No. 9. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
… that is, from the 6th to the 11th of November 1884, such an assembly was held, calling itself the Delegates' Assembly of the "Chowewe Zion," at Kattowitz, O. S. Unhappily this "Congress" — a name perhaps better suited to the thing than that of Delegates' Assembly — appears to have fallen into forgetfulness even among the Zionists, and it must be recalled to memory all the more loudly and lastingly, inasmuch as the continuity between the Then and the Now must be preserved and insisted upon with the utmost decision.
But over against the above-named declarants there come into consideration also the men who at that time attended the assembly, or else furthered and approved it by word and by pen. I will name but a few: Rabbi Jizchok Elchonon Spector (Kowno), the honorary president of the assembly by right of age, Rabbi S. Mohilewer (Bialystok), Rabbi Dr. J. Hildesheimer (Berlin); then the distinguished president of the assembly, Dr. Pinsker (Odessa), the scholar S. J. Finn (Vilna), Professor H. Graetz (Breslau), the editor A. Zederbaum (St. Petersburg), the poet L. Gordon (St. Petersburg), Dr. Rabbinowicz (Paris). Which of all those named above may dare to set himself at the side of such men, heroes of faith and of learning.
I know well what you will answer: Yes, that was then; but the present generation, these youthful hotheads and hotspurs and their ideals, are surely of quite another sort than the endeavours of those noble, sober men, grown grey and aged in the service of the faith and of Jewish learning. That may well be. Yet you ought to have considered that even to-day there stand hundreds beside, before and behind these young men who are no worse than those of that time, at the hour of the first Zionist assembly. Hundreds of older men who also have a word to say, and to whom the young in Israel will gladly subordinate themselves.
"Hail to our young, they put not our old to shame!" They have taken up the great Zionist idea with all the freshness and warmth of youth and have given it expression after their own fashion: that is altogether natural and self-evident, and can only redound to the advantage of the good cause. There, where youthful enthusiasm and the considered circumspection of age join together in a common noble and laudable work, there may yet something fruitful be brought to pass.
You say in your declaration:
- The endeavours of the so-called Zionists to found a Jewish national State in Palestine contradict the messianic promises of Judaism as they are contained in the Holy Scriptures and in the later sources of religion.
Such a word plainly signifies nothing but insinuation, quibbling, sophistry and false doctrine. The object is to stir up against the hated Zionism the mob, that mammon-worshipping, self-seeking and pleasure-seeking orthodox and neolog mob. Zionism is at last charged with wishing to found the Jewish national State. If the thing could be done so lightly, why not indeed! and if our young men, who after the manner of hot-blooded youth would gladly leap over the intermediate stages in order to reach the goal quickly, speak with enthusiasm of a projected State of the future, who will hold it against them? In the end they will surely have to yield to the better insight that is directed upon the attainable.
But to you, and above all to you who count yourselves of the orthodox party, I put the question: Do you not likewise believe in the future restoration of the Jewish State? Say you yes! Well then, you do not differ greatly from our young Zionists. Whether this restoration be hoped for at a nearer or a remoter time is no great difference. If it be hoped for at all — the nearer, I should think, the better.
But say you no! Well then, be pleased no longer to reckon yourselves among the orthodox; be pleased no longer to give the lie, before the all-knowing God, to your faith, your hopes, and all your prayers. That would indeed be the worst of all hypocrisy and blasphemy.
To this a twofold answer may be made on your side: The one party say, we await the personal Messiah, whom we shall follow through thick and thin, even to the re-erection of the Jewish State. He alone has a right thereto, and not you. — The others say, we do not believe in a personal Messiah, and accordingly not in the restoration of the Jewish State either — we believe only in the messianic character of the Jewish people in the midst of all the other peoples of the world.
Granted, both granted! But to you also who appeal to the personal Messiah we reply: Who tells you, then, that this Zionist movement is not called to prepare the ways for the coming Messiah, to labour before him and to make ready his work of redemption, according to the word of the prophet: "A voice crieth in the wilderness, prepare ye the way of the Lord, make level in the plains a highway for our God. Every valley shall be exalted, every mountain and hill shall be laid low, and the rugged shall become a plain and the broken ground a level place. And the glory of God shall appear, and all flesh together shall behold that the mouth of God hath spoken it." If you do not awaken him, the coming man, he will not awake; if you do not prepare his ways, he will not come; if you do not make ready his work for him, he will not be able to begin it nor to accomplish it; who then can know whether this Zionist movement be not the beginning of that messianic time which God has promised us by the mouth of the prophets?
But to you who will not believe in the personal Messiah, and who would transfer all messianic promises and missions to the people of Israel, we reply: What is it that you want! Thereby you have surely conceded our principal demand, the recognition of the folk-character, of the Israelitish nationality. Not the people, you will say, but the faith. No, friends, the faith has fulfilled its task; it has brought to the world one God and one morality. Our people, however, as a people, has yet a great mission to fulfil, both with regard to itself and with regard to the world. Its mission towards itself is an eternal one, which can never be extinguished nor lost. But the world-mission of our people as a people seems only now to be becoming a present concern, since men have set about repairing all the great economic, national and social ills of the world. In this direction there appears to be set for our people a task as great and as significant as that which once fell to its religion. Were it not for the great and exalted mission of our people as a people, it would truly not be worth while in these days to live as a Jew and to endure all these revilings, incitements, calumnies and denials of right. If you, our opponents, think otherwise upon this, we know very well why.
When you set forth a possible founding of a Jewish national State in Palestine as contradicting the messianic promises in the Holy Scriptures and in the later sources of religion, that is simply untrue. It is wholly incomprehensible how men who subscribe to such an assertion can still count themselves among the orthodox. I set over against you dozens of the greatest authorities of Judaism, who will convict you of untruth and of unbelief. You entrench yourselves perhaps behind imputations and false accusations against the Zionists; but would that not be a procedure which mocks all truth, justice and legality?
You say further:
- Judaism obliges its adherents to serve with all devotion the fatherland to which they belong, and to further its national interests with their whole heart and with all their powers.
What is that to mean? Is that perhaps meant to be one of those base denunciations which accuse the Zionists of loving their fatherland less than you do? To your honour I will
