Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 5.
(continued from page 3)
…Councillors do indeed still speak of assimilation. People still speak to-day of Liberalism, of Manchesterism as well. But no man in the world will take to-day's Liberalism seriously. The Manchester men of to-day are but petty epigones, apers of that copyist Bastiat. The assimilationist Jews are the Jewish Manchester men; they are the Bastiats of Geiger and of Holdheim, those classics of the Jewish assimilation movement.
Assimilationist Liberalism is dead, just as its stepbrother, economic Liberalism, is dead. One should not mock the dead, says the Talmud. We too will leave these dead in peace.
Now let us pass over to our opponents standing farther to the left.
How do the Social Democratic Jews stand towards Zionism? It is hardly open to doubt that the great number of adherents of Social Democracy among the German Jews is to be ascribed to the dominion of Anti-Semitism and to the setting back of the Jews in the public life of Germany. Germany's Jews form about 1 per cent. of the total population. The number of proletarians among the Jews of Germany is a very small one. But from the fact that in those countries where the Jews are, as in Germany, well-to-do, yet at the same time in civil respects wholly equal in rights (England, Italy, France), the relative number of Jewish Socialists is quite small, we may draw the conclusion that the Socialist consciousness of the Jews in Germany is not the outflow of their proletarian-social, but of their Jewish race-proletarian-social position.
The Jews in Germany — the Social Democratic ones at least — thus possess a dim consciousness of their Jewish race-proletarian position. Only they are not yet Zionists, perhaps because they doubt the practicability of the Zionist plans and therewith hold an emancipation of the Jews to be possible only in the Socialist society. But perhaps they are also not Zionists because they have had no occasion to become acquainted with Zionism. Zionism is a Jewish-proletarian phenomenon. It arose among the poor Jewish population of Russia, Poland, Galicia and Roumania. Among the well-to-do Jews of Germany it has not thus far taken proper root. The Jews living in Germany, who belong to quite another "class" than the Galician or Roumanian Jews, could therefore have had no notion of Zionism.
And the Social Democratic Jews of Austria? The "Socialist" Jewish merchants of Vienna, who voted Liberal in the second curia and Socialist in the general curia, we cannot take seriously. They voted for the Social Democrat because they did not want the Christian Socialist. The same may be said of the Socialist-voting traders, hucksters, chafferers and so forth of Cracow or Lemberg. We pass on, then, to the Jewish Socialist party leaders, to the Jewish Socialist "intelligence" of Galicia.
Here we have two groups to distinguish. The first group consists, no doubt, of such men as are not averse to Zionism, and who coquet with Socialism only because they hold a complete emancipation of the Jews to be possible solely in the Socialist society. That is a standpoint about which one may dispute. We believe, however, that this standpoint is more an anarchist than a Socialist one. The Anarchists set their hope upon a sudden transformation of the social order; of a gradual development and of a social policy they will hear nothing. The Jewish Socialists will likewise acknowledge no "Jewish social policy." We Zionists say to ourselves that so long as the Jew lives in modern conditions he cannot and will not alter his economic mode of life. Every man earns his bread as it comes easiest to him. The Jew is, in the field of commerce, shrewder and more artful than the non-Jew — he becomes a workman only where he has a still shrewder competitor, when he emigrates to America or England. Neither can the Jew become a workman in Galicia, for apart from the necessary Sabbath labour — and the Galician Jew will not for a long time yet profane the Sabbath — there is no industry in the land and he therefore finds no work. The Galician Jew is thus compelled to be a vegetating pauper. We Zionists will not wait for the Socialist society, but will help the Jew even now to give up his hitherto mode of life and himself produce goods — and for that reason we Zionists believe that we represent the progressive element.
We come to the second group. This second group consists of young people who, remarkably enough, find the Polish-national consciousness perfectly in order, but designate the Jewish-national as something bourgeois in kind. Some two years ago there appeared in several journals essays upon Zionism. The gentlemen held themselves entitled to denounce Zionism as a bourgeois movement. Remarkably enough, the same gentlemen found it, a few weeks later, compatible with their "proletarian" confession to pose as defenders of the Polish-national idea. We have nothing to object against any national movement; we should only wish that the gentlemen Poles "of the Mosaic confession" would at last say to themselves that what is right for them is fair for us as well, and that they ought not to meddle in our Jewish-national affairs. But since the gentlemen have once provoked us, we will indeed see what manner of intellectual offspring these Poles "of the Mosaic confession" who call themselves "Socialists" are.
Is the conception "Pole of the Mosaic confession" a proletarian conception? No. The mass of the Jewish people in Galicia is Jewish and not Polish. "In Galicia, where the Poles form the ruling element, the number of assimilated Jews, for whom a special designation exists as 'Poles of the Mosaic confession,' amounts to barely 0·37 per cent. of the entire Jewish population."*) The Poles of the Mosaic confession are in Galicia the bourgeois, the court Jews of the Schlachta, the advocates, the physicians, the bankers, the landed proprietors and so forth. The going over to Polishdom "of the Mosaic confession," in Eastern Galicia at least, is the proof of a lackeyism towards the ruling class, for in Eastern Galicia the working peasant population is Ruthenian and only the Schlachta is Polish. Why, then, have we thus far heard of no Ruthenian "of the Mosaic confession"?
As Poles of the Mosaic confession the gentlemen have therefore no right to call themselves representatives of the proletarians. Are they, perhaps, by their individual position in society, proletarians? By no means. They are students, physicians, advocates and so forth — men who already draw a handsome income or may hope for a good one. Is the class, perhaps — the Jewish class — from which they spring, a proletarian working class in the strict sense of the word? That neither. The number of Jewish workmen in Galicia is but a small one. The mass consists of petty-bourgeois paupers. The economic conditions for the rise of a Socialist consciousness among the Jews of Galicia are not present, and, as we have already intimated above, these economic conditions will not be able to be created under the present circumstances.
We have thus far touched only the economic side. But there are also — we must say with Eduard Bernstein**) — "motives that stand higher with man than the flatly economic," and we can only agree with Kautsky when he says "that the national idea is not yet overcome."***) We Jews have the same feelings of nationality and of honour as the other peoples. We will no longer be house Jews or protected Jews of this or that party, but will apply our best powers to becoming independent. That we hold to be the solution of the Jewish question.
*) "Neue Zeit," 1893/94, No. 37, page 332.
**) "Neue Zeit," 1896/7, No. 266.
***) Loc. cit.
