Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 22 · 29 October 1897
13printed page
scan 17 of 20

"Die Welt" — No. 22. — Page 13.

(continued from page 12)

... of rescuing our poor — who, moreover, are so numerous not in Vilna alone — meets with resistance among the over-satiated of our western brethren. Here we see the misery and the indescribable distress with our own eyes, we feel it in our own bodies, and we have nothing left but the sweet hope of a better future in the land of our fathers. Our poor would indeed follow any call to emigrate, no matter whither; but whoever knows these poor knows that their most honest and sincere wish is that the hope in which they were reared, for which they have suffered and bled, and for which they suffer and bleed to this day, may be fulfilled.

Kieff, 20th October 1897. Last Saturday an uncommonly important meeting was held here. Some hundred persons from the intelligent and wealthy circles had come together to listen to the words of the highly esteemed Dr. M. Mandelstamm, one of the most famous physicians in Russia. It was only a report upon the Basle Congress — but what a report! In a brilliant address, worthy of the Congress, the speaker depicted the objective state of affairs and his personal impressions, now carried away by feeling, now bubbling over with wit, but most of all inspired and inspiring when he came to speak of the hopes which the first step upon the difficult road to our great ideal has awakened in every participant of the Congress. One felt oneself transported once more into those historic days; many were plainly overwhelmed by the fulness of the thoughts.

The speaker set forth, among other things: When he went to Basle, he had himself looked forward to the impending event with a certain scepticism, since he knew the temper of the "practical" people. Above all he had called to mind the situation of the Russian Jews. On the one hand the crushing multitude of begging, starving, wholly deadened elements, who must needs unlearn how to feel; on the other a not considerable number of rich, at times even very rich Jews, who nevertheless pay homage to a most trivial and pernicious philosophy of the real; for it is precisely these who see the fulfilment of their duty in seeking to alleviate the momentary distress, in supporting the plundered, in building hospitals for the wretched so that they may be permitted to be sick — a most respectable class of men, therefore, and often a very beneficent one, yet they reminded him of those empirical physicians who cure each single symptom of the malady, but not the malady itself. To these must be added the class of the educated, who draw all their wisdom from anti-Jewish sources, turn with contempt from the essence of their own people, and in their ignorance and instability steer straight for assimilation. With pain he had asked himself whether anything could be accomplished with such dead material. Hard it is, under such circumstances, to create great works, to carry through an idea which demands a fully developed national consciousness, a clear understanding of the pitiable dog's conditions in which Jewry finds itself; for that a considerable force of will is needed, endurance and confidence in one's own powers, but above all self-respect.

To Basle he had journeyed in the hope of finding at least a number of such as possessed the qualities enumerated. Since his return he could assure them that, thanks to the Congress, he had revived and been filled with hopes. There, at the spot from which the first step towards another turn in the destiny of the Jews had been undertaken, he had perceived a mass of intelligence, energy, and enterprise which justified him in those hopes.

The lecturer then reflected in luminous pictures the several proceedings of the first Zionist Congress, gave a characterisation of the acting personalities altogether his own, pointed to the merits of Herzl, Nordau, Birnbaum, and so forth, and excerpted a part of the first speeches, translating whole sections out of Nordau's masterpiece. The Basle Programme was then developed in detail, and the irrefutable services were brought out which that first sign of life of the Jewish nation has already rendered to the whole of Jewry. What a mighty protest it was against anti-Semitism! From accused we have now transformed ourselves into accusers, have renounced all mediation after the manner of the "Societies for the Defence against Anti-Semitism," and have proclaimed to the world that we will not degrade ourselves. Before the honoured public we have not defended ourselves for having been born as Jews, but we have set our enemies' injustice before them ad oculos indeed.

Further, at the Congress we pointed with such clearness to the ostrich policy of the Jews themselves, who have made of themselves a religious community, have divested themselves of all national aspirations, and have therefore sunk into want of energy. In spite of our dispersion and our diversity we declared ourselves at the Congress a nation, finding the necessary attributes above all in the community of our past, our present, and — from now onward — our future. In this we do not mean to learn from others by watching how they clear their throats and spit, but rather to draw nourishment from our own ethics, without of course surrendering "so much as a foot's breadth of European culture."

The Congress at Basle has worked a process of disinfection among us; the same, I am convinced, we have to expect from the Congresses to come. Let the worse elements depart, if only the better remain! In our views we have been confirmed above all by the enthusiasm which we found among a part of the Jewish youth; this self-consciousness and its manifestations offer us a picture of the future.

To the principal question, what the Congress has done towards the realisation of the plan of transferring the Jews to Palestine, the speaker could reply as follows: If it be true that we have directed the attention of all Europe to this question, that we have awakened the self-consciousness of a certain part of the Jewish people and proved by facts that we have to build upon ourselves alone, then we have for the present done everything towards the realisation of the thought to which we devote ourselves. In the measure in which the national consciousness penetrates the Jewish masses, the modest wish to acquire a territory of one's own will be transformed into an elemental force, into a mighty and real striving.

"Believe me, gentlemen," said the speaker in conclusion, in that tone which conviction inspires, "that we are not so naïve as to fail to foresee all the difficulties that are to be overcome. But difficulties are overcome by work, by energetic work, and not by useless subtilising, which is nothing else than the fruit of that terrible indifferentism which hides itself boldly under the firm-name of 'being practical.' It requires no great understanding to put the questions: 'What will the Turk say? The Christian Governments? The Pope?' Verily, greater insight and far-sightedness are needed to discover those chances which might be favourable to us and are de facto at hand; to these we must cling as to an anchor of salvation." The Jewish mass cries out to us: "Land, land!" and we hesitate; Hannibal is before the gates and we subtilise, forgetting that for our deliverance nothing better has yet been found.....

We believe in the success of our cause, but we do not fear the mockery should we suffer shipwreck. For we have willed greatly.

The speaker's words died away in a grave exhortation to draw the conclusions from the thoughts he had thrown out, and to stand up vigorously for Zionism. Lasting was the effect of the address, which was delivered in the Russian language; when the speaker had ended, a storm of applause arose that lasted for minutes.