Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 20 · 15 October 1897
4printed page
scan 8 of 20
Facsimile · scan 8 of 20
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 20.

(continued from page 3)

…and hamlets; and they are also still the same Jews as I left them. Or perhaps not quite? —

German Jewry falls, in the conceptual categories, into Orthodox and Freethinkers, between whom there is said to be at most a middle party as well. In truth this account is by no means accurate. Rather, there is only one great indifferent mass which, above all — and precisely in so-called religious matters — is thoroughly indifferent. Attached to this great mass are little appendages called "Orthodox" and "Reformers," or who even call themselves so, applying to themselves these curious names, taken over from another community and from other circumstances. These parties, small and tiny as they are, are by no means homogeneous or even united within themselves. Rather, all shadings from the one to the other are represented within them; and from Berlin's law-abiding Jewry to the Frankfort and Mainz "Orthodoxy" is exactly as far as from the latter to Reform, or again from the freethinking of a Steinthal to its grotesque presentation in certain Berlin synagogues. As a rule, to be sure, these antagonisms do not touch the Jewish mass — and it makes no difference whether that mass, in South Germany, clings out of mental convenience and without criticism to old customs, or whether, in North Germany and the East, it no longer observes them out of material convenience. Convenience is precisely the characteristic mark of the German Jew, so far as Jewish affairs are concerned. How else would it be conceivable that the same Berlin rabbis have for so many years been preaching in the strictly conservative synagogues as well as in the houses of prayer of the most extreme so-called Liberalism, without being swept away by the indignation of the religiously feeling congregation?

Thus convenience is also the sole decisive ground that has hitherto kept the majority of Jews in the German Empire away from Zionism — a convenience whose effects were all the more disagreeable because the Jewish philistine, above all, will not take the trouble even to acquaint himself with Zionism and its aims. Whether this cowardly fear of perhaps having to think came from the rabbis down to the people, or whether the rabbis are simply, on the whole, no better than their congregations — to decide that would require an extensive labour; enough: rabbis and congregants are worthy of one another, that is, in the majority of cases they are thoroughly Jews-of-convenience.

This fear of having to think about things that do not even bring in money characterises most of the opponents of Zionism in Germany. So it is only natural that they put their heads together to whisper to one another, with self-importance and secretiveness, what dangers Zionism may harbour in its bosom. If one asks wherein these dangers consist — what the calamity is that threatens from the Basle Congress — then again the sole, often quite earnestly urged, rejoinder is that Zionism is far more dangerous than antisemitism. "Why?" "How so?" To that no answer is given, for there is none; and even from the pulpit, whence the catchwords "Zionism… antisemitism… danger" resounded, no explanation was given except that Zionism is the highest of dangers. And our poor philistine souls let themselves be frightened like little children, who in the dark fear most that danger of which they notice nothing.

Some braver souls, to be sure — who are perhaps even capable of hearing a sermon to the end without falling asleep, and therefore may also know how much irresponsible stuff is offered up there in the name of religion and enlightenment — are gradually beginning to ask what Zionism really is; while younger elements, especially of the academic circles, have in the university towns already become widely acquainted with the national-Jewish world of ideas, and now, in consequence of the so highly regarded Zionist Congress, have the opportunity to speak of Jewish matters in their circles.

Thus the Zionist Congress of Basle — and, indirectly, the notorious Rabbis' Declaration too — has given occasion for Zionism to become a subject of conversation in wide Jewish circles, especially west of the Elbe, where Jewish feeling and general culture were always more strongly represented; and so the opportunity is offered it of gaining entrance for its truths among the indifferent Jewish mass, that is, the falsely so-called great middle party. This by far largest majority of German Jews — who cannot be called poor, but to whom no all-too-great share of the luck-purse of the late Fortunatus has fallen either — is beginning to let itself be set in motion by the Zionists. During the antisemitic attacks they were able to observe that those circles which, on account of their money, "act as though they were Pinto of Amsterdam,"*) never had anything to spare for Jewry, while they constantly did their utmost to expose the Jews as a whole. The Jewish middle class wishes to emancipate itself from the leadership of these elements, and no longer lets itself be held back or even scared off from Zionism by their exclusive class interest.

All the greater, naturally, is the anxiety of those gentlemen whose business it is to shriek out into the world each week that the Jews are German-national and cosmopolitan. It seems, to be sure, that German-national and cosmopolitan generally count as opposites; but not in the organ of these gentlemen, the "Mittheilungen aus dem Vereine zur Abwehr des Antisemitismus."

This little sheet, namely, with the long name — which is meant to serve as a scarecrow against the antisemites, but which, as is usually the case with such scarecrows, impressed and worked only so long as it was quite new — takes pleasure, among its Jewish subscribers (readers it has but few, Christian ones none at all), in making propaganda for the Social Democratic party, even if the gentlemen in the Magdeburger Straße have hitherto not found the courage to say openly what they secretly agitate for. The greater now the advances of Zionism, the more the "Mittheilungen" with the long name feel their business threatened, and so it comes about that they shun no means that might serve to cast suspicion on the hated movement and to represent it as a danger to German Jewry. Admittedly they have never yet brought a single word about what Zionism really wants, for they neither know it nor wish to know it; but that does not prevent them from devoting the greatest part of their paper not to combating antisemitism — which they have, moreover, never seriously combated — but to combating Zionism. The column "Zur Abwehr" now serves only this purpose. Against this conduct it is the duty of our Berlin like-minded friends to step forth openly. Should the "Mittheilungen" bring no honest retraction, then one must not shrink from inaugurating a defence against this "Defence."

Precisely as a consequence of the Basle Congress — which, after so many centuries of passive history, was the first public manifestation of a newly beginning active history of Jewry — the mood necessary for national-Jewish propaganda has risen in Germany to such a degree that it would be a never-to-be-repaired sin of omission were one now to fold one's hands in one's lap. Above all, on the basis of the Basle Programme and of a special action-programme to be resolved upon for Germany, the Berlin Zionists should organise themselves uniformly and at once step before the public with a mass meeting, in order to protest energetically against those shameful attacks.

*) A saying among the West German Jews.