Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 17 · 24 September 1897
5printed page
scan 9 of 20

No 17. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

On my return from Basle to Amsterdam it struck me as odd that so little publicity should have been granted to a Congress which had drawn the attention of the whole world upon itself. — Nevertheless the faint echo which had penetrated hither had not been without effect. At first I doubted whether this were mere curiosity or genuine interest. But last Monday evening I found a proof that in that secluded land the seeds of Zionism must be present, for in the most important journal I read the long letter of a "Netherlandish Jew" who addressed an "earnest" appeal to his brethren by no means to forget their loyalty, and after all not to take part in a movement which the writer calls a "stillborn child". I believe I may assume that this letter comes from the Chief Rabbi of Amsterdam, since one of the members of his family belongs to the editorial committee of the paper, and and moreover the letter was written in a tone which plainly betrayed a leading. personality in the community. To seek to demonstrate the misfortune of such a stillbirth is a ridiculous undertaking; the letter shows rather a knowledge of the state of affairs and a certain fear of the near future. One cannot assert with certainty that a Zionist movement already exists in Holland, but I can notify it, for the use and benefit of every fellow-labourer in our work, and this should receive attention, that the possibility of a Zionist movement exists among the numerous Jewish adherents of Multatuli, the great leader of Dutch Socialism. Their Jewish feeling is thus far very weak; they are unhappily wholly taken up with the Communist movement, and shut off from every Jewish influence from abroad. One, indeed two of them, whose personal acquaintance I enjoy, admitted to me that the humanitarian side of the Zionist movement touches all Jews, yet they cannot conceive of a Jewish movement without ritual polemics.

J. de Haas.

An American View.

Taking as its basis an interview which the Vienna correspondent of the "New York Journal" had with Dr. Herzl, an American review publishes a detailed article upon Zionism, from which we take the following noteworthy passages. We reproduce them because they illustrate the practical manner in which our American friends approach the matter. We need hardly tell our readers that we are not in agreement with these arguments of the review. They are set forth here merely as a contribution to the discussion, which daily assumes an ever greater compass.

"The mass executions of the Armenian Christians by Turks are still a proof that the Turks carry on proselytising with the brutal force of the sword. And with so fanatical a people Doctor Herzl would enter into relations under international law, in that he would not only settle Jews there against an annual tribute of 500,000 to 5,000,000 dollars, but would also expose them to all the terrors of a proselytism by the power of the sword. From this catastrophe the Jews can be protected solely by giving up the idea of a "Jewish State in Palestine" and regarding Palestine only as a cradle in which Israel passed its childhood. For now the whole world is the Palestine of the Jews, appointed thereto by their religion, which all the leading nations have adopted — with the exception of the sin-offerings.

We hope that the Zionists will give up the idea of founding a Jewish State and will recognise the tendency of our century, namely the absorption of the small States into the greater empires or republics; for only then shall we attain to a universal republic, in whose midst all nations and religions will disappear and be replaced by a universal brotherhood, where every man will take part in the government of the people according to the measure of his capacities. To bring in these fair days is the duty of every Jew, wherever he may live.

The formation of a Jewish State in Palestine would hinder the attainment of this great aim. If the Turkish Government should find new resources opened to it in the two million Jews and in the yearly 5 million dollars, then the Turks would again come forward in the old fashion as conquerors and proselytisers, and would murder the men and drag the women and their children into slavery in order to convert them to their faith. The Jews must not give occasion to such a movement. Let the idea of the settlement of Palestine be laid aside, with all its delusions and sentimentalities. Instead of this, let the two million Jews be led to agriculture; that would be a gift of God for them, who amid the concentration of capital can so hardly help themselves. It is clear that the concentration of capital and the number of new inventions do not diminish but rather increase, and with this increase it becomes ever harder for the poor Jew to live. Israel's hope is not Palestine; Israel's hope is agriculture on the great scale, where success would be permanently assured and where they would no longer stand in anybody's way.

The earth, when well tilled, is the mother of riches; it secures to every family its own home. Sun and rainfall are not held back by brick and mortar, and the children are not exposed to manifold temptations, as in the crowded tenement barracks of the great cities. The working of the soil is the happiest and healthiest occupation of man. Moses, the great leader and lawgiver of the people, understood this rightly and ordered the calling of the people accordingly. The settlement of two million Jews as independent farmers should be the task, and their praiseworthy endeavours would be supported by all the Jews of the whole world. To this end we recommend to the Zionist Congress the election of an Executive Committee, consisting of 4 members, with its seat in Vienna or Berlin. This Committee is to possess complete freedom of action; it is to appoint a committee for the purchase of land — at least 1 million acres are to lie together — in fertile regions and such as lie in the neighbourhood of navigable rivers. This land is to be leased for a certain number of years, with the right of purchase.

Forty million acres of fertile soil might be procured in the various parts of North America, of Canada, at the price of 25 cents to 1 dollar per acre. These forty million acres would, on the day when the colonists gather in the first harvest, be worth 10 dollars per acre, and would thereby create four hundred million dollars for 400,000 families, of whom each would have a definite share, ever increasing in value. Each family would receive only 100 acres allotted to it for tillage, and a special law would have to provide for careful and intensive cultivation. The roads would have to be shaded with fruit-trees, and the care of these would be entrusted from generation to generation to the women and children.

A Finance Commission will have the task, so soon as the necessary lands are discovered, of creating the corresponding basis for a loan among those who support the movement, in order thereby to obtain the ready means.

The 400,000 families require 400,000 horses, oxen, cows apiece, 800,000 sheep and 2,000,000 fowls and geese. For this purpose committees must be established in various places for the receipt of gifts to this end.. It would be an honour for every Jew to contribute according to his means. The cattle thus given to the colonists would have to be returned by them in the same number and quality within 7 years, so as then to pass to other colonies.

The committees for the reception of the colonists must be called into life everywhere. Only healthy men and women,