No. 2. — "Die Welt" — Page 15.
That which England and France did in the fourteenth century, Spain in the fifteenth, Russia in the nineteenth?
It is for those peoples who favour the second method to consider whether the example of Spain deserves imitation from the standpoint of pure utility; but suppose that, in defiance of all historical experience, they repeat the imprudent attempt — what then?
Here Disraeli's admonition to the nations ends, and his — Zionism begins. The poem "Tancred," with the sub-title "The New Crusade" (1847), is as little unified and rounded as Disraeli's whole nature, and whoever would extract the innermost tendency of the work must again attend to incidental matters and side remarks that easily escape notice. The admonition to the Christians Georg Brandes has summed up briefly and aptly in these words: "If you were consistent, if you believed in earnest what you always profess to believe, then you would act in the mass as enthusiastically, as naively, as devoutly, as madly as my hero. And if you were truthful, then you would concede, as he does, that you owe to the Jews and to Judaism all your most precious jewels, and you would, like him, hold them in honour instead of despising and persecuting them. But you are neither consistent nor truthful, neither devout nor enthusiastic; you are one and all philistine nationalists, and since you do not dare to confess it, try your teeth upon my book."
But the work is not written for the Christians alone; here again Brandes has misjudged Disraeli's relation to the Jewish question. Tancred, the scion of a ducal family, and therefore a "born leader," despairs of his fatherland, which seems to him to have lost everything — faith, truth, love . . He seeks light in this darkness, he thirsts for a new revelation. And there is but one place in the world where God has revealed Himself to men, the place upon which the patriarchs, the prophets and Jesus walked.
Tancred goes, a modern crusader, to Palestine, there to learn the truth concerning things divine and human. His wish is fulfilled. First an angel in the shape of a Jewish maiden reveals to him the origin of the Christian religion and of modern culture; then there appears to him in a vision the genius of the Semitic world, proclaiming the gospel of a return to the simplicity of ancient Jewish national life — therein lies Europe's future and the healing of modern society. The equality of all men before God — that is perhaps the most concise formula into which one could compress Disraeli's theologico-political tract, for such is "Tancred."
But if this remedy is prescribed for all Europe, it has of course its first and foremost application to the Jews, who are the readiest disposed to employ the medicine with success. The Jews, in their overwhelming majority, have forgotten neither their old God nor their old equality; they have therefore nothing new to learn. The formula of equality before God, which for Christian Europe means a veritable horse-cure — for never yet was European society so divided into castes as in our own time — is for the Jews the most natural and easiest means in the world. Upon one condition — that they be permitted to go their own way upon their own soil.
And how does Disraeli think upon this question, which contains the kernel of all problems touching Judaism?
Clearly and plainly, not through the mouth of a poetic figure but in his own name, he states it in a terse epigrammatic form that sounds almost like a motto for the Zionist movement of our day.
The vineyards of Israel have ceased to exist, but the eternal law enjoins the children of Israel still to celebrate the feast of the vintage (Tabernacles). A race that persists in celebrating its vintage, although it has no grapes to gather, will regain its vineyards.*)
Was Disraeli in earnest with his Zionist ideas? He has so often been reproached with frivolity, and not always unjustly; he so often treated the parliamentary government of England as a comedy, and himself played therein the part of first comedian. But never yet has anyone called in doubt the sincerity of his views regarding the Jews and their future; and if further testimony were needed, Beaconsfield's great opponent Gladstone — assuredly an unimpeachable witness — has furnished it in the tart censure: "Disraeli has taken only two things seriously: his wife and his race."
And have Disraeli's Zionist thoughts an authoritative significance?
Nearly two decades have passed since the Conservative party in England lost its creator and leader, and yet his memory is as living as ever in both camps of the parliamentary host. And for good reasons. If the Marquis of Salisbury commands to-day a majority such as perhaps no English Prime Minister ever possessed before, he owes it to the principles of his master, which he made his own hesitatingly and unwillingly, but afterwards followed the more zealously; if all England, England in the widest world-embracing sense, prepares to render Queen Victoria a homage unique in the history of that happy island realm, then those who know — the Queen first among them — know also who reared this monarchical sentiment in a people that in the thirties and forties, when Victoria began her reign, was filled with radical republican ideas; if England now sets about securing to the peasantry a new significance urgently demanded by events, this is done in fulfilment of a wish which Disraeli bequeathed to his party; and if finally, on the 22nd of June 1897, men of every colour and costume appear before the British throne, and it is shown to the Queen before her very eyes that the sun does not set upon her empire, then everyone knows to whom the Empress of India owes the unity and solidity of that vast edifice of state.
Benjamin Disraeli's political ideas have, like the prophecies of a seer, become truth and reality in a comparatively short time.
The prophecy also that the Jews will regain their vineyards moves towards its fulfilment.
*) The vinegards of Israel have ceased to exist, but the eternal law enjoins the children of Israel still to celebrate the vintage. A race that persists in celebrating their vintage, although they have no fruits to gather, will regain their vinegards. Tancred II, 152 (Tauchnitz Edition).
The World of Books.
The National Regeneration of the Jews. An economic study by Max Jaffe. Berlin, Hugo Steinitz, publisher. The little book, which is quite agreeable reading, brings the Zionist reader nothing new. Nevertheless the author at once wins our sympathy by the sober clarity with which he grasps modern Zionism, and by the convincing force of expression with which he dismisses every objection. Even though we cannot assent to Jaffe's view that the Jewish question is an economic question of power, we must yet note with approval that Jaffe is a modern Zionist who pleads for State-Zionism. Worth reading, too, is the rebuff he administers to the mission-Jews. We gladly recommend the book for purposes of agitation. Sch.
To Our Readers!
In one of the next numbers of "Die Welt" we begin the publication of an interesting series of articles by the architect
Oskar Marmorek
under the title:
"Building Ideas for Palestine."
The Editors.