Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 15 · 10 September 1897
15printed page
scan 19 of 20
Facsimile · scan 19 of 20
Scan of p. 15
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 15. — "Die Welt" — Page 15.

(continued from page 14)

...a fitting reply in the "Times" from Chief Rabbi Dr. Gaster. He came forward as a decided Zionist and an orthodox rabbi, in order to tell the English, as the only competent person to do so, how matters really stand between Orthodoxy and Zionism. He closed with these words: "One thing is certain: the whole of orthodox and believing Jewry, which does not do violence to the words of the Prophets, and does not regard the divine promises as mere symbols that anyone may interpret at his pleasure, is now assembled in spirit at the Congress and follows its deliberations full of sympathy and hope."

The "Times", as well as the other daily papers (the "Daily News", "Pall Mall Gazette", "Daily Chronicle", etc.), have reported in more or less detailed telegrams upon the course of the Congress proceedings. They gave their reports the fine and fitting heading "Palestine for Jews" (Palästina für die Juden). The Congress in its entire course has been described at greater length by the English-Jewish papers (the "Jewish World", "Jewish Chronicle", and "Jewish Express"). All three were represented by special correspondents; the "Jewish Chronicle" sent no fewer than two. In the editorial articles we find, besides this, reflections upon the Congress.

The "Jewish World" is very well satisfied with the results of the Congress. "Whatever the practical results of the Congress may have been, it remains an epoch-making deed in Jewish history... That this Congress came about without the support of the recognised Jewish organisations and without the help of the small but powerful Jewish plutocracy; that this Congress brought together workers of hand and of mind, orthodox and doubters, who nevertheless proceeded with a wonderful unanimity — that must be to every impartial man an object of the highest attention."

The "Jewish Chronicle", which next to "Die Welt" gave the fullest report of all the papers, is somewhat more reserved in its reflections. It is hard, after all, to find a thing white to-day which one decried as black but yesterday. Still, it makes concessions. "We have already said that the Basle Congress was not unfruitful. The spirit which animated Herzl's speech, his appeal to the Jews, could not but work deeply. But the programme adopted departs from the Jewish State.

If Zionism desires for the Jewish people a legally secured home in Palestine, then all Jews are at one with the Zionists. The Jewish colonies in Palestine must remain unmolested. We are likewise on Dr. Herzl's side when he wishes the question of Zion to be treated publicly."

The "Jewish Express" gives as its leader an article upon Dr. Herzl.

French Papers.

Having returned from Basle, I at once set about collecting and classifying the most important French newspapers which had published articles or entrefilets upon the Zionist Congress. I lay before you the results of my small labour.

In the first place one must note the opinion of the serious organs of French public opinion. The "Journal des Débats" has occupied itself most thoroughly with the Congress, while the "Temps" gives itself the air of not listening particularly closely. The "Temps" has indeed printed the telegrams reporting upon the labours of the Congress, but thus far we find no judgment upon the work begun. Must we wonder at this? By no means. Silence is the wisdom of kings, and everyone knows that the "Temps" regards itself as the king of the moderate press in France.

Less circumspect are the "Debats". Besides the daily telegrams they contain an article of their own upon the Zionist idea and a correspondence from Switzerland upon the Congress. The article comes from the pen of Mr. Maurice Spronck, one of the principal contributors to that academic paper.

Mr. Spronck, who is a Parisian spirit, begins of course in an ironical tone, which, however, he very quickly abandons in order to speak in full earnest. He finds that the attempt of the members of the Basle Congress is in truth exceedingly interesting. Whether the undertaking succeed or fail, the mere fact that it was attempted seems already a phenomenon lying outside the customary. And there is really something wonderful in the vitality of this little people, which after nearly two thousand years of dispersion, oppression, and misery, still cannot resolve to die and does not despair of recovering its lost nationality.

But Mr. Spronck asks himself whether the Jewish people will ever attain to the realisation of its dream, and he raises certain objections. Among these there is one that is untenable. The author of the article says that the soil of present-day Palestine recalls the fabled fertility of the Promised Land only very remotely. That is not correct. The agricultural colonies of Judea and Galilee have already formally refuted this assertion. Mr. Pierre Loti maintains, it is true, in his well-known book upon Galilee, that it is a dying land and that one must make haste to go thither if one would still see it. But is it not singular that this worldly academician traversed Galilee without seeing even one of our colonies, since he mentions not a single one? Yet it is impossible, by whatever road one roams the country from Safed to Banias, not to remark at least Rosch Pinah, which lies upon the highway itself, and indeed upon a fairly lofty point of the mountain slope of Canaan. Despite these objections, however, Mr. Spronck finds that the initiative which Dr. Herzl has taken deserves to arrest attention and is worthy of the sympathy of all.

The Swiss correspondent of the "Journal des Débats" contents himself with simply stating that the Zionist Congress has produced a very considerable impression in Switzerland and has aroused very lively sympathies. The whole correspondence is couched in very well-disposed terms. The writer rightly emphasises that the Zionist idea recruits its adherents chiefly among the democratic and popular elements of Jewry. Against anti-Semitism unleashed the Zionists would set the national restoration of Jewry. The Basle Congress was therefore a genuine raising of the standard against a resigned or self-satisfied Jewry.

The boulevard papers have also occupied themselves with the Congress and the Zionist idea, and that very vigorously. You know that the "Echo de Paris" and the "Journal" despatched special reporters to the Congress. In the "Echo de Paris" the well-known chroniquer Henri Fouquier devoted an article to the idea under the title "The Kingdom of Zion". As a boulevardier, Mr. Fouquier treats the question superficially enough. He finds, for example, that anti-Semitism is a fire of straw already all but burnt out. Notwithstanding this, Mr. Fouquier's article is quite well-disposed towards the thought. Being a sceptical spirit, he doubts the success of the idea. Yet he says that he comprehends the dream of a people which desires to find itself again, to rouse itself, to have its national life and its resurrection. "Here", he writes, "I am almost a Zionist, although of Helleno-Latin and Christian race. It seems to me that, were I a Jew, I should wish to have my house about Jerusalem, that I might go to the walls of Solomon and weep ..."

The "Figaro", on the other hand, has taken up an ironical, hostile attitude. Mr. Emil Beer, the Israelite editor of the "Figaro", was charged with writing an article upon the Congress and the Zionist idea. I well comprehend the embarrassment of my excellent co-religionist. The Israelite editor of the "Figaro" leans, moreover, upon the Israelite press of France, which likewise treats the Basle Congress in a disdainful, mocking tone.

These gentlemen of the Israelite press are, for the rest, very much to be pitied. They are worthy people, but what would you? "One does not make a newspaper out of what one loves,