came into my mind in that great moment. It is said that the Jews are quarrelsome and cannot get along with one another. Well then! at the Basle Congress as at the London Conference the Jews have been seen concordant and united!

With this we may close our notes. We have kept the solemn promise well in memory: "If I forget thee, Jerusalem, may my right hand wither!"

Subjects of the Deliberations.

We now have the detailed reports before us. The conference lasted only a single day, but in three sittings it mastered an enormous body of material. Colonel Goldsmid, Vice-Chief Prag, and Mr. H. Bentwich presided over the assembly by turns; it proceeded in a solemn spirit, borne along by a unanimous enthusiasm, without a single discordant note. Of 168 elected delegates, more than a hundred appeared from all parts of the "United Kingdom." Among them were seen two officers on the active staff, Colonel Goldsmid and Major Lewis-Barned, seven rabbis, six graduates of the juridical and philosophical faculties, and otherwise men of various professions and stations in life. On the platform, over which the splendid banner of Zion was unfurled, there took their places: Colonel Goldsmid, Major Lewis-Barned, Mr. Prag, Rev. Gollancz, Dr. S. A. Hirsch, Mr. Bentwich, and Mr. J. de Haas.

The conference, whose proceedings we here propose to describe according to the special edition of the Zionist "Jewish World," began at ten o'clock in the morning precisely.

To Mr. H. Bentwich, as chairman of the convening committee, fell the task of welcoming the assembly. He first pointed to the approaching Feast of Purim and the memories it awakens in us. Then he came to speak of the struggle of the Maccabees against Hellenism, for which the morrow was likewise a day of commemoration. "This day reminds us of the victory of Juda Maccabi over the general Nicanor and of the re-establishment of the Jewish kingdom; and we who take part in this conference are going forward to a similar struggle with the same enemy — Hellenism. The English Jews find themselves at present in a condition similar to that of our forefathers in Greece, where everyone was held, on pain of death, to attach himself to the one party or the other: they must be either Philo-Zionists or Anti-Zionists, otherwise they will perish as victims of their own incapacity for decision. It will not do to waver any longer to and fro between the one view and the other, and history has proved to us to what fate cosmopolitans — a people without nationality, that would fain do right by everybody, whose hand is against every man and against whom every man's hand is turned — are condemned.

The whole Sanhedrion that Napoleon convened denied the national idea through its proclamation: 'France is our Zion.' Yet this nevertheless led to Panama and to Devil's Island.

Zionism is the embodiment of the ideal of Judaism. It is Zion that unites us all. What a wonderful assembly sits here to-day before the eyes of our contemporary statesmen. We form the first parliament of English Jews; the delegates represent more than ten thousand Zionists, and we have all come here with but one resolve — to stand up for Zion and for our national existence. Every great city of the United Kingdom is represented in our midst, and, more than that, every shade of Zionist party." With some splendid verses by Sylvie d'Avigdor, in which is celebrated the significance of the new generation, "that dwells where Zion lies," Mr. Bentwich closed his most favourably received address of welcome.

Colonel Goldsmid, greeted with a storm of applause, took the floor to open the conference as Chief of the "Chovevi Zion Association." He first declared that he associated himself with the words of the previous speaker. If certain associations still allowed themselves at present to go unrepresented here (meaning, no doubt, the "Anglo Jewish Association" and the "Jewish Colonisation Association"), this was to be ascribed only to a state of nervousness over the growing anti-Semitism. This was now nothing other than blind race-hatred. In vain had the Jews undertaken to prove that in respect of loyalty, patriotism, and charity they in no way stood behind their fellow-citizens; for one "black sheep" all would always be held responsible. Thus there were for the Jews only two ways out: assimilation or the realisation of the national idea. Assimilation could be attained only by the way of mixed marriage and baptism. For only then can one speak of a true assimilation. But that solution was for us impossible. Peoples have come and peoples have vanished, but Israel never perishes. He had often heard English Jews argue that for England they had solved the Jewish question through their forefathers' struggle for civil and religious liberty, and that the others might do likewise. How fine and plausible that sounds, and yet how false it is in reality! The English Jews owe their favourable position solely to the innate British sense of freedom. Nor must it be forgotten that when the barriers were torn down in England, the Jewish population there was still very small. But what of those in the ghettos and the settlement-districts, where the Jewry, bereft of all civil rights, of all means of livelihood and of education, perishes physically and mentally? It was very comfortable, when one lives oneself under the most comfortable conditions, to preach patience to the victims of tyranny. "Change places, my dear sirs, with those to whom you give such counsel."

Then Colonel Goldsmid came to speak of Zionism, which he described as the sole sheet-anchor of the masses: "A short while ago its adherents were still regarded as visionary enthusiasts. What visionary folly! But the events of the last few months have reversed the roles. Who, then, are the visionaries now — the Zionists or the assimilationists? At the beginning of this century the Napoleonic Sanhedrium could still solemnly declare: 'France is our Zion!' And at the close of the century we see that this Zion disowns them, as they have disowned their Zion. Ah, ye poor visionaries, once again Israel teaches that whoso forgets Zion, his right hand shall be forgotten and shall grow powerless and weak. For what is Israel without Zionism?

The much-discussed question of the patriotism of the Zionists was also touched on by the active English colonel — a personality assuredly far more competent than sundry rabbis who already possess a decoration or are but striving for one. "I know," said Col. Goldsmid, "certain people who express the fear that a Zionist could not be regarded as a loyal English subject. One might with equal right maintain that no believing English Christian can be a loyal subject, because he awaits the day on which all peoples shall revere the King of Israel."

Colonel Goldsmid for political Zionism.

"The Zionists do not dream of a great empire whose interests would collide with those of the Great Powers. They desire only the establishment of a polity in their ancient homeland, under the guarantee of the Great Powers, where their persecuted brethren would find a secure home. It lies in the interest of the European Powers that such a solution be brought about, for no other is possible at all. The founding of the state would, however, no more compel all Jews to emigrate than, for example, the founding of the Greek state compelled all scattered Greeks to do so."

Then Col. Goldsmid, as chairman, brought the agenda already known to us up for reading. He closed his speech with a reference to his relationship with Dr. Herzl. "Before