Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 7.
(continued from page 5)
…then there seems to me to be nothing unreasonable in that. We may not abandon our people to an uncertain future. Care must be taken that it can live in security, and if we attempt this under the eyes of the whole world, in the manner of the modern peoples, then in that, too, no danger can be perceived. Both speakers seem to shrink back from the word 'State.' Now, what is a State? A great colony. And what is a colony? A little State. And mankind has never seemed to perceive anything dreadful therein. Now the first speaker holds that, were it to prove possible to establish a commonwealth in Palestine, this would be of little use to the proletariat, and that things there would grow no better in the economic sphere than is the case here with us. I cannot understand that the speaker should fear something for the proletariat in this imagined commonwealth. I can tell you that I do not make this proletarian distinction, that for me there is no difference among the Jews, and the whole bent of the movement is a solicitude for the lot precisely of our poorest. And if we cannot guarantee them the fowl in the pot, does Socialism give it to them? I believe that, of the two states of the future — the socialist and the Zionist — the latter has more prospect of realisation than the former. (Cries: Come, come!) To a 'Come, come' it is, to be sure, hard to reply. When I consider that with new institutions everything is always made better than it was with the old, then I give myself over to the hope that in the newly founded Jewish State economically sound conditions, too, will prevail. And when we proceed to the founding of a new order, the gentlemen who believe they must take up the cause of the proletariat will indeed have opportunity to voice their wishes and to see to their realisation.
I do not wish to repeat myself too much, so let me close. Our standpoint is no fanatical one; we are modern men, and have not been able to understand why the errors of an earlier age should still endure in this one. Regard this movement as a movement of charity, which seeks to serve the poor, is hostile to no one, and can afford mankind a certain relief.
Dr. Caro stressed his standpoint as a "German of the Jewish faith," who wishes to place his strength in the service of his co-religionists, in order to win for them equality of rights with the other citizens.
The advocate Silbergleit alludes to the Dreyfus case and holds that it speaks in favour of Zionism; if it is possible that such a thing can occur, who then can know what else may yet come to pass. There was no sharply-marked nation save precisely the Jewish. The Jew had indeed Europeanised himself, but had not assimilated himself, and for that reason there will always be points of friction between him and the other peoples.
Pastor Faber: Honoured Assembly! I must confess that I, as a Christian, am unable to understand the contradiction that the Zionist movement calls forth in certain circles of the Jewish population. It is truly a feeble explanation for this phenomenon, that one seeks to bring German patriotism into opposition with the Jewish-national movement. When American citizens of German nationality follow with some sympathy the history of their old fatherland, no one will reproach them with acting unpatriotically toward the land in which they live. Just as little can one hold it against a German citizen of Jewish nationality if he meets with sympathy the mighty and magnificent Zionist movement, and places his strength in the service of the idea that is now beginning to set aflame the Jewish people of the whole earth. The frightful plight of the Jewish masses in Russia, Roumania, and of late in Persia too, compels all Jews who are rachamanim bene rachamanim (the merciful, sons of the merciful) to turn a helping participation toward the colonisation endeavours in the Holy Land. But without the assured legal protection of a Jewish State, these colonies will be given over to arbitrary caprice. As the blossom from the bud, so will and must the Jewish State go forth, with compelling necessity, from the colonisation endeavours of the Holy Land, now engaged in a magnificent development. World history knows few movements of so magnificent a character as the Zionist, which even now — as I know from personal experience — makes its powerful effect felt into the remotest regions of the world. The revival of the Hebrew language proves, on this side too, the vital force of the Jewish nation. To-day's assembly is a proof that Zionism has entered upon its triumphal course in Berlin as well. Let it be assailed and mocked ever so much, one thing is certain: the winning-back of the Holy Land for Israel, the people without peer, is preparing itself, even if only in its first beginnings. One of the preceding speakers said: "one must not anticipate God; it will be the business of the Almighty to accomplish this work; God will Himself lead the Jews back to Palestine, the land of their fathers; for the fulfilment of this promise no Zionist movement and no leaders are needed." To this I answer with the old Talmudic word: "en somshin al haness" (one must not rely upon a miracle). God does not work directly, but avails Himself of human powers. But this is the great thing about the Zionist movement: that all Jews — be their outlook in religious respect what it will; be they modern people without religion, be they Orthodox, Talmudists, or Reformers, be they living in whatsoever religious conviction — all of them can take part in this current, which is precisely not a religious one, but a national one, rooted in the natural foundations of the people. Zionism can, will, and must conquer!
Thereupon Herr Rosenthal spoke against Zionism, with a great expenditure of bodily motions. Full of promise was the programme this gentleman unfolded. He most magnanimously permits all Jews who do not feel at ease in the lands in which they dwell to go to Palestine. Of his remaining expositions I will adduce, as a characteristic touch, only this further point: that with prophetic seer's gaze he proclaimed to the Berlin Zionists that in future, at their assemblies, they would see Ahlwardt and Liebermann von Sonnenberg come forward as agitators for Zionism, because they had made themselves guilty of the "crime" of allowing an Evangelical clergyman to speak in the discussion!
It had meanwhile become half past eleven o'clock, and among the public a certain restlessness was already making itself noticeable. On the list of speakers six gentlemen still stood entered. The chairman regretted that, on account of the advanced hour, he must curtail the discussion. Thereupon Herr Goldberger took the floor on a point of order and asked that at least Herr Löwenstein be permitted to say what lay upon his heart, since the Zionists must otherwise be prepared for the "Association of German Citizens of the Jewish Faith" to make capital out of the fact that its representative had not been granted the floor. The board declared itself in agreement with this proposal, and Herr Löwenstein was able to begin. This man abused the freedom of speech in order to intensify still further his outrageous attacks upon the Zionists, by which he had already attained a sad celebrity. The speaker was nevertheless heard out, until he committed the tactlessness of attacking Pastor Faber in a manner happily not customary among educated people. The assembly was thereby thrown into such agitation that the police saw themselves compelled to dissolve it.
It is sad that these Jews, who truly have enough to suffer from the anti-Semitic suspicions, do not abhor drawing their weapons, in the struggle against Zion, from the anti-Jewish arsenal. And it is blameworthy to impute base motives to a man like Pastor Faber, who with noble courage and self-denial stands up for our cause. When the gentlemen of the "Association of German Citizens of the Jewish
