(continued from page 7)
...Organisation is the proof of what is reasonable in a movement. Here, however, is a point which cannot be worked out clearly and vigorously enough. We Zionists desire, for the solution of the Jewish question, not an international association, but only international discussion. The difference is for us of the highest importance, as I need not first expound to you. This difference also legitimises the convening of our Congress. With us there can be no question of petty leagues, secret interventions, and by-ways, but only of a candid deliberation under the constant and complete control of public opinion. It will be one of the nearest successes of our movement, already perceptible in broad outline, that we shall transform the Jewish question into the question of Zion.
So great a popular movement must be taken hold of from many sides. The Congress will therefore also occupy itself with the intellectual means for the revival and cultivation of Jewish national consciousness. On this point too we have to contend with misunderstandings. We do not dream of surrendering so much as a foot's breadth of acquired culture; we think rather of a further deepening of culture, such as all knowledge signifies.
For the rest, the intellectual life of the Jews has, as is well known, at all times left less to be desired than that of their bodily activity. This the practical forerunners of the present Zionism perceived when they began to call a Jewish agriculture into being. Of these attempts at colonisation in Palestine and Argentina we all can and shall never speak otherwise than with sincere gratitude. But they were only the first word, they are not the last word of the Zionist movement. This must be greater, if it is to be at all. A people can help only itself; if it cannot do that, then it simply cannot be helped. We Zionists, however, wish to rouse the people to self-help. In doing so no premature, unsound hopes shall be awakened. For this reason too a publicity of treatment, such as our Congress aims at, is of high value. Whoever considers the matter calmly must yet say to himself that Zionism cannot attain its end in any other way than by an unreserved understanding with the political factors concerned. The difficulties attending the right of colonisation were not, as is well known, first created by Zionism in its present shape. One must ask oneself what interest the tellers of such fairy tales really have. The confidence of the Government with which one wishes to negotiate concerning a settlement of Jewish masses upon a large scale can be gained only by open speech, by a loyal procedure. The advantages which an entire people is able to offer in return are so considerable that the negotiations are from the outset invested with sufficient seriousness. In what legal form the agreement shall finally take place — to speak much of that to-day would be an idle undertaking. One thing only is to be held inviolably fast: the basis can be only a condition of right and not of sufferance. With toleration and with the protected-Jew status revocable at pleasure we have by this time had experience enough.
Our movement has consequently a reasonable character only if it strives after public legal guarantees. The colonisation hitherto carried on has attained what, upon its plan, it was able to attain. It has established the much-disputed fitness of the Jews for work upon the land. It has furnished this proof, as it is termed in the language of the law, for perpetual memory. But it is not the solution of the Jewish question, nor can it be in its present form. Neither has it — let us openly confess it — met with any considerable response. Why? Because the Jews can reckon; it is even asserted that they can do so too well. If now we assume that there are nine millions of Jews, and that colonisation should succeed in settling ten thousand persons yearly in Palestine, then the solution of the Jewish question would take nine hundred years. That looks impracticable.
But you know that the figure of ten thousand settlers a year is downright fantastic — under present conditions, that is. At such a figure the Turkish Government would at once revive the old prohibitions of immigration — and that would suit us exactly. For whoever believes that the Jews could, as it were, smuggle themselves into the land of their fathers, deceives himself or deceives others. Nowhere is the appearance of Jews so quickly signalled as in the historic home of the people, precisely because it is the historic home. Nor would it lie at all in our interest to go thither prematurely. The immigration of the Jews signifies an influx of strength of unhoped-for abundance for this now poor land, indeed for the whole Ottoman Empire. His Majesty the Sultan has, moreover, had none but the best experience of his Jewish subjects, even as he is to them a gracious sovereign. Conditions therefore exist which, with a prudent and happy handling of the whole matter, may lead to the goal. The financial assistance which the Jews can offer to Turkey is not inconsiderable, and would serve to remove many an internal evil from which that country now suffers. If a portion of the Eastern question be solved together with the Jewish question, this is assuredly in the interest of all civilised nations. The settlement of the Jews would probably also be a bettering of the position of the Christians in the East.
But it is not from this side alone that Zionism may reckon upon the sympathies of the nations. You know that in many countries the Jewish quarrel has become a calamity for the Government. If one takes the part of the Jews, one has the excited masses against one. If one takes part against the Jews, this has, owing to the peculiar influence of the Jews upon the traffic of the world, often grave economic consequences. There are examples enough of it. If, finally, the Government remains neutral, then the Jews see themselves without protection in the existing order and take refuge in subversion. Zionism, the self-help of the Jews, now opens the way out of these manifold and singular difficulties. Zionism is simply the peacemaker. It fares with it, to be sure, as it commonly fares with peacemakers: it must do the most fighting. Only if among the more or less honest arguments against our movement there occurs also this, that we shall be charged with a want of patriotism, then this suspicious objection disposes of itself. Of a complete exodus of the Jews there can nowhere be any question. Those who can or will assimilate remain behind and are reabsorbed. If, after a proper agreement with the political factors concerned, the Jewish migration begins in all order, it will yet last for each country only so long as that country wishes to give up Jews. How is the outflow to come to a standstill? Simply through the gradual abatement and final cessation of anti-Semitism. So do we understand, so do we expect the solution of the Jewish question.
All this my friends and I have often said. We will not let the labour of saying it again and again, until we are understood, grow irksome to us. Upon this solemn occasion, when Jews from so many lands have come together at a call, at the ancient call of the nation, let our confession be to-day solemnly repeated. Must not a presentiment of great events pass over us when we reflect that at this moment the hopes and expectations of many hundreds of thousands of our people rest upon our assembly. To distant lands, aye, across the ocean, the news of our deliberations and resolutions will speed within the next hour.
Therefore shall enlightenment and reassurance go forth from this Congress. Everywhere men shall learn what Zionism, which has been taken for a sort of chiliastic
