Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 20 · 15 October 1897
6printed page
scan 10 of 20
Facsimile · scan 10 of 20
Scan of p. 6
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 20.

(continued from page 5)

…has flared up between the radical and Jacobin Republic on the one hand and the liberal, progressist one on the other. "It would lead to nothing," said the Minister of the Interior, "to conceal that the differences which divide the Republicans from one another will henceforth bear less on questions of execution and of tactics than on the principles and doctrines themselves."

The antisemites — I speak of those of parliament — such as d'Hugues, the Abbé Guérand, and so on, belong to the extreme Right. They too are revolutionaries, although their revolution is quite distinctly to be distinguished from that of the extreme Left. The Socialists see the evil in the dominion of capital; the antisemites pretend to find it in what they call the Jewish-Masonic dominion. The former see the remedy in the social revolution. The latter find that it will suffice to confiscate the property of the Jews in order to bring about the general welfare in France. The final aim of the one as of the other is revolution: the social one for the one party, the antisemitic one for the other. The antisemites tell themselves that it is they whom a revolution would benefit, while the Socialists in turn cradle themselves, for their party, in the same hopes. Meanwhile Socialists and antisemites make pacts with one another. But since they are a minority in the country, they united of their own accord with the great radical party. This showed itself at the time when the Radicals were at the helm. The radical party strives not after a revolution but solely and only after radical reforms. It reckons, however, with its forces, and knows that without the alliance with the extreme parties of parliament it will always be numerically weaker than its adversary, the party of the Moderates, which is supported by the Right.

Yet the alliance between Radicals on the one hand and Socialists and clerical antisemites on the other has so far manifested itself in France itself only a single time in an electoral contest — as is well known, at the election of a senator in Bordeaux, where the socialist candidacy carried the day against the moderate one. Is it now to be expected that this example will find imitation at the next elections for the legislative bodies? — I do not know.

But what has so far not been realised in France is already a fact in Algiers. There Radicals and Socialists form a single great antisemitic party, which stands in struggle against the opportunist party. The antisemitic party does not dare to call itself by its true name, in view of the fact that one finds oneself on essentially Semitic soil. It has therefore given itself the name of an anti-Jewish party.

And why, then, have the Radicals become antisemites? The matter is exceedingly simple. Because the Jews side with the Moderates. The party of the Moderates is certainly in decline in Algeria. Perhaps, too, it is ill represented in parliament. But here it is not a question of the causes of the decline of any political party in Algeria. It will suffice for us to content ourselves with the statement of the fact. What we can say with sufficient certainty is this one thing: that the struggle against the Jews of Algeria would at least lose its savage character if the Jews were to vote for the Radicals. But can we demand of our brothers in Algiers that they go over into the radical camp? Are we then sure that they would not, the moment they swing about in this way, have against them the party of the Moderates — that is, the party which at present is in possession of power in France? Can we assert that the liberalism of the Moderates will not permit them to become antisemites? And the Radicals? Does their radicalism, perchance, prevent them from being the most vehement antisemites? And then.

Who knows, then, whether the moderate party will not, in a few years, when it is better represented, regain its influence and its former political standing? Can one require the Jews to change their party allegiance from one day to the next?

However one may look at it, then — the situation of Algerian Jewry is truly a tragic one. If it is allied with the Moderates, it has the Radicals against it; if it holds with the Radicals, it will doubtless have the Moderates against it.

The Jews perceive that in Algeria they are treated as foreigners. There lies an irony of a truly cruel kind in this title of foreigner that is applied to the Jews of Algiers. It is not yet 70 years since Algiers became a French colony, whereas the Jews, according to the testimony of historians, have dwelt there since time immemorial. But the Frenchman is the victor, and might goes before right. That is such a theme for reflection as one might commend to our Jewish anti-Zionists.

If the French treat the Jews as foreigners even on African soil, how much more will it be so in France itself, when the political situation shall create for the French Jews the same insoluble problem! Well then! The struggle between the radical and Jacobin Republic, of which I have spoken above, could bring the Jews of France into the same situation as that of the Algerian Jews. Oh, there is nothing at all impossible in this hypothesis.

— That is sufficiently proved by the stance of the Radicals of the capital against the Jews of Algeria. Have not the radical journals said that the Crémieux Decree, which emancipated the Algerian Jews all together, was "a historical error"? And the Radicals of parliament? Were they not the ones who proclaimed the same opinion from the tribune of the Palais Bourbon? And did the government itself perhaps protest against the words of the Radicals, against those words which concerned the Jews and the Crémieux Decree? When I speak here of Radicals, it is not a question of the representatives of the extreme views of radicalism. The anonymous author of the daily political essays in the "Eclair" is a former president of the municipal council of Paris, a Radical of the moderate tendency. It is he who is perhaps the most decidedly and clearly hostile of all toward the Algerian Jews. Did not, at last, after the debates on the Jewish question that took place in the Chamber of Deputies in the year 1895, this very author write an article in a sense rather unfavourable to the Jews, in which he too imputed to them that they were the greatest holders of unlawfully acquired capital, and that the people would yet demand an accounting of them? Shall we still make mention of an article by François Coppée, who poured out a flood of unjust and unjustifiable abuse upon the head of the Algerian Jews, and did not therein omit to add that he was by no means an antisemite?

"The situation of the Algerian Jews," said a Jewish journalist, "deserves our attention not only because it is our duty to defend our brothers in this French colony, but still more especially because it can be a useful warning to us French Jews. If we take into consideration the deeds of the antisemites down there, we can gather from them what awaits us in France on the day when our enemies shall have attained their goal."

What our excellent co-religionist did not say is that the political situation in France shows the very same symptoms as that in Algiers — that in consequence this "useful warning" has an all the more significant importance